Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

2 year old killed by pit. Who is at fault?

who's talking here?

Picky Vicky 2
Pasha 1
EastCoast 3
MylilZombie 1
Christina 1
Donny 2
Ruthie 4
Thread Killer 1
VivaLaDoll 1
Zany Lady 1
Mommeee Drest 13
Mrs. Tiki 2
San Antonio Bound 1
jo_mamma 3
BlackBetty 3
El Doosho 2
MandaBabyy 1
Jessica Ree ™ 1
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1
krisbunny 2
LakerGirl 1
♫Indie Lady♫ 1
SusseTraume 6
summer1 2
MommaNanny 1
Tits McGee 6
TaDa 1
Life expansions 1
Mama22Angels 1
*FoReVer*iN*lOvE* 1
Mimi80 1
BadMomma 3
frecklebox 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

jo_mamma --- 16 years ago -

who is at fault? 

summer1 --- 16 years ago -

It will always come down to being the owners fault. 

MylilZombie --- 16 years ago -

It will always come down to being the owners fault. it was the FAMILY dog so your saying the parents are to blame for their own child's death??? 

summer1 --- 16 years ago -

I am just saying that in a case where a dog bites someone the owners will always be the ones at fault (law wise) 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

it was the FAMILY dog so your saying the parents are to blame for their own child's death??? ummmm - yes. they had a breed considered by most as dangerous sharing the same space as their child yes i know not all pit dogs are killers but the breed is classified as a dangerous breed for a reason and even well loved and behaved dogs (from pit bulls to fluffy white maltise) have a bad day of course this doesnt help the parents in dealing with this tragedy - a very sad thing to happen 

Christina --- 16 years ago -

are they suddenly not responsible for their dog??... if it killed another child it that was not theirs it would have been. i hope your astounded question had some sarcasim in it... or something. other than the answer being a big DUH 

*FoReVer*iN*lOvE* --- 16 years ago -

Pit bulls aren't bad dogs... Its the owner. When trained pits are sweet loving dogs. Don't get a pit if you don't have any intention on training it. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

So sad that those parents "took a chance". And yes I think they took a chance. With any animal (ANY) there is a risk of their inherent animalness coming out in any situation. I think we tend to forget that even with family pets, they are still animals. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

Pit bulls aren't bad dogs... Its the owner. Not according to that article. 

Picky Vicky --- 16 years ago -

Dammit! Doesn't anyone get mauled by poodles? 

jo_mamma --- 16 years ago -

i have been mauled by a chihuahua. lol mean little monster. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

Not according to that article.  I'm not going to take anything to heart that a website called "Mom Logic" publishes. Lame. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

Dammit! Doesn't anyone get mauled by poodles? man-oodles??? http://static.flickr.com/90/252808438_b7c4f12244_b.jpg sorry, havent figured out how to put pics up yet 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

I'm not going to take anything to heart that a website called "Mom Logic" publishes. Lame. How about good old common sense???Or is that lame too? 

jo_mamma --- 16 years ago -

the only reason i posted it was because the article was posted on my FB from Rescue Ink a rescue site and the debate about it was interesting. was wondering what you guys thought about it. 

Mrs. Tiki --- 16 years ago -

Pit bulls aren't bad dogs... Its the owner. I totally agree... I grew up with pits and they NEVER got aggressive with us kiddos!! 

Picky Vicky --- 16 years ago -

man-oodles??? I can't see the pic. 

Zany Lady --- 16 years ago -

These dogs were bred for violence. It's in their genes. Even if they have good owners, love is not going to take genetics away. Why take the chance, if it could cost your kid his or her life?" Read more: http://www.momlogic.com/2010/05/if_you_have_a_baby_give_away_your_pit_bull.php?adid=060110_pit_bull#ixzz0peK6zbcw What gets me about this article is that Pits and Rotts WERE NOT bred for violence. Pits were bred actually as a "baby sitter" for kids and Rotts were bred as working dogs. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

How about good old common sense???Or is that lame too?  When I was a kid, my best friends (we were there every day of every summer ages 5-12, also my babysitter) had a Rott. A huge Rott- he was 150lbs. We all played with that dog- rode him when we were little, tugged his ears and were generally kids around him. Never once were any of us hurt by this dog. I've also owned a Pit Bull who was so sweet, she was more likely to drool all over you than bite you. Not all Pits are bad- but if you don't properly train them and do things like neuter them- then you'll get what you get with any dog- behaviors. So as for your "common sense" I'll take experience. Thanks. Go ahead and believe everything you read. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

So as for your "common sense" I'll take experience. Thanks. Go ahead and believe everything you read. I don't believe everything I read thanks. But it's a good start. You read what experts have to say (and I'm willing to bet you are NOT an expert) and then you mix it in with experience, and your own common sense, and then you form an opinion. Doesn't matter what ONE person's experience is, all it takes is ONE death to a child for me to not want to ever take that risk. 

VivaLaDoll --- 16 years ago -

The owners (parents) are at fault.. 

Mrs. Tiki --- 16 years ago -

My moms pomeranian is a hell of a lot more mean then my pits ever were! I have literally been attacked by that little demon when I was just sitting on the couch. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

Doesn't matter what ONE person's experience is, all it takes is ONE death to a child for me to not want to ever take that risk.  Not having any first hand experience yourself, you're basing your opinion off of what you read, adding to the hype. People who have great day to day experiences with Pits and Rotts aren't out there writing about it daily! It's sad whenever this happens, but these dogs aren't the only ones guilty of hurting people. German Shepherds (not properly trained) are one of the most dangerous dogs out there. Chows bite people all the time. A Husky is prone to biting and needs a firm hand in training. So? Every dog can be dangerous if it's not properly trained! Pits and Rotts are not especially bad. 

Pasha --- 16 years ago -

I think there are a lot of animals that are just not appropriate for a family with small children. Pits being one of them. I don't give a crap how much training the dog goes through or how sweet it seems, I personally would never own a large dog or a pitt as long as my children are small. Kids can be taught all day long and dogs can be trained, but in the end kids do stupid things and a dog's instinct is louder than the voice of reason. It's just not worth it. If you know that it's "risky" then why intentionally expose your kids to it? Even small dogs attack. But I've never heard of a kid being "mauled to death" by a chihuahua or pomeranian. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

My moms pomeranian is a hell of a lot more mean then my pits ever were i believe you.... but the little dogs that snap/bite usually dont kill whereas due to sheer size and force of strength the bigger breeds cant be called off once they get out of control im pretty sure i could punt a pomeranian at least 20ft if i had to but against a bigger bred, im toast :) 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

I think there are a lot of animals that are just not appropriate for a family with small children. Pits being one of them. I don't give a crap how much training the dog goes through or how sweet it seems, I personally would never own a large dog or a pitt as long as my children are small. Kids can be taught all day long and dogs can be trained, but in the end kids do stupid things and a dog's instinct is louder than the voice of reason. It's just not worth it. If you know that it's "risky" then why intentionally expose your kids to it? Even small dogs attack. But I've never heard of a kid being "mauled to death" by a chihuahua or pomeranian. Here is my rebuttal to your comment Amy 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

I've seen an infant (back home, not here) pretty beat up by a long hair chihuahua. Just saying! And Toni I'm not saying run out and get a big dog, esp. if you're not comfortable with it, just dont lump them all into one "bad dog" group. That is all. 

BlackBetty --- 16 years ago -

pit bulls are bread for violence, it doesnt matter how loving the family is the dogs are insane and mentaly unstable. But people are stupid and if ur dog is more important than your child. be prepare 

TaDa --- 16 years ago -

pit bulls are bread for violence No actually their not. 

SusseTraume --- 16 years ago -

No actually their not.  There's no use fighting them =) 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground