Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

How different is the Navy?

who's talking here?

Donny 2
Skittles 1
laneys mommy 1
Trace 7
DocsWife 6
Texas10 4
tuckersmama 2
jtswify 1
HarlequinSoul 1
PODA PODA 1
DocsWife 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Texas10 --- 15 years ago -

My husband is currently in the Marines, but is considering switching to the Navy once his contract is up. Just curious from Wive's point of view is it any different really? 

HarlequinSoul --- 15 years ago -

ummm I know as far as differences between different branches, the Marines and the Navy are the most similar, since the Marine Corps is a department of the Navy, but other than that, I have no idea. I have been told that the Navy is more lax about the fitness requirements for their Sailors, but I have no proof to back that up. I know one Sailor, and he is not "fit" but he is also a data guy, so I know they have different requirements than other MOS's.

Basically, I am talking out of my butt, and I really have no idea X-) 

Texas10 --- 15 years ago -

haha I figured they were pretty similar, and If i were to give any advice on this subject I would be talking out of my butt too, so I getcha haha =] 

Texas10 --- 15 years ago -

Oh, and Are naval bases any different? I went to the Air Station in my hometown a few weeks ago, and it was a little different, and I got funny looks for Showing the Cashier at the commissary my ID..lol. 

Skittles --- 15 years ago -

A lot of the Marine bases have Navy there as well. My husband is a Marine but we're now stationed at a Naval Ship Yard on the east coast and it's tiny. The NX is the same size as a gas station. I haven't ventured into the commissary yet, but I don't have real high hopes seeing it's about 1/4 of the size of the one back in 29 from the outside.
He may want to make sure he's even eligible to transfer branches. I know quite a few guys that got out of the Marines and wanted to join other branches and they weren't taking prior service. 

laneys mommy --- 15 years ago -

I've been both LOL. I spent time in the Norfolk area as a navy wife. Its been a long time so some things change and it also depends on bases. But all in all I think its very different. I can't really explain everything but the people are really different. The Marine environment is much more uptight but much more squard away. But the Navy side had more fun. LOL

My Navy ex served both on a ship and on a staff command while we were married. Ship life sucked big time. Its not just the deployments that come in rotation every couple years. They are constantly gone for training and workups. In addition the ships have duty sections where the guys have to remain on ship for 24 hours. This was as little as every 6 days to as long as every 10 days. Our duty stations lasted 4 years where as my current husband (Marine) has 3 year duty stations.

Positive is when my ex deployed he was on a ship and not out in Iraq like my current husband. However (I'm old) he was deployed near the Cole when it was attacked and was off the cost of Kosovo during their conflict. Still I didn't stress near as much with ship deployment.

Love the Navy NEX's much better then the MCX. PT at least back then was much less for the Navy. Don't know much about Promotions. My ex was an A kisser and got meritorious and then went into the Seaman to Admiral officer program.

A big difference for me was location. But that depends from person to person for duty station.

The last differnce I can think of is communication. Ship communication was better then Iraq communication. LOL 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

it's harder to pick up rank in the Navy. mostly that's the only difference. personally I like the Naval bases better than Marine bases. I think the Navy gets paid a little more also. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

If he wants another branch I suggest the army. It's a tough time in the Navy right now. Between PTS, ERB and everything else they are throwing at sailors its getting harder and harder to stay in.

Ship life can be rough. My husband doesnt really mind it and I am used to him being gone a lot. My husband ususally had 2-3 underways a month which would last anywhere from 3 days to 3 months. It is hard to plan because schedules arent usually available too far out. They also deploy around every 18 months and right before deployments they are gone a lot. Ship deployments are 6-9 months. The good news is they have shore duty. Which is usually 3 years (after 4-5 years sea duty). And they usually don't deploy during shore duty. My husband has been tasked for 3 deployments this shore duty but every one of them ended up being canceled. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

it's harder to pick up rank in the Navy. mostly that's the only difference. personally I like the Naval bases better than Marine bases. I think the Navy gets paid a little more also.

The base pay charts are the same across the board. However, if your on a ship you get seapay. But you also lose your BAS (even when in port) so it usually equals out. 

jtswify --- 15 years ago -

My husband was in the Navy before coming into the Marine Corps. He said basically said the only difference is it's a lot harder to pick up. Of course the PFTs (PRTs for Navy) are different you have to run 1 1/2 miles and if you can't run you can swim. Also you have to take test for promotions and you have to have very high test scores.

FYI the Army is facing the same cuts as the Marine Corps they are currently not excepting prior enlisted. My husband called and my brother is an Army recruiter! 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

But you also lose your BASĀ 


BAH? you won't lose it if your married. 

Texas10 --- 15 years ago -

haha thanks everyone. He doesnt know if he is going to do it or not, just thinking about it. He's also thinking about re-enlisting with the Marines, just thinking of options, we have a few months to decide. lol 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

But you also lose your BAS


BAH? you won't lose it if your married.


No, BAS. If you are stationed on a ship you do not get BAS. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

FYI the Army is facing the same cuts as the Marine Corps they are currently not excepting prior enlisted. My husband called and my brother is an Army recruiter!

Army AGR is. AGR 

tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

bas: basic allowance for subsistence. its liek $160 a paycheck. its to pay for food but only for the servicemember not the family, thats why it goes away when they are gone for more than 30 days (woohoo im finally learning and dont have to be lectured about taking a links class) 

tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

oh and ive never been married to anyone in the navy but my dad was in for 20 years and from what ive seen navy families were less involved in the military life. maybe it was just my mom not wanting anything to do with it though. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

Okay, who is this other DocsWife?! ;) anyway, it depends a lot on the rating (MOS) how easy or hard it is to pick up. Corpsman have a difficult rate to advance in, but other ratings are much easier. I can't really tell you the differences though because I've never been a Marine wife.

ETA: this is a different DocsWife than the one posting above. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

Okay, since this other DocsWife registered it changed the capitalization on my name...mine used to be Docswife. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

ETA: this is a different DocsWife than the one posting above.

lol?

eta: if you click on your names you can see its too different people. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

from what ive seen navy families were less involved in the military life. maybe it was just my mom not wanting anything to do with it though.

I think it just really depends. I've noticed a lot of people like that around here (mostly the people that live in temecula etc.). I was involved but not overly. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

lol?

I know! Not to be rude, but I know that military pay is all the same based off rank, regardless of the branch. And I know what BAS is. She must be new to the whole life and still learning...of course, I'm always learning too. Those just happened to be things I know. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

eta: if you click on your names you can see its too different people.

I know, I just figured people wouldn't bother doing that and think I've gone off the deep end ;) you can also see on the left hand side where it lists all the posters on this thread we're two different people. 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

The base pay charts are the same across the board. However, if your on a ship you get seapay. But you also lose your BAS (even when in port) so it usually equals out.

BAS or COMRATS as i call it..lol. (food money for the simpletons). :p

This is both true and false. Just starting out seapay is less then COMRATS, but the more years you are on ship and your sea counter moves the more you get paid...and it can be a lot more.... I know guys who make almost $900 for seapay.

Keep in mind COMRATS is money given to the individual. It's the active duty person's money to eat it is not for his/her family. So losing it while on a ship makes sense because we can get our 3 meals onboard.

As far as advancement, yes it can be tough because you compete against everyone in the Navy in your paygrade to advance.

The plus side is they aren't letting people into the Navy right now in the overmanned rates they are filling voids in undermanned rates so if you do get in it will more then likely be in an undermanned rate where advancement is easier. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -


Keep in mind COMRATS is money given to the individual. It's the active duty person's money to eat it is not for his/her family. So losing it while on a ship makes sense because we can get our 3 meals onboard.


How is this different than BAS? That sounds exactly like it. 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

How is this different than BAS? That sounds exactly like it.

It's not, i'm old school and still call it COMRATS...lol. I think everyone calls it BAS now...i refuse to. haha 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -


It's not, i'm old school and still call it COMRATS...lol. I think everyone calls it BAS now...i refuse to. haha


Oh okay, I was thoroughly confused for a moment because I've never seen a COMRATS on my husband's LES lol 

PODA PODA --- 15 years ago -

The rank structure is very different.He may not like it.My husband and I use to work together before we were married and he HATED working with us(THE NAVY).We were neck n neck in rank and still at the end of the day the marines of the same rank got more RESPECT!And you have to test to make rank in your rate(MOS) 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

This is both true and false. Just starting out seapay is less then COMRATS, but the more years you are on ship and your sea counter moves the more you get paid...and it can be a lot more.... I know guys who make almost $900 for seapay.

Yeah, my husband was getting $450 before we came here. I call it comrats too but I didn't want to confuse anybody since it shows up as BAS. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

navy
army

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground