CHICAGO (AP) Should parents of extremely obese children lose custody for not controlling their kids' weight? A provocative commentary in one of the nation's most distinguished medical journals argues yes, and its authors are joining a quiet chorus of advocates who say the government should be allowed to intervene in extreme cases.
It has happened a few times in the U.S., and the opinion piece in Wednesday's Journal of the American Medical Association says putting children temporarily in foster care is in some cases more ethical than obesity surgery.
Dr. David Ludwig, an obesity specialist at Harvard-affiliated Children's Hospital Boston, said the point isn't to blame parents, but rather to act in children's best interest and get them help that for whatever reason their parents can't provide.
State intervention "ideally will support not just the child but the whole family, with the goal of reuniting child and family as soon as possible. That may require instruction on parenting," said Ludwig, who wrote the article with Lindsey Murtagh, a lawyer and a researcher at Harvard's School of Public Health.
"Despite the discomfort posed by state intervention, it may sometimes be necessary to protect a child," Murtagh said.
But University of Pennsylvania bioethicist Art Caplan said he worries that the debate risks putting too much blame on parents. Obese children are victims of advertising, marketing, peer pressure and bullying things a parent can't control, he said.
"If you're going to change a child's weight, you're going to have to change all of them," Caplan said.
Roughly 2 million U.S. children are extremely obese. Most are not in imminent danger, Ludwig said. But some have obesity-related conditions such as Type 2 diabetes, breathing difficulties and liver problems that could kill them by age 30. It is these kids for whom state intervention, including education, parent training, and temporary protective custody in the most extreme cases, should be considered, Ludwig said.
Related: Factors that increase a child's risk of becoming overweight
While some doctors promote weight-loss surgery for severely obese teens, Ludwig said it hasn't been used for very long in adolescents and can have serious, sometimes life-threatening complications.
"We don't know the long-term safety and effectiveness of these procedures done at an early age," he said.
Ludwig said he starting thinking about the issue after a 90-pound 3-year-old girl came to his obesity clinic several years ago. Her parents had physical disabilities, little money and difficulty controlling her weight. Last year, at age 12, she weighed 400 pounds and had developed diabetes, cholesterol problems, high blood pressure and sleep apnea.
"Out of medical concern, the state placed this girl in foster care, where she simply received three balanced meals a day and a snack or two and moderate physical activity," he said. After a year, she lost 130 pounds. Though she is still obese, her diabetes and apnea disappeared; she remains in foster care, he said.
In a commentary in the medical journal BMJ last year, London pediatrician Dr. Russell Viner and colleagues said obesity was a factor in several child protection cases in Britain. They argued that child protection services should be considered if parents are neglectful or actively reject efforts to control an extremely obese child's weight.
A 2009 opinion article in Pediatrics made similar arguments. Its authors said temporary removal from the home would be warranted "when all reasonable alternative options have been exhausted."
That piece discussed a 440-pound 16-year-old girl who developed breathing problems from excess weight and nearly died at a University of Wisconsin hospital. Doctors discussed whether to report her family for neglect. But they didn't need to, because her medical crisis "was a wake-up call" for her family, and the girl ended up losing about 100 pounds, said co-author Dr. Norman Fost, a medical ethicist at the university's Madison campus.
How to tell if your child is at risk for obesity
State intervention in obesity "doesn't necessarily involve new legal requirements," Ludwig said. Health care providers are required to report children who are at immediate risk, and that can be for a variety of reasons, including neglect, abuse and what doctors call "failure to thrive." That's when children are severely underweight.
Jerri Gray, a Greenville, S.C., single mother who lost custody of her 555-pound 14-year-old son two years ago, said authorities don't understand the challenges families may face in trying to control their kids' weight.
"I was always working two jobs so we wouldn't end up living in ghettos," Gray said. She said she often didn't have time to cook, so she would buy her son fast food. She said she asked doctors for help for her son's big appetite but was accused of neglect.
Her sister has custody of the boy, now 16. The sister has the money to help him with a special diet and exercise, and the boy has lost more than 200 pounds, Gray said.
"Even though good has come out of this as far as him losing weight, he told me just last week, 'Mommy, I want to be back with you so bad.' They've done damage by pulling us apart," Gray said.
Stormy Bradley, an Atlanta mother whose overweight 14-year-old daughter is participating in a Georgia advocacy group's "Stop Childhood Obesity" campaign, said she sympathizes with families facing legal action because of their kids' weight.
Healthier food often costs more, and trying to monitor kids' weight can be difficult, especially when they reach their teens and shun parental control, Bradley said. But taking youngsters away from their parents "definitely seems too extreme," she said.
Dr. Lainie Ross, a medical ethicist at the University of Chicago, said: "There's a stigma with state intervention. We just have to do it with caution and humility and make sure we really can say that our interventions are going to do more good than harm."
Wow, I think we need to focus on the Casey Anthony type of abusers first, before tackling this, but I do think parents of children who are overfed or malnourished should be held accountable for the well being of their child. As my daughter grows, we're hoping to take her to every activity that she enjoys.
Jerri Gray, a Greenville, S.C., single mother who lost custody of her 555-pound 14-year-old son two years ago, said authorities don't understand the challenges families may face in trying to control their kids' weight. "I was always working two jobs so we wouldn't end up living in ghettos," Gray said. She said she often didn't have time to cook, so she would buy her son fast food. She said she asked doctors for help for her son's big appetite but was accused of neglect.
Her sister has custody of the boy, now 16. The sister has the money to help him with a special diet and exercise, and the boy has lost more than 200 pounds, Gray said.
I don't know how I feel about the whole topic, but this part really ticks me off. She worked 2 jobs so they didn't live in the ghetto, but her sister has money to help him with diet and exercise? It costs less to eat at home than it does to eat out.
I get it, there are days where I'm like screw it, I'm not cooking. I feel for her that she worked 2 jobs to support her family, but her son was part of her responsibility. How does a 14yo get to be 555lbs? So sad.
If you are talking about the type of obese they show on the Maury show then yes absolutely because that to me is neglect and child abuse to let your three year old be 200 pounds.
I think it is a wonderful idea. While I think children are almost always better with their parents, in extreme cases of obsesity, I view it as abuse. The parents are giving their children posion and giving them diabetes, heart disease and hypertension.
There's no excuse for a 3 year old to weigh 90 pounds. The parents are the ones who are in complete control of what that child eats. In cases like the ones mentioned in the article I absolutely agree the state should be intervening in some way.
I am not sure foster care is a good idea. There are so many children in the system. Many being abused. With that said I do think something needs to be done.
And people who think healthy food is more expensive irritate me.
LOL I am one of those!!! ;) The difference, though, is that I don't mind paying more for my kids to eat healthy lol I just know it would be cheaper to eat hamburger helper than to buy ground turkey and make homemade spaghetti sauce, but I do it because their health is more important to me. I have been at differing levels of overweight all my life and I wish my parents had paid more attention to that. I am sure my mom thought it would hurt my feelings, but I would have at least learned how to eat healthy before I was a grown adult with children lol
I wonder if the cost of putting them in foster care would be less than offering the families a nutritionist to come in and teach them differently. I understand that the scare value in having your kids taken away from you is higher than offering the help, but helping them is a lifelong change. They would certainly take a child who was malnourished so I get where they are coming from.
It's just as cheap to make hamburger helper as it is to make cauliflower smash and turkey patties. :)
I *used* to think eating healty was expensive, until i looked at all the possibilites of healty food. You don't need to buy the most expensive gourmet healhy food they sell.
I also switched from vegitable oil to canola, and use mostly EVOO. I just started cutting corners here, and there. And it makes a difference. As much as I like healthy food, don't take away my nachos, hot wings and wontons.
I don't know how I feel about the whole topic, but this part really ticks me off. She worked 2 jobs so they didn't live in the ghetto, but her sister has money to help him with diet and exercise? It costs less to eat at home than it does to eat out.
I get it, there are days where I'm like screw it, I'm not cooking. I feel for her that she worked 2 jobs to support her family, but her son was part of her responsibility. How does a 14yo get to be 555lbs? So sad.
I agree..
I'm not sure about anyone else, but as a teen I was able to cook for myself and my sisters. Also, there is always cooking food and freezing it for busy days. My mom did this with chicken mostly she would buy a whole chicken since it was cheaper, boil it, pull the chicken off the bone, and put it into little freezer bags. All we had to do was cook it in a pan, add taco seasoning, cook canned beans, warm up tortillas, and we had a good meal. My mother was always gone at "church" so we just took care of ourselves and we didn't have much money growing up. There wasn't any junk food in the house, no cookies, no sugary cereals, we didn't eat out, and we were all very active kids.
Unless there is some medical condition causing a child to be overweight there is no excuse IMO. Healthy food isn't expensive just buy the basics and stay away from junk food.
I'm not sure about putting kids in foster care, but educating parents on their options and push for more physical education in schools should help.
I didnt read all the comments...BUT I feel there should be a penelty to the parents...but at the same time most overwieght children are aware they are overweight...and now you want to take away there family AND put them in a foster care home thats only goal is to put them on a diet? How does that not mess the child up?? I understand that being overweight causes health problems and could end in death...but if the ONLY issue with the parents is that they have overweight children, why are we not offering to HELP he WHOLE family (child and parents) with classes and whatnot?? You can put the child in a diffrent home untill they loose the weight...but what happens when they live with there family again if the parents are still uneducated? I understand that there are cases where the parents will not even care or what to put forth the effort to help there child...and yes then the child will need to go elsewhere...but alot of the reason children are obese is because the parents are ASLO making unhealthy choices...
I'm not sure about anyone else, but as a teen I was able to cook for myself and my sisters.
We knew how to bake. My mom was a stay at home mom and she cooked. She cooked typical southern style and everything was either fried, breaded, or both lol
I am one of the few who believes that obesity problems often stem from genetics. It was pretty recently found that there is a gene that makes you more predisposed to gaining weight, regardless of your eating habits. I think it's unfair to parents who are really trying to keep their kids healthy yet they are still overweight. Especially single moms. Being a single mom is hard stuff.
Also I watched a true life about teens who were overweight. One of the moms had er son on a strict diet but the son would sneak off and buy junk food and fast food. How would it be fair to take him away from the mom when she is working hard but it's the kid?
MORE predisposed.... if you feed your child a healthy diet of nothing but fruits, veggies and meats they will NOT be obese.
So then what is more wrong, letting your child be obese or starving them? Where do we draw the line? Parents should be allowed to do what they want without putting the child in physical danger. Making parents feed their kids what the government says is just communism. Parents SHOULD have the brain to feed them healthy, but taking away a child because they are obese doesn't accomplish anything and if we could just take children away because we don't agree with their lifestyle would mean no choice in what you do with your children, period. If feeding them unhealthy is punishable, so should circumcision, formula feeding, disposable diapering, etc. The government doesn't have the right to do it.
He "borrowed" from his friends or worked for his friends dad filing things away. The mom had no clue till the show and got pissed at the friends and his dad
I have to disagree.. My cousin is fat and has been her whole life, her mom is, her brother his, but she has 2 siblings who are UNDER weight and her dad is very tiny. How in the world did they not ALL get fat if they are eating the same thing?
They WERE taken into foster care because their mom is a lazy slob, and I can say 100% it was NOT a better environment for them. The psychological effect of taking a child from its mother is MUCH MUCH greater than that of being overweight and will likely only lead to further overweight.
It is PROVEN, that the KLF14 gene is linked to obesity, diabetes, cholesterol, insulin, and glucose. This gene is a "switch" that controls all of the conditions, and is inherited from the mother.
I doubt the children you were talking about ate healthily... the 2 skinny ones got lucky with the good metabolism gene, not the other way around. I would be willing to wager that if she were fed a completely healthy diet, she would NOT be overweight, genes or no.
So then children who have high metabolism but eat the same as kids who don't shouldn't be taken away from their parents because they "got lucky"?
Foster Care is not the answer. I grew up in the system and it is very flawed. Thats not even thinking about the fact that there are so many children in the system already and not enough homes. They need to find a way to school the parents and be able to penalize them, like with fines and such. Taking kids from there home and puting them with strangers who 75% percent of dont care about the children just the extra income coming in is not the right thing to do.
Taking kids from there home and puting them with strangers who 75% percent of dont care about the children just the extra income coming in is not the right thing to d
Exactly, who's to say foster parents would feed them better than their own parents would?