Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What are your thoughts on housing changes?

who's talking here?

Mrs Patch 4
CourtesyFlush 8
cindy 9
laneys mommy 1
IamtheWalrus 2
*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* 1
LakerGirl 2
***C+J*** 2
Just Sayin 1
Trace 7
Housewife Say What 3
AINOKEA 2
Smile 2
Maddies Mom 2
Murphy 9
SuKitty 1
Ella Mafayo 2
skysmommy 2
rxpryncess1 2
Turquoise 1
xVivaLaDollx 1
TeenySurfer 1
Bugbite 2
Doo Schnugget 2
LullabiesButterflies 2
Elizabeth M 1
a3526660uu 1
CuteCurlyC 1
SecretSquirrel 12
3myboys 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Trace --- 15 years ago -

What are your thoughts on housing changes since housing became privitized?

A friend of mine is married to someone in the Army who is fresh out of training. They moved to their first base and they are going to be moving into a 4bdrm home thats supposed to be for E5 and above. They have one child.

One benefit that used to go with rank was nicer/bigger homes. That doesnt seem to be the case anymore. I kind of find it sad, I don't know why. I really feel a lot of newer enlisted military and their families feel entitiled to big/nice/new houses. What are your thoughts? 

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

That isn't fair. I heard that e3 and below is going to start receiving a portion of their bah back too if they live in housing. Why didn't they do that when my hubby was e3? 

Smile --- 15 years ago -

I already get bah back So I am good.

But I don't know anyone upon camp Pendleton who is an e-3 living in e-5 housing or wig one kid and 4 room. 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

heard that e3 and below is going to start receiving a portion of their bah back too if they live in housing.

Is this EVERY E3, or is this kickback you're talking about still reserved for those that live in Serra Mesa? 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

But I don't know anyone upon camp Pendleton who is an e-3 living in e-5 housing or wig one kid and 4 room.

I have noticed CP sticks to the "rules" more. The housing website even says the house she's moving into is for E5-E8. I would imagine she is easily moving into a 4bdrm because of the area. I bet most E5-E8s are buying since house prices are cheap.

I guess its just odd for me. I remember when I first got married we lived in a 1 bdrm apartment. Our kitchen was the size of a closet. lol. 

AINOKEA --- 15 years ago -

I've asked to live in a smaller house.. lol. I mean I love my house. We don't live in an area that we're not rated for. I don't know though. I know I would feel odd living in a housing area where everyone is a higher rank than my husband. 

Elizabeth M --- 15 years ago -

I think it depends, if you live somewhere that is taking away full bah you should get a bigger house. growing up living on military bases the advantage was usually that you got a bigger house which isnt the case anymore 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

I've asked to live in a smaller house.. lol. I mean I love my house. We don't live in an area that we're not rated for. I don't know though. I know I would feel odd living in a housing area where everyone is a higher rank than my husband

That would be odd for me too. We moved into a housing area that they were changing ranks from E6-E9 to E1-E9. My husband was the first E3 and it felt odd. We were living in a 2bdrm though. If I were her I'd live off base and pocket the extra money since her son is so young. But that's just me :). 

Maddies Mom --- 15 years ago -

At the base I was stationed at (AF) my friend got there as an E-3 and had a 3 bedroom, 2 bath with a big fenced yard. Our BAH there was only $1200. Not privatized. Her house is bigger then my E-5 husbands 2 bedroom here with no yard. 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

I have a question, which may sound kind of silly. My husband is an E-5 and we live in a 2 bedroom in Santa Marg, but we are waiting to see if he gets selected for E-6 in Sept. I was curious, do we have to move into a 3 bedroom? I honestly hate moving period. I like my house and it's not like we are having more children so there is really no need for the extra room. Could we just stay here and maybe keep the extra BAH that he would get if he does end up getting promoted? 

Maddies Mom --- 15 years ago -

I highly doubt it. 

SuKitty --- 15 years ago -

You can stay there but you won't see your bah. 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

You can stay there but you won't see your bah.

Eh, I don't really care about the BAH, I just really hate moving and like I said we don't need the extra room. 

LullabiesButterflies --- 15 years ago -

I hate this about housing! It's so completely unfair. And I agree, it does make a lot of the young families feel really entitled. I think that the housing companies care more about having houses filled and getting their money than they do about following the rules. And if they are going to make it like a true rental community they truly should make a set rent price for each home based on what it's worth and what the military members should be able to afford. That way, if pfc schmuckatelli and his 4 kids live in a nice 5 bd in wire mtn 2, they might have to pay a little above their bah, and the msgt who lives 2 blocks away would get a chunk of his bah back. That way they could keep the smaller, older homes for the low ranks and the bigger new homes for the people who have been in longer. Because it's just not fair that someone pays $1400 a month for a house and someone who's been in longer might be paying $2200 a month for a smaller house just because they chose not to have kids or can't have them. Ugh, sorry, I could go on about this forever. Lol 

Ella Mafayo --- 15 years ago -

I'm an old salty wife and I've lived under both "regimes," so to speak. LOL! I will agree that the privatized system has some great benefits...believe it or not, the housing wait list is GREATLY streamlined because they turn these houses around SO FAST. Back in the day, I'd watch a neighboring house sit empty for over a month while the maintenance office dragged their feet getting it turned around.

The move-out system is a VAST improvement over what it used to be. You young'ins hear jokes about "white glove" inspections, but that was darn near true once upon a time. They didn't just come in and take 5 minutes glancing around. It would be an hour long inspection, and they'd look to see that you cleaned behind the fridge, in the cabinets, and in the tracks of those nasty sliding glass shower doors! Their version of "improving" this process was that you could leave a $350 check with the housing people and you you hired one of their "approved" cleaning services. They wouldn't pay the cleaner until the house passed inspection, and meanwhile, you could be on your way. I always found this shady, though. I worked at the temp lodging for a while at MCAS Beaufort, and people would be held up for DAYS trying to clean a home themselves to pass inspection. They'd come back having failed 3 or 4 times, and finally end up shelling out the $350 for a pro cleaner. Seriously...I thought it was a dirty kick-back system! So, being able to walk out of the house without going out of pocket for cleaners or busting your hump for DAYS is NICE!

Maintenance is a vast improvement too, believe it or not. I used to wait DAYS for simple repairs.

However, I think we're sacrificing things like quality construction and rank-privilege in housing size. There's definitely no consistency there. Our walls in Quantico were so shoddily insulated that you could hear me unrolling toilet paper in the master bathroom from out in the garage...and the bathroom didn't directly share a wall with the garage. My girlfriend lives in enlisted housing in Miramar - hubby's a Gunny - in a ginormous, brand new 2500 sq ft home. My husband's a Captain with 20 years in, and we're in a ghetto-fabulous 1500 sq ft home with blue stains in the shower and paint droplets all over the linoleum. Drop the rank snobbery and ask...who's getting more for their BAH? 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

My girlfriend lives in enlisted housing in Miramar - hubby's a Gunny - in a ginormous, brand new 2500 sq ft home. My husband's a Captain with 20 years in, and we're in a ghetto-fabulous 1500 sq ft home with blue stains in the shower and paint droplets all over the linoleum. Drop the rank snobbery and ask...who's getting more for their BAH?

Personally, If I were you'd I'd live off base because I wouldnt want to pay that much for so little. lol. But I agree, it has gotten crazy. My husband has been in for a while and when we lived in hawaii it wasnt privitized. We had a house from the 60s that was infested with everything, but at least it was sturdy. lol. 

Smile --- 15 years ago -

I would like the idea of them opening housing up to all and setting rent that you pay monthly. So if you want the bigger house fine but it costs more and you will be paying out of pocket for it. 

TeenySurfer --- 15 years ago -

I think everyone should receive the same house no matter how many kids they have, or what rank they are.

It's ridiculous that you all think because you have kids or a husband that is higher ranking you deserve a better house than other people. I understand it's like this in real life (people who make more money, have nicer things obviously.) But why can't you guys be thankful for what you have and stop complaining about what it used to be like? Things change, get over the fact that you don't get $$$ back on your BAH, and that people do now. It sucks, but get over it, that's life! 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

Was any one complaining about their house? I must have missed that... 

3myboys --- 15 years ago -

"It's ridiculous that you all think because you have kids or a husband that is higher ranking you deserve a better house than other people. I understand it's like this in real life (people who make more money, have nicer things obviously.) But why can't you guys be thankful for what you have and stop complaining about what it used to be like? Things change, get over the fact that you don't get $$$ back on your BAH, and that people do now. It sucks, but get over it, that's life!"

Why should someone getting $2400 in BAH taken out receive the same house as someone getting $1400 in BAH out? In town you get what you pay for, so why should anyone be entitled to everything new and big on base just because they are a marine. Surely if you received $1400 in BAH and couldn't live on base for some reason and had to live in town you wouldn't be entitled to getting a $2400 house because you couldn't afford it! Yes things change but it's called taking advantage of people too.

PS....Not saying this is you specifically, just saying hypothetically! 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

$2400 in BAH taken out

Why would anyone who's entitled to that much in BAH even live on base? That's my question. lol 

cindy --- 15 years ago -

Its stupid to get housing for how many kids you have. I hate when I hear wives complian about housing. I understand if its about mold, and insects, but most complain about dumb stuff. If your spouse is a e5 you deserve better housing than a e3.
In the "real world" people who receive a pay raise have better houses then the ones who are low income. 

3myboys --- 15 years ago -

$2400 in BAH taken out

Why would anyone who's entitled to that much in BAH even live on base? That's my question. lol


Personally, I say the same thing! But there are plenty who do! 

SecretSquirrel --- 15 years ago -

When my husband was an E3 we lived in condemned housing that had sludge growing outside, frequent gas leaks, only 1 working stove burner (the housing budget for non emergency repairs was always gone) and asbestos flooring. Move out inspection back then included having the stove dismantled into a bunch of parts lined up along with every light cover in the house for inspection.

Privatizing housing has been a very positive change. One of the biggest changes is that the wait time has been drastically diminished due to the increased amount of housing units and the much quicker turn around times for maintenance. 

SecretSquirrel --- 15 years ago -

I think everyone should receive the same house no matter how many kids they have, or what rank they are.

Military members overall tend to lean towards the right and probably , in general, aren't too much a fans of socialism in any form. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

It's ridiculous that you all think because you have kids or a husband that is higher ranking you deserve a better house than other people. I understand it's like this in real life (people who make more money, have nicer things obviously.) But why can't you guys be thankful for what you have and stop complaining about what it used to be like? Things change, get over the fact that you don't get $$$ back on your BAH, and that people do now. It sucks, but get over it, that's life!

I didn't see anyone complaining about their house. I just think it's a little sad that making rank isnt what is used to be anymore. My husband isnt high ranking by any means.. I guess we are just old and miss the good old days when we had something to look forward to when my husband made rank. 

IamtheWalrus --- 15 years ago -

It sucks, but get over it, that's life! 

Why should someone getting $2400 in BAH taken out receive the same house as someone getting $1400 in BAH out?


I kinda agree with both sides..
But if it bothers you so much do something about it. Obviously some lower ranking guys did something about their situation and got their way. 

Ella Mafayo --- 15 years ago -

Why would anyone who's entitled to that much in BAH even live on base? That's my question. lol 

Well, I can only answer for myself, and that answer is that moving from one end of the country to the other makes it hard to shop for rentals. We decided we would NOT buy anything out here because this is not going to be our forever home. We already own a home in NC that we are renting out. And we considered a plan of "just take what's available, and then shop for rentals as we get to know the area" but once we settle in and start forking over that BAH, it's very hard to come up with a lump sum of nearly $5000 to cover deposits, first month's rent, etc. 

3myboys --- 15 years ago -

"It sucks, but get over it, that's life!

Why should someone getting $2400 in BAH taken out receive the same house as someone getting $1400 in BAH out?

I kinda agree with both sides..
But if it bothers you so much do something about it. Obviously some lower ranking guys did something about their situation and got their way. "

Actually it doesn't bother me that much since we have our own home that we bought. We did something about it, thank you very much. As for the guys who got their way, it just is usually the ones who feel entitled and whine and moan about everything thinking they're above following the rules. Karma always comes around though. So in my book, they may live there but they sure as heck don't deserve to. But hey life goes on and quite honestly I'm content with and proud of what I have because everything has been honestly earned. 

CourtesyFlush --- 15 years ago -

Why would anyone who's entitled to that much in BAH even live on base? That's my question. lol

Ours is in that range, but we just aren't ready to buy, and it was just easier to move into base housing and not have to worry about utilities, etc. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground