Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: spanking

who's talking here?

CourtesyFlush 1
ChestyMcBreasty 1
cindy 5
LakerGirl 5
BaylesObedience 2
CharlieWhiskey 1
NotPhased 2
~Lauren~ 2
Trace 3
Housewife Say What 5
JessesGirl 1
Bell10 1
Jack Hass 1
Momzilla 1
BadMomma2 5
xVivaLaDollx 2
Scrappy 2
YOU MAD BRO 2
Sarah H aka Boot 1
lil momma 2
KCJ2008 1
IrishMaiden 3
tuckersmama 6
Kaisully 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: spanking

i was spanked and i turned out fine, but i dont think i will spank my kids. my husband thinks we should if they are really bad. what do you guys think?

yes, i spank my kids when they are really bad Vote
 
 91.2% (83)
no i would never! Vote
 
 8.8% (8)
tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

i was spanked and i turned out fine, but i dont think i will spank my kids. my husband thinks we should if they are really bad. what do you guys think? 

BaylesObedience --- 15 years ago -

we spank i deff think there is a fine line, that you have to be carefull not to cross but we deff do. if the crime fits they get spanked. 

tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

what do they have to do to deserve it? i was spanked because my friend tracked dirt in the house once. also for changing the channel during the super bowl lol. i thought it was really unfair! :p 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

we spank i deff think there is a fine line, that you have to be carefull not to cross but we deff do. if the crime fits they get spanked.

Agree, my son gets pops on the butt when he misbehaves and will continue to do so when he blatantly doesn't listen. 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

what do they have to do to deserve it? i was spanked because my friend tracked dirt in the house once. also for changing the channel during the super bowl lol. i thought it was really unfair! :p

Oh no, nothing like that. I spank my little one, like when I tell him no and he smiles and does it any way blatantly doing wrong or not listening. But never for something like an accident or changing a channel that's a little crazy. 

tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

also, would you let someone else spank your child if the child, say, took a baseball bat to their car window? at 4 years old 

NotPhased --- 15 years ago -

also, would you let someone else spank your child if the child, say, took a baseball bat to their car window? at 4 years old 

no!!! I would handle it. 

Momzilla --- 15 years ago -

When I was little we got spanked with a belt. And once, when my brother (who was about 10) was acting like a "baby" my dad duct taped a diaper on him and drug him out front so our neighbors could see his new baby lmao. We turned out fine, and we always thought twice about misbehaving or talking back. 

Jack Hass --- 15 years ago -

I spank BUT as has been said in many of threads, there is a HUGE difference in spanking when appropriate and then spanking out of anger. 

tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

to the person who said no, why? 

IrishMaiden --- 15 years ago -

??? 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

sdsweetheart --- 14 sec ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
also, would you let someone else spank your child if the child, say, took a baseball bat to their car window? at 4 years old 


No if my child needs discipline it will come from my husband or myself. 

BaylesObedience --- 15 years ago -

same as housewife, we try time out and otheres befor we spank, and its never for an accident or someone elses fault. 

IrishMaiden --- 15 years ago -

A 4 y/o took a baseball bat to a window? 

CourtesyFlush --- 15 years ago -

My son is older so there is no reason to spank. when he was younger we popped him every now and then, but not much. I think you should never spank out of anger...that I don't agree with,and see it all too often. But whatev...not my kid, not my problem unless someone is blatantly crossing the line. 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

also, would you let someone else spank your child if the child, say, took a baseball bat to their car window? at 4 years old

Um, if it was family such as my mother or grandmother of course they have the right to discipline my child because they disciplined me. In my family every one helps and works to raise the children together but we are very close like that. Friends or people I don't know then absolutely not, I will handle it. 

tuckersmama --- 15 years ago -

also, would you let someone else spank your child if the child, say, took a baseball bat to their car window? at 4 years old

btw, im asking this because it happened lol. my friend did this to my grandma who is from the south, and she spanked him. i cant remember what his mom said lol but i wouldnt spank another persons kid no way. 

NotPhased --- 15 years ago -

to the person who said no, why? 


no one would ever put hands on my child. Never!
Me & my husband would take care of disciplining. 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

I have popped my daughter on the bottom a couple of times when she is REALLY misbehaving (ie - when she let go of my hand and ran into the road). But other than that I try to avoid physical punishment... 

lil momma --- 15 years ago -

i think a pat on the but is okay, but when people bare butt beat their child thats a whole different story. 

Housewife Say What --- 15 years ago -

same as housewife, we try time out and otheres befor we spank, and its never for an accident or someone elses fault.

Yeah, we have like a 3 strike rule, he does it once it's a warning, twice in a row of course another warning, once he does it a third time after knowing the boundries and purposely trying to push them, then he gets popped. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

to the person who said no, why?

my parents were abusive. i have only once laid a hand (slap on his clothed butt) on one of my boys (he ran into the path of a car), and it was my shock and distress that caused me lose control

i do think that sometimes a swat on the diapered bum or a smack on the hand is fine but thats it. open handed slaps on the body i dont agree with 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I don't care who you are family or not. No one better ever put their hands on my children. 

cindy --- 15 years ago -

a lot of research says that spanking does nothing but create fear. In society we are taught that its not ok to hit, if you hit someone you go to jail. What kind of message are you sending my spanking them. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

to the person who said no, why?

I was raised by non-spanking parents.
I just don't believe it's the most effective form of discipline. In my opinion, it teaches fear rather than truly getting to the heart of what the child did wrong.

Our son gets time-out or time-in, depending on where we are. Sure, it sometimes takes more patience and lots of explaining and talking, but I feel like he's learning WHY things are right or wrong rather than just "if I do this, mom and dad are going to hurt me." 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

and it was my shock and distressed that caused me lose control

This is what happens with me. I honestly avoid MOST punishment with my daughter...She usually just gets told no and if she is misbehaving in the house - she gets put into her PLAY area (what a great punishment...right?).

Of course...she is PRETTY well behaved, she is going on 2 - so she has hit her rebellious stage and she does act out, but nothing over the top (yet..). 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

i was spanked and i turned out fine,

This is my least favorite argument for anything. My mom grew up not wearing seatbelts, and she turned out fine too. So maybe we should all stop wearing seatbelts. :/ 

cindy --- 15 years ago -

I just don't believe it's the most effective form of discipline. In my opinion, it teaches fear rather than truly getting to the heart of what the child did wrong.

This.
This is probably going to raddle some cages , but a lot of research is behind this statement. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

i was spanked and i turned out fine,

This is my least favorite argument for anything.


im currently thinking about my friend who was sexually abused by her father - yeah, im guessing she wouldnt go for this argument either if i phoned her to ask

i think as long as the parent remains in control and the punishment is fair and just goes a long way for the pro spanking argument - not all spanked kids are abused

but for some, like me, its not something i can do to my child because it affects me greatly 

IrishMaiden --- 15 years ago -

My mum called them "attitude adjustments". 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground