Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

The D word

who's talking here?

Donny 1
QT 6
Allison 1
Barbie 1
BellaLaVie 1
YouReallyThinkSo 1
Mom25 1
Vod Kaknockers 1
Momma2Fur 1
SoonToBeJD 1
kristin40 1
shizzlemydizzle 4
GardenWitch 1
Clinical Depression 3
Champ 4
JMoney026 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

QT --- 14 years ago -

So my friend is going through a divorce because her husband cheated on her. I don't really know what to tell her, and she keeps bringing up some things that I am not sure how to answer. Help?
1. If the other woman involved is a marine as well, can only she get charged, or would both her husband and the WM be charged? I told her I thought it was command discretionary, but I'm not sure.
2. He said he would take care of her no matter what, but she wants to make sure she protects herself. After how many years is she entitled to benefits? I thought it was 5, but I don't know.

Please don't be catty on this. Thank you for any advice you may have. 

Clinical Depression --- 14 years ago -

She is entitled to zero military benefits; per military you have to be married at LEAST 20 years with 20 years of military service to receive full benefits, or married 20 years with 15 years of service to receive partial benefits. Married 10 years with 10 years of service to receive retiree pay.

She will only receive 1/2 BAH until the divorce is final. If she wants alimony she needs to go through the STATE, however, in most states to automatically get alimony you need to be married 10 years. Under that is not guaranteed. Alimony is taxable income, as it's also deductible on his taxes. 

BellaLaVie --- 14 years ago -

in most states to automatically get alimony you need to be married 10 years. Under that is not guaranteed.

That's what I've heard as well. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

my mom got medical (until she remarried) and 1/3rd of his retirement pay with cost of living increase. They were together 15 years of his service (he early retired at 18)and was already retired when they divorced. Once she remarried she lost medical, but still recieced 1/3rd retirement pay. So that pretty much says what clinical depression stated.

I've heard people say after X amount of years you can keep benefits for as long as you were married while serving, but I have absolutely no idea if that is true. After you're officially divorced you get none of his BAH as that is his "entitlement" for serving, not a "benefit".

My husband always jokes around about after 10 years I own his soul, but I don't think he knows of anything, but rumor mills. 

QT --- 14 years ago -

Thank you.
I told her that if he did promise to take care of her no matter what, then they should go through a mediator and have it in writing, with an amount, bills, etc.
I don't know.. this situation sucks. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

Oh yeah, and if I was her I wouldn't go anywhere near that female Marine area. If she's punished he will be punished more than her, which could result in loss of pay which kind of affects her if he says he'll be taking care of her... I'd remind her, "your husband is the one who cheated on her, not the female Marine." 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

Thank you.
I told her that if he did promise to take care of her no matter what, then they should go through a mediator and have it in writing, with an amount, bills, etc.
I don't know.. this situation sucks.


people always have their best intentions when they hurt someone they love, but even if she got something in writing through a mediator, a few years later it'd be easy as pie for that to be reversed. (O don't think you said how long they've been married, but unless he's a millionaire no judge is going to equal 2 years of marriage to taking care of a grown women for the rest or very long of her life. 

kristin40 --- 14 years ago -

What she receives will most likely depend in the judge. Are there kids involved? 

Momma2Fur --- 14 years ago -

in most states to automatically get alimony you need to be married 10 years. Under that is not guaranteed.

That's what I've heard as well. 


That's usually the case, but in more than a few cases I've seen it granted for marriage in under 10 years for half the time the couple was married. So a 3 year marriage could get 1 1/2 years alimony. Not sure how it works though. I know it happened to my FIL, and they had no kids or communal property together. 

Allison --- 14 years ago -

I got alimony from my ex for 3 years for a 4 year marriage because of our judge and my lawyer. My ex stole my car (during seperation) so i had no way to get to my job and i got fired. there's very few short marriages that get alimony but some do. Like if they've let you live a certain lifestyle without having to work it could depending on the judge. 

YouReallyThinkSo --- 14 years ago -

It all depends on the circumstances. If she has money get a lawyer if not tell her to go to base legal and be the first one there. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

Alimony is becoming less and less common, especially when there are no children involved.

No children = able to support self without the expense of childcare. 

QT --- 14 years ago -

No there are no kids involved. Only their dogs, which are like their kids.

I think they have been married for 5-7 years. He's been in 10-12 years.

She does not work, but takes care of everything.. and I mean everything!!!

She literally does not spend a dime because she makes sure he is taken care of 200%.

She is a full time student, and is a FRA (why she doesn't work).

All the bills are in her name, and she wouldn't be able to pay them, hence why she wants to make sure she is "secure" in some way.

I told her she needs to get to legal first. But they were talking about mediation?? I also said not to bother with the chick's command because it could affect her future as well.. (financially)

I just feel bad for my friend and don't really know what to tell her. Thanks for all your comments. 

QT --- 14 years ago -

Question, since there is adultery, isn't he guilty and she should be granted what she wants? (not sure if I worded that correctly)
Honestly, It's really not a lot that she wants. She just wants all the bills paid and him to help her with rent for a studio or 1 bed apt while she finishes school and finds a secure job. And also she wants to still have medical/insurance incase of an emergency. That one I really have NO IDEA about!! 

Vod Kaknockers --- 14 years ago -

Question, since there is adultery, isn't he guilty and she should be granted what she wants?

It depends on the state they get divorced in, CA is a no fault state so it doesn't matter that he cheated (if they go through CA).

And also she wants to still have medical/insurance incase of an emergency.

It wouldn't be TriCare but she could have him pay for it, if they can actually come to an agreement. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

Question, since there is adultery, isn't he guilty and she should be granted what she wants? (not sure if I worded that correctly)
Honestly, It's really not a lot that she wants. She just wants all the bills paid and him to help her with rent for a studio or 1 bed apt while she finishes school and finds a secure job. And also she wants to still have medical/insurance incase of an emergency. That one I really have NO IDEA about!!


That is actually A LOT! but she's better off staying married to the piece of work he is, and just not taking it seriously until she finishes school because once he gets a gf he won't want to give her anything... but she should get a lawyer (a real one, not base legal) 

Clinical Depression --- 14 years ago -

Again, even being married 5-7 doesn't meet the 20/20/20/10/10/20/15 rule because they weren't married for at least 10 years of his 10-12 year career. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

No judge is going to grant her medical or make him pay for it, once the divorce is final.

She could use the adultery card to get him to fork over some help in paying for rent.

If the debt was incurred during the course of the marriage, they'll split the debt down the middle, even if it's in her name only. All she has to do is prove it was incurred during the course of the marriage and both benefitted from the debt. He'll owe half and she'll owe half, again, unless she can try to pull the adultery card without actually dumping his career down the toilet. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

Oh, and what does FRA mean? 

QT --- 14 years ago -

Oh, and what does FRA mean? 

She's a FRO assistant/ Family Readiness for the battalion he husband works at 

Clinical Depression --- 14 years ago -

Family readiness assistant.

Again, she gets 1/2 BAH until the divorce is final; with 10/12 years he has to be a SGT/SSGT, which is easily $1,000+.and if his contract is up soon her alimony joy will be cut short once he gets out.

She retaliates to get him in trouble she is jeopardizing the amount she gets. 

QT --- 14 years ago -

Thanks CD 

Barbie --- 14 years ago -

She could use the adultery card to get him to fork over some help in paying for rent.

It's a pretty hard card to pull, I've seen a lot of guys get away with cheating because it's "he said she said bs". She needs proof to really get her any where. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

I'm not saying report him to command, use it as a "bargaining chip" - she keeps his dirty little secret and return, he agrees to what she wants.

Medical, however is off the table. If she's divorcing him, doesn't the FRA go out the window anyway?

She'll just have to get a job. MANY college students work while going to school. School isn't an excuse not to be able to support herself. 

GardenWitch --- 14 years ago -

Adultery is not grounds for divorce in California, all she can really do is hold it over his head to get everything she wants IF she has proof.

At 7 years I actually had to sign something waiving my right to his retirement. He cheated so I didn't sign it until I had everything I wanted in the divorce papers and he didn't contest it. 

Donny --- 14 years ago -

All the bills are in her name, and she wouldn't be able to pay them, hence why she wants to make sure she is "secure" in some way.


It doesn't matter who's name is on what if the debt was acquired during the marriage the law considers it community property and both parties are responsible to pay the debt. So if they acquired $10k in credit card debt during the marriage even if the credit card is in her name only he's still on the hook to pay $5k of it.

The only thing that doesn't get split 50/50 are any assets acquired prior to the marriage or once a legal separation is in place those items or debts become the sole responsibility/property of the individual. 

JMoney026 --- 14 years ago -

she will receive 0 benefits, as soon as the divorce decree is given, her benefits stop 

SoonToBeJD --- 14 years ago -

I'm not saying report him to command, use it as a "bargaining chip" - she keeps his dirty little secret and return, he agrees to what she wants.

That's essentially blackmail... 

Mom25 --- 14 years ago -

Agree with Donny on assets and bills...that is fairly standard. If she goes the mediation route, she needs to bring all the bills and assets of the marriage to the table. Copies of debt contracts etc.

Although it is tempting to report him for cheating. I would advise to only use it to persuade him if talks were getting out of hand. A no fault State is just that. My ex had numerous affairs, which I could prove...in the end it does not matter. You try to agree on how to split the assets, put it in writing. If you cannot agree, a court decides for you.Without kids this is fairly simple.

Whatever they agree to in mediation gets the seal of the court after. This is a way to keep court and attorney fees down for both parties.

She needs to look into the costs of medical coverage for herself, as that benefit will go away. Her FRA position, is that through MCCS? GWOT funds pay FROs but they hire through MCCS, she may be able to transfer to another MCCS position and get some benefits. The package offered by MCCS is very similar to the TriWest coverage.

I would advise she seperate any joint accounts if she fears he would run up debt, that said, a court will consider when debts ocurred when splitting them, but that area gets sticky and costly. Protect what you can until the divorce is finalized. The same advise for him. Debt incurred after legal seperation is established, is not split.

Alimony may be granted if she has no skill or education due to being at home, following his career. For example, if a SAHM has the ability to make 45K a year in the current market, her child support would be set with her contribution to the formula being 45K...alimony the same. If she expects alimony, mediation may not work.
Base legal takes the first spouse to request. A good family law attorney is worth the costs when kids are involved, but without kids, she could go Pro se (represent herself) yourself. In that case, his attorney or the court would file everything and charge her a fee for the filing. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help
marriage

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground