Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

OPINION: Too Young For An Email Acct?!?

who's talking here?

YouReallyThinkSo 2
puppylove 1
Mom25 1
Momma2Fur 1
MzMarineGirl 1
shizzlemydizzle 1
CharlieWhiskey2 2
accountnickname 1
LaLa 1
GardenWitch 1
alwaysright 1
Maleficent 1
Rainbow Dancer 4
RedBird 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Rainbow Dancer --- 14 years ago -

May I first start off by saying I’ve already discussed this matter with both mine and my daughters psychologists along with my attorney as well as my husband.

Long story short…
The father of my daughters has a mental health problem as well as a substance abuse problem that affect his ability to make appropriate judgment calls on our daughters over all well-being. He has been in this state while were married (2002) and continues to be this way to present day. With that, the judge has granted me sole physical and legal custody of our daughters. His visitation is 4 hours a week and must be professionally supervised. And all other communications with our daughters are to be recorded as he has a tendency of inappropriate communication (i.e. negative statements and exposing them to court papers/disputes).

Well come November he is getting kicked out of the military and leaving to South America, why he is leaving to South America?!? I don’t know and quite frankly don’t care. But he notified me that he made an email account for the girls to write him and send him pictures when he leaves. Grant it he gave me the address along with the password, I just don’t feel it’s appropriate for an 8yr old and 6yr old to have an email account. With his history, he can get upset very easily and I can see him changing the password to hide things from me. I suggested the girls can write him letters/notes/posters and mail it to him and that I would be more than gladly email him pictures of the girls and we still have telephones to where he can call them anytime from 5pm-7:30pm during the week and anytime during the weekends.

As stated earlier, I’ve already discussed this matter with mine and my daughters’ psychologists, my attorney as well as my husband. So I’m not looking for advice I’m looking for opinions!!

At what age is it too early or is it appropriate for children to have an email account??

Opinion = “This is what I think.”
Advice = “This is what I think you should do.”

I would especially like opinions from those who have children from someone else and are in the same/similar situation as me. 

accountnickname --- 14 years ago -

To me it's not just a question of having an email account, but also the opportunity for your girls to have unsupervised contact with someone with the history your ex has. IMO they are far to young for that at this point in time. For that set of circumstances I think they need to be able to be old enough to truly understand manipulation and whatever else they might encounter. I would say perhaps 16. 

Momma2Fur --- 14 years ago -

I think that is too young for a personal email account. At that age using a parents email address is sufficient to keep tabs on what's going on. 

Mom25 --- 14 years ago -

In this situation, I would use a personal account, created and maintained by you and only you. One, for both girls, for the time being. This way you can monitor and backup their exchanges as needed. We still monitor our 15 year old, even though she is a great teen and email exchanges were useful in court once. 

LaLa --- 14 years ago -

IMO
I would never give the girls the email information. Email address or password. I would either read the emails to them and type their responses myself. Or sign on the email for them. Monitor them as they read/type and then when they are done sign off the email. I would also check the content before and after each use. And save emails as they may be needed later. Thats just me. There are to many sick people out there. And with spam etc its so easy for children to be contacted. And you never know that your ex could be planning as far as trying to get them back. 

Maleficent --- 14 years ago -

I have an 11 year old with a father who is also incapable of making appropriate choices for her. If I were me even with them at that age, I would be okay with it under the strict parameters that the children CAN NOT access the account without you. I also would not allow them to read or see any of the email without me first seeing it. And it would be an account inset up, not one he set up. If they are always with you, there is no reason that they should be able to access it without you anyways. Good luck. 

GardenWitch --- 14 years ago -

If you are allowed to monitor/record legally, then absolutely no to the email accounts he set up. They shouldn't be using an account he can change the passwords, delete items etc. You have offered plenty of other satisfactory options.

You probably already have the legal right (under the supervision aspect) to read anything he sends before the kids see it? If it's anything you aren't sure about the kids seeing, just ask the therapist for her opinion. (Then you have a backup as to why you may have withheld anything.)

That's what we had to do with my ex. 

CharlieWhiskey2 --- 14 years ago -

I would monitor the e-mails. I would be the one checking them and reading them prior but other than that, I would have no problem. I have personally been in a situation where my father would tell us things that happened in court and I was in Canada so obviously I had a long distance father/daughter relationship with him and back then, it would have been much easier to keep in contact if I had had an e-mail account.
Change the password to one of your own liking and set it up on your phone. When you get an e-mail, read it and if it is ok, let your daughters respond. 

CharlieWhiskey2 --- 14 years ago -

P.S. Since he probably used his e-mail address as the secondary, you will need to get in the account info and change everything. Put your e-mail as secondary before you change the password because it will notify him and if you don't change the secondary to your's, he will be able to get a password by clicking that he forgot it and answering security questions 

shizzlemydizzle --- 14 years ago -

P.S. Since he probably used his e-mail address as the secondary, you will need to get in the account info and change everything

Changing the secondary account will also trigger a notification to his email account.

6 and 8 are too young to have an email account, but then again, the written word is better than having telephone communication. You can better control what transpires, than you can via the telephone. 

puppylove --- 14 years ago -

I had an email account at that age but I didn't have a person with history like that in my life. I think I would have them use my email account with supervision 

alwaysright --- 14 years ago -

i personally would NOT use the accts he set up. However, I would set up an acct my self for the children. I would always monitor it, and pre read everything that is sent and recieved. I think if it is handled properly between yourself and your ex that it could be a decent for of communication for your kids. I think it would also make it easier to keep tabs on anything he says does that he shoukdnt be telling the kids about. 

MzMarineGirl --- 14 years ago -

I think he is in no position to create any accounts on their behalf. You have custody of the children, you make the decisions. If it were me, I would create an account only for their conversations if they were to talk and or send pictures. I would not use the accounts he used, and would not provide him with any passwords, he doesnt need them.. I would only provide the email address where he can contact them and thats it. Don't leave it up to the child to have an account.. make it yours but for the kids. Meaning, they can make contact this way, but you monitor it, you log in, and dont give passwords to your child.. 

Rainbow Dancer --- 14 years ago -

Thank you for all the opinions and advice thrown in here.

We are all pretty much in agreement that in a sense its inappropriate.

As stated from the beginning I have already sought professional advice from mine and my daughters psychologist and my attorney at the time this situation arose.

What we had decided then was that the girls can write him letter, make him posters, etc. He can call mine or my husbands phone anytime during the week from 5pm-7:30pm and anytime on the weekends. As for email, no one is going to set the girls an email account, not I nor their father nor themselves. My 8 year old has an iPhone and I feel that with her having any email account access just throws red flags.

For those who suggested me screening the emails first, yes for a civil relationship that would be reasonable. But unfortunately, he has a history of abuse towards us. With that, I, personally, can't read text messages, emails, FCS reports nothing from or pertaining to him without my husband or someone else reading it first otherwise my anxiety will arise. Not to fret, this is why I see a psychologist who in fact also worked with domestic abused women. 

YouReallyThinkSo --- 14 years ago -

My oldest has a father who is very immature, a partier, does not think about if things are appropriate for children or not and we have had similar arguments. He believes my son should have a facebook page because its easier to communicate and share pictures is his reasoning. My son is 9 going to be 10 in a month. I dont think he is old enough for a facebook but if I was to decide he was and monitored it his dad would not be one of his friends. He post pics of chicks in barely any clothing, pics of him drinking and smoking, and his words follow the same format. Both my husband and I have him on our facebook page, for the specific purpose of pictures. I could careless what he does with his life as long as it doesnt affect my son. I set up a email address that only me and my husband have the passwords to for them to communicate back and forth. His father has sent him 2 emails and we have had this set up for almost a year. My son doesnt ask to email him, when he gets a message I read it first talk about it with my husband and than let him read it and he would respond. I would help him with the message, not telling him what to say but helping as far as spelling and putting what he wants into the right words. I say make your own account that you have all the information on and monitor it. If he is anything like my sons dad it sounds cool but they will eventually loose interest. Sad but true. My son also has a cell phone that we pay for and his dad has asked for the number more than once but I always say no. Any type of communications needs go threw my husband or I and be monitored. He had said once that he will just get him a cell phone so he can call and text whenever he wants. I said no to this also. I highly doubt he would of done it in the first place but someone who doesnt use good judgement and think about whats appropriate for kids and whats not does not need to have unmonitored contact with children, at least not mine. 

YouReallyThinkSo --- 14 years ago -

When he had brought up the facebook thing and I said no I gave him examples of his posts and how they are inappropriate for kids, one of them I used was referencing sex and how he needed some so he was going to go to the bar and take home the most wasted girl there and have a good time. I said how he was to young and doesnt need to be seeing that kind of stuff and his response was he has to learn sooner or later. Some people just arent born with that train of thought. At least thats what I tell myself, lol. You need to do whats best for your children and not there dad. Good luck 

Rainbow Dancer --- 14 years ago -

YouReallyThinkSo- Yup!! These two people are very similar. He actually blocked me from his FB bc I brought in screen-shots of his FB to court which is how I won one of my cases.

My 8yr old daughter as phone as well that my husband and I pay for. We got her an iPhone for the purpose that its easy to use and we can locate her at any time. As there were times when he had overnight visitation that she wanted to come home to my place and her father wouldn't let her contact me.

Her father did have her number but then him and his mother were contacting my daughter disclosing court information with their inappropriate opinions. So I immediately changed her number. *Knock-On-Wood* he has not yet asked for her number. But then again he hasn't seen them in over 2 months and probably isn't aware that she still has a phone. 

RedBird --- 14 years ago -

This is what I think, the parent should create an email address where it has the girls name combined where the parent not only maintains the email but reads the email's before the child receive's the email. Don't forget there is always snail mail that the girls can write him letters and send him pictures. I think it's a bad idea to link the childs iphone with the email address. You should be the first to read the email then have the girls read it. As soon as you receive the email you can forward it to either a friend or your husband to have him go over it before you go over it. There is a way to mark the email unread so that the girls feel like they are the first to read it. I see that you already mentioned that the girls could write him letters and make posters for him. It sounds like your doing all the right things here. I'm sure your doctor has told you this but the biggest key to these things is waiting to reply. If you ever receive something from him or if you decide to do the emails please wait and breath before you react. DON'T FORGET TO BREATH!!!!! Everyone's situation is unique so none of us have a clue what your going through and what you have gone through. Just know that whatever your doing, YOUR IN THE RIGHT!! I have respect for you to be so strong to go through this and I wish you luck with the future. Just don't forget to breath...... respond, don't react, and remember, try to remain calm. :) 

Rainbow Dancer --- 14 years ago -

I think it's a bad idea to link the childs iphone with the email address

I completely agree which is why I wouldn't want her to have any know-about of a "special" email or any email account for that matter for communication with their father.

I'm sure your doctor has told you this but the biggest key to these things is waiting to reply.


My psychologist indeed has told me this!! LoL, I've gotten really good at not responding immediately.If at all, bc most of the time its not necessary and I'm not about to open a door for him to attack me. So he communicates with my attorney :)

DON'T FORGET TO BREATH!!!!!

HAHAHAH!! Funny you mention that. I always have to remind myself that. Even my husband, whenever he sees me starting to stress out about something he stops me in my place, holds me and tells me to breathe.

Thanks again for the reminders :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground