Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Do you breastfeed?

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
3Kleebs 1
Giggle Butt 1
Vintage_Girl 1
laneys mommy 1
shesfromthevalley 1
Starr 1
Barbie 2
Trace 1
AmberUSMC 1
LilShutterbug 7
SecretSquirrel 2
Poe 2
MAM1979 1
KikiSantana 3
SoonToBeJD 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you breastfeed?

Just curious as to what the ratio is here. I'm a breastfeeding mom (well, I breastfed my son until his 2nd birthday and will be breastfeeding my next little guy for at least a year) and am a big proponent of breastfeeding. Just about all of the moms I know breastfeed, so I'm curious as to whether breastfeeding is more common here or if its just who I've happened to bump into since I moved here :D

90-100% formula Vote
 
 22.7% (10)
Mixed feeding Vote
 
 15.9% (7)
90-100% breast Vote
 
 61.4% (27)
LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

Just curious as to what the ratio is here. I'm a breastfeeding mom (well, I breastfed my son until his 2nd birthday and will be breastfeeding my next little guy for at least a year) and am a big proponent of breastfeeding. Just about all of the moms I know breastfeed, so I'm curious as to whether breastfeeding is more common here or if its just who I've happened to bump into since I moved here :D 

Giggle Butt --- 15 years ago -

First 2 months, second 7 months.

My daughter had to supplement.... She was jaundice. 

SoonToBeJD --- 15 years ago -

I nursed for about 2 weeks and switched to formula. 

MAM1979 --- 15 years ago -

1st baby: 2.5 months (got colic and had to use formula)

2nd: 10 1/2 months straight to whole milk

3rd: 13 months straight to whole milk

4th: still breastfeeding he's 13 months, trying to stop, but he's not happy about it! 

ALEM --- 15 years ago -

formula for both. if we have a #3 then i'll attempt it again 

AmberUSMC --- 15 years ago -

I nursed all 4 of my kids as long as I could. I have to pump at work so it dried up between 5-10 months. 

shesfromthevalley --- 15 years ago -

I'm more informed this time around so I'm hoping to go alot longer with this baby. I breastfed my daughter for 3 months last time and had several people pushing me to supplement which really didn't do any good. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

Oldest nursed for 2 mo.

2nd nursed for 9 mo with 1-2 formula bottles a day. Then went to formula. 

SecretSquirrel --- 15 years ago -

#1 no formula, weaned at 15 months
#2 no formula, weaned at 19 months
#3 formula from 9-12 months, weaned due to allergies

Then I pumped for 6 weeks for my friends baby (that I carried as a surrogate) and got enough to last her 3 months. 

laneys mommy --- 15 years ago -

ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh our struggles. Prescription formula. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

My daugther till after the first year and still nursing my son (11m) 

3Kleebs --- 15 years ago -

Nursed my son for a year, bit he also got formula. Tried cow's milk, but didn't work. He's an all soy kid now. 

Starr --- 15 years ago -

Currently nursing. 6 weeks so far 

Vintage_Girl --- 15 years ago -

Nursed exclusively for the first 4 months but she wasn't gaining weight. Formula since 4 months (she is 9 months next week), but I still nurse her every morning and some evenings. 

Poe --- 15 years ago -

I think its weird after 8 months, my boss (a doc) agrees with me. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

I think its weird after 8 months, my boss (a doc) agrees with me.

I don't think it's weird, my stepmom (a doc) agrees wth me 

Poe --- 15 years ago -

There ya go, only the mom can decide what's normal for them. 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

I think its abnormal to stop before a year.

When my son was 11 months I went to a dinner party and was nursing (covered) in the corner of the room. At that party, I was told (by a nurse) that it was akin to child molestation to nurse past 8 months. I laughed and said that anyone who had breastfed a child (she did hers for 6 weeks each) and still thought that breastfeeding was in any way sexual clearly had deeper problems than worrying about how long I breastfed MY child!

My son nursed until 4 months ago. He still has a relationship with my breasts, which (in my opinion) is totally healthy. If you ask him now about boobies, he says they're for baby and that they're for "Brudder" to eat (who is coming soon). When we were weaning, I taught him that my boobs were tired and needed to go "night night" so sometimes he tells my boobs night-night randomly still, but its his way of reminding himself that they're still there, but that he doesn't need to nurse for comfort.

Honestly, though, this American concept of weaning before age 2 is completely strange. We are one of the only major countries in which breastfeeding is below 50% (although, it seems its more common here as I suspected!!!) and breastfeeding after 3 months is only 13%!!! The average age for weaning from the breast in most other countries is age 2---definitely not only 3 months!

And, the World Health Organization (WHO), American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), American Medical Association (AMA), National Breast Cancer Foundation (NBCF), La Leche League, and even the US Government (via WIC and other programs) ALL recommend breastfeeding until "At least age 2"---as in minimum.

So, globally and medically speaking, breastfeeding past 8 months is 100% normal and 100% recommended!

Also, the longer you breastfeed, the better the long-term benefits to your child AND your health (decreases in reproductive and breast cancers, heart disease, diabetes, and about a dozen other major diseases...all of the most common and most deadly ones!)

*steps off of soap-box about the "weirdness" of extended breast feeding* 

SecretSquirrel --- 15 years ago -

I think its weird after 8 months, my boss (a doc) agrees with me. 

That make no sense, babies can't have cow's milk until 12 months.

Personally I don't care who thinks it's weird, I care about the science that shows how good it is. 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

There ya go, only the mom can decide what's normal for them.

Actually, only the mom can decide what is normal and acceptable for the mom. It IS best for baby to continue to nurse long after 8 months of age. If the mother is not comfortable with that, then that is her own personal hang-up that she must deal with as best she sees fit.

Although, I don't know what magically happens at 8 months that makes it suddenly weird that isn't also true at 7 months or 9 months---why 8 months? I'm only curious because this is the exact age at which many people have told me that it becomes unacceptable. Funny, my doctors and my pediatricians (being military, we've seen many of them in 3 years!) have all been thrilled when I told them I was still breastfeeding (before I weaned) or that I waited til age 2 to wean! My son's main pedi was almost sad when I told her I'd decided to wean (which I only did because I was pregnant again and had high risk for miscarriage and didn't want to increase that risk).

I, personally, would not return to see a doctor that recommended stopping breastfeeding at 8 months---which goes against EVERY medical study on breastfeeding, all of which show that long-term breastfeeding is preferred when it is mutually acceptable to mother and child. Any doctor who does not read the research to know what is best cannot be as informed as I'd want my doctor to be. Sure, saying "Oh, your child is 8 months, so if you wean, its okay" is a lot different than saying "Its weird to nurse after 8 months"----one condones a mother's right to choose when to wean (which I'm ALL for---breastfeeding should be 100% up to the mother and the child) and the other encourages mothers to STOP doing something that is healthy.

The big fact for me is that babies NEED formula or breastmilk as a staple of their diet until at least one year---so, if you have the supply and physically CAN breastfeed, it makes ZERO sense to me to choose to stop nursing at ANY time before 12 months and pay for formula when you have two working boobs that will give you the (even better!!!) stuff for free! 

KikiSantana --- 15 years ago -

Neither of my babies (2 years and 7 months) have EVER had formula, and I'm damn proud! I breastfed up until I found out I was pregnant with my second (my son was 11 months) and my daughter and I are going strong. If someone has an issue with you breastfeeding, it's usually coming from the lips of someone that would not or could not do it themselves. I would be devastated if I couldn't feed my own kids...on a side note, formula is SO expensive, but boobies are free! I'll be so sad when my daughter switches to whole milk at a year, it's our last baby, and BFing has truly been an amazing bonding experience for me and my kids. 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

Personally I don't care who thinks it's weird, I care about the science that shows how good it is.

Amen! I was actually called a child molester for nursing my 11 month old once.

I just giggled. When you have a hungry infant/toddler gnawing on your chest, the last thing you think about is sex! Having someone chewing on your nipple is in no way physically pleasurable.

The endorphins, however, are pretty nice! Nursing my son before his naptime always left me more relaxed so that I could feel more peaceful while he slept and when he woke I felt like I'd had an awesome break! If I didn't go right to sleep and take a nap too ;) Now that he doesn't nurse at all, when he naps I find myself stressing about what I need to get done while he's sleeping and have to remind myself to relax while he naps! Now that I'm pregnant and constantly exhausted, I miss those joint naps even more! 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

Neither of my babies (2 years and 7 months) have EVER had formula, and I'm damn proud! I breastfed up until I found out I was pregnant with my second (my son was 11 months) and my daughter and I are going strong. If someone has an issue with you breastfeeding, it's usually coming from the lips of someone that would not or could not do it themselves. I would be devastated if I couldn't feed my own kids...on a side note, formula is SO expensive, but boobies are free! I'll be so sad when my daughter switches to whole milk at a year, it's our last baby, and BFing has truly been an amazing bonding experience for me and my kids.

I was duped into supplementing when my son was 3 months old because they threatened me with hospitalizing him because his reflux was so bad that he wasn't gaining weight. Even prescription formula made it worse. Instead, I found a different pediatrician and 2 weeks later (after cutting dairy from MY diet), I had a happy baby who was gaining weight beautifully!

My goal with this baby is to never have a drop of formula pass his little lips! I KNOW I can breastfeed (I did it for 2 years!), so i'm really glad that I have the confidence not to fall into the trap of supplementing---that 2 weeks of supplementing nearly cost me my ENTIRE supply (and I went from 10oz per breast to 2oz per breast in A WEEK of supplementing!!! formula KILLS your supply!)

It was so great knowing that I was everything he needed during those early months. Literally, all he NEEDED was a piece of cloth for his butt and a boob (I cloth diaper too). Everything else was extra. There's something primal and comforting in that knowledge. And my lil guy didn't drink whole milk until after he was 18 months and only drank chocolate milk then (a rare treat since I was still breastfeeding multiple times a day). He refused plain whole milk completely until just before his 2nd birthday. Now he drinks it like a pro, but didn't EVER request it until after I weaned him. Made me feel good to know he preferred MY milk to cow milk!

When I decided to wean him due to my high risk pregnancy, I was heartbroken the first time I told him "no boobie" and he didn't fight me. And I almost cried the first time he rolled over and went to sleep without even asking to nurse. It IS very sad when they outgrow that bonding that has become so special to you. Especially when they're older and they don't ever sit still for you to just hold them EXCEPT when you're nursing anymore, so you feel like you're losing your baby completely! :(

But, now I have a big 2.5 year old and a baby on the way, so I guess I can live with having a big boy since I'm getting Baby #2 :D 

KikiSantana --- 15 years ago -

Good for you Shutterbug, and good luck with the new little one! You'll be great! Oh, what pump are you using (if any). I used Ameda with my son, but got a Medela swing for my daughter and have been amazed at the difference! I'm talking 4-6 ounces in less then 5 minutes! Crazy fast! Anyways, just in case you needed to pump, Medela is where it's at! :-) 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

I used a cheapy medela electric hand model (took AA batteries) for emergencies---like our cross country road trip...nothing sucks worse than having a crying hungry baby when you're stuck in traffic and can't pull over and you're so engorged that the seatbelt is making you spew everywhere!

But, in general, I'd only use it for emergencies when he'd sleep through a feeding or car-trips or about once a month just to check how much I was producing.

I'm planning to use the same pump this time around, but a friend of mine has a Medela she's offered to loan me for this baby since she'll be weaning right around the time I deliver---but I don't see much point in having a Medela double electric pump that I'll use only a few times, ya know? 

KikiSantana --- 15 years ago -

Definitely! Nothing like having your milk come in at those inopportune moments :) 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

A friend of mine (when I was pregnant with my son) came to the Ball and left her 2 month old in the room upstairs with her mom. During the ceremony an infant at another table started crying and her milk let-down. She wound up taking my shawl and shoving it down her top and wrapping her shawl around to get out of the ceremony before it ruined her dress. She went up, nursed, and then came back down. Luckily, we were sitting right next to the doors, so it was easy for her to slip out without disrupting the ceremony! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground