What exactly is the difference between saying "you black people" and "black people?"
I would think if it is offensive it is equally offensive. Both are identifying and lumping people together. Right? How is only saying "black people" more correct than putting a "you" in front of it?
I mean really when someone says "black people" the "you" is implied anyways. I really don't see it any different than if someone says "country singers" or "you country singers." If you are in fact talking to a country singer lol. Right?
I would think when talking to someone about a race you would use the term "black/asian/white/latino" or what ever but when talking to someone and belittling them based on race, you would say "you black/asian/white/latino people". I dk... that would be my theory on it
"you black people" should be used when you're talking to black people. "black people" should be used when you're talking about them in general.
Same as if someone called me an effing cracker. Which would actually be quite hysterical since I'm pretty comfy with my whole whiteness thing... dunno about ya'll on that though.
I think maybe the way the person may say it.. maybe it might come off as more negative with "you" in front of it. No?
haha I have no idea. Thats why I asked. And when I read it, it didnt sound mean. It sounded like she was addressing the issue that was being discussed. Black people saying other's were racist. That they would need to prove it bc when "you black people" accuse people of racisim and it is unfounded, it looks bad. That's how it came off to me. I think the person just took offense bc it was not what she wanted to hear.
I think (and this is just my personal thoughts on what people are thinking) that saying "you" before a description implies that the person is making themselves sound like they are superior.
However, when I say "you kids are annoying the crap out of me" I mean no disrespect to their age, short stature, or lack of adult-ness. It is simply a statement to lump them all into one category of driving me crazy.
Therefore, it is my opinion that if someone were to say "you people..." they are just stating the fact that they are not including themselves into the category. I can see why it is offensive, but I can also see why it should not be taken offensively.
That did not help in any way, shape, or form did it?
I'm just curious why some people are so offended by what people say. If someone calls me a cracker, snowflake, honky....I just laugh at their ignorance and let it go.
I think it means the same, but the "you" just sounds worse.
(example...using a stereotype here..)
Black people like kool aid.
You black people and your kool aid obsession....
Its still rude and lumping people together because not all black people like kool aid. It just sounds worse when you put the "you" in front of it.
I personally try to not say "look at that black guy" or "that black chick is tall"....I try to just say "that guy" or "that girl" and if they can't see who I'm talking about I would say "the dude in the red shirt...he's black..do you see him." But I won't just right out say "that black dude" if I wouldn't just right out say "that white dude".....I wonder if "black people" (haha...can't believe I just said it...but I don't really know how to say it otherwise, unless I say "non-white people" which just sounds worse..) anywho, I wonder if they say "that white girl" LOL..
Because we are not discriminated on a daily basis, racial slurs are not as offensive. Its impossible to say what is or isnt offensive unless its you they are talking about.
I think (and this is just my personal thoughts on what people are thinking) that saying "you" before a description implies that the person is making themselves sound like they are superior.
No, its a group thing. Not superiority thing. Its like saying "all Norwegians"
That did not help in any way, shape, or form did it?
haha I guess. Still I would think that she would be equally offended by "black people" or "you black people." That's why I dont understand the correction of "please just say black people" or whatever lol. That was silly to me. Since she is black and obviously saying "black people" implies the you anyways lol. Oh well.
I"m not offend when people say black people, but when people say "YOU black people," it's usually followed by some kind of insult, which then gets black people upset. It's all in your word choice and how you use words. But the funny thing is that black people get so upset when other people(not black) use words that is considered racist, but when we are taking to one another(black to black) it's ok! I think it's time for all the words to die, it's sad that we are still disputing racism now!
OMG! I just thought of my grandma "Don't let any of those damn Pollacks come over here." Bwahaha! Grandparents say the darnedest things.
My grandma told me when she first came over to the US when she was 10 she had never seen a black person before. She ran home and asked her mom if she could bring her friend with the dark skin and white palms home to play....
Back home I got the.. "Oh she must be half Japanese". o___o I dont see it. Then when I got here, I get mistaken for being Hispanic (Of course I do have some Hispanic decent) LOL. Some of the girls I made friends with, forget that I am Filipina and would speak to me in spanish only to get a reply of "Uh.. X_X What?"