Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Spanking: Abuse or No?

who's talking here?

KeyboardWarrior 1
Mrs Patch 4
sweetcheeks 2
Mommeee Drest 1
ALS MommaKitty 1
Vanbam 2
laneys mommy 1
::♥::andrea::♥:: 1
KayLay 2
LakerGirl 11
jessicajane 1
Jane Wayne 8
Barbie 2
LilyB 1
SierraFoxtrot 2
JAZZ 2
Shoes 1
AINOKEA 3
mztammy 3
DoctorDonna 3
SouthernBelle 1
cede 1
MommyofAA 1
JessesGirl 3
Alisa 1
RaeLyn 6
skysmommy 2
BadMomma2 5
Whitness Protection Team Betty 4
emysmama2 1
whatevergirl2 1
Notfromhere 1
Texas9 3
Sleepless in SoCal 3
TheRoses 1
Scrappy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Spanking: Abuse or No?

Do you think spanking should be considered abuse? I'm not talking leave black and blue markings, I'm talking just a few swats on the rear end. Do you spank your children?

No, it's not abuse/Yes I spank Vote
 
 73.5% (108)
No, it's not abuse/No I do not spank Vote
 
 8.8% (13)
Yes, it's abuse/No I do not spank Vote
 
 4.1% (6)
Yes, it's abuse/Yes I spank Vote
 
 0.7% (1)
No kids, but I will spank in the future Vote
 
 10.9% (16)
No kids, I will not spank in the future Vote
 
 2.0% (3)
RaeLyn --- 15 years ago -

Do you think spanking should be considered abuse? I'm not talking leave black and blue markings, I'm talking just a few swats on the rear end. Do you spank your children? 

AINOKEA --- 15 years ago -

I do.. not to the extreme.. they mostly get it on their hands and bottoms.. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

i think there needs to be clarification of what sort of spanking

i have no issue with smacking the hand or butt when they are younger but you were talking about your parents smacking (or thumping as you called it) on the face and thats not ok for me 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

just a few swats on the rear end.

If this is done open-handed over clothing, no, I do not consider it abuse.

We don't spank though. We don't feel it's the most effective way to discipline our son. 

sweetcheeks --- 15 years ago -

:0 I get spanked all the time 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

I do not think it is abuse but I do not spank my children. Time out works just fine for me. 

RaeLyn --- 15 years ago -

parents smacking (or thumping as you called it) in the face and thats not ok for me

BM, smacking implies they hit our face with an open palm. They thumped, which means thumped their pointer finger on our mouth. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

I think it would only qualify as abuse if you:
Leave Marks/ bruises/ cuts/ scrapes
Beat them out of anger

There are other instances, but I definitely feel that if you hit your children when you don't have a level head (like you are angry or overly emotional) then that is abuse. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

They thumped, which means thumped their pointer finger on our mouth.


they used their authority, size, anger and physical force to intimidate and projected that to your face - that still not ok for me 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

One of the problems with spanking is that it can very easily turn from non-abusive to abusive if the parent is angry or has control issues. 

Vanbam --- 15 years ago -

I tap my daughter on the behind, not hard, but enough for her to realize what she did was wrong. 

sweetcheeks --- 15 years ago -

DD I don't know any parent that is calm and collected when deciding to spank 

RaeLyn --- 15 years ago -

they used their authority, size, anger and physical force to intimidate and projected that to your face - that still not ok for me

My parents never had "authority" over me. I respected them, that's the difference. My mother did the thumping and she was shorter than I. There was no intimidation. Just a quick punishment for talking back. 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

Parents need to have a good balance of fear and love. Kids need to know you are serious and that they are loved. Too much love equals spoiled and too much fear equals abuse. Finding the right balance is tricky. I am not saying beat your kids, clearly I did not. I am just saying boundaries have to be made and consequences have to be enforced. And obviously love has to be given.

I did swat my kids when they were little. Nothing too serious just enough to let them know momma wasn't playing. 

RaeLyn --- 15 years ago -

I did swat my kids when they were little. Nothing too serious just enough to let them know momma wasn't playing.

That's what my parents did. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

Just once I said something horrible to my mom, and she slapped me across the face. I deserved it, I deserved it long before that, but I can guarantee you I never pushed her that far again.

I was a teenager... 

Vanbam --- 15 years ago -

I don't know any parent that is calm and collected when deciding to spank

oh im very calm when i smack her behind. i make sure its not hard and that she understands whats going on. yes im angry, but i can control myself, i let her know that im not playing around and what she did was wrong. 

AINOKEA --- 15 years ago -

There are other instances, but I definitely feel that if you hit your children when you don't have a level head (like you are angry or overly emotional) then that is abuse

I couldn't agree more. There have been times where either my husband was extremely angry or I was angry and over emotional but we never let it get to that point. One of us is always level headed to stop the other before it gets to that point. I think what our problem is, is that sometimes, we forget they're kids and that they really don't understand what we're saying. I don't think it helps that sometimes its a cultural thing for it to be okay to hit your kids. I also think sometimes the environment can help. I know since we've been here, we've done more of the talking and time out and I hands down agree that it is way more effective. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

DD I don't know any parent that is calm and collected when deciding to spank

This is my issue with it. The child sees a parent who is angry and hurting them. I never want to see fear in my son's eyes when he looks at me. There are other ways to teach a lesson besides inflicting pain. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

sweet, my mom was. It is supposed to be a cause and effect punishment not a "you did a bad bad thing and I am going to beat you for it"

It is meant to startle not bruise 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

Just once I said something horrible to my mom, and she slapped me across the face. I deserved it, I deserved it long before that, but I can guarantee you I never pushed her that far again.

I was a teenager...


X2 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

we've done more of the talking and time out and I hands down agree that it is way more effective.

Yes, but it takes more time and requires patience and control. That's why a lot of people skip it and go straight to hitting. 

JessesGirl --- 15 years ago -

We only spank occasionally and we always talk to our daughter about it first and let her know why she is getting the spanking and that we love her very much. The anticipation is worse than the actual spanking, which is just a light slap over clothes. Then she stands in time out if she is still acting naughty. We time her and it usually only take a minute or two for her to say she is done crying and then we talk about it, and give her a big hug! It takes more time, but it works sooo well!! 

AINOKEA --- 15 years ago -

LakerGirl.. you're talking to someone who is VERY low on patience.. lol. When we were home our surroundings were family but slaps and lickens is what my nieces got. I think its been a harder lesson for my husband and I than my children. I feel bad for my kids because I want them to understand and be open and not to fear me, but to respect me. I mean my in laws still do it to this day but then tell us that we have to do more talking and stuff. Hypocritical really, but we're consistent with talking and such and less spanks. 

TheRoses --- 15 years ago -

I agree with you LakerGirl. There are other ways to teach your child right from wrong. 

SierraFoxtrot --- 15 years ago -

When I do have kids I will not spank. Maybe it's not physical abuse, depending on how you do it, but I view it as mental abuse. My parents spanked me and my sisters and it did no help to get me to be good it just made me HATE my parents and therefore I acted out more. I do not think it is an effective form of discipline. I think that you can find other ways to discipline your children without being physical. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

my dad had a special belt for us. I got spanked a lot but I was a trouble maker. After I finally learned, all he had to say was 'Go get me the belt' and I would shape up REAL fast.


But see, that seems like you were behaving out of fear, not because you understood why something was wrong or not.
I am VERY much against spanking with objects. That's purely intended to inflict pain, which to me is crossing the line. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

My husband and I debate over this all the time. Ayden is my child with my ex husband and he does not get spanked but Chris and I argue about if Sean will be spanked or not I say no and he says yes so I told him he will be the one doing it because I refuse. 

SierraFoxtrot --- 15 years ago -

I think that by spanking your children, you may be unintentionally teaching them that by inflicting pain and causing fear, they can get what they want because that is what they see from their parents. 

Texas9 --- 15 years ago -

I got spanked growing up when I was given several warnings and didnt shape up, and I turned out fine. When my daughter does something wrong or bad, I get down on her level and make sure she understands what she did was wrong and that it is not okay to do that. We do however give little swats on the bottom too, but we try talking and time out first. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground