I am a regular PUer and this is obviously not my real account. I know there a lot of harsh people on here but I would appreciate if you all would take the time to just hear me out for a second or two. One of my best friends who is also a marine wife has a very real and sad problem. I have slowly noticed a cry for help and I am at a complete lost on how to confront the situation. Last night I was over at het house and I had noticed cuts on her wrist..not just tiny scrapes, long, deep cuts. I didn't say anything because I didn't want her to feel like she was being attacked. I need to know how to confront this, she and het husband have a child and I don't wasn't to risk her being labeled as an "un fit mother" should I get in contact with her husband and tell him myself or should I confront her and let her just take it from there? Sorry this is so long....I am deeply sadend by this situation. Nobody should ever have to suffer silently. Any advice or info is appreciated. TIA
Talk to her. I know two cutters, be a friend and listen. They have some good books on the topic. Are they recent scars? Open wounds still? It is a very serious thing for sure. I wish recovery for her.
Yes he is deployed. And they are very fresh cuts....when I saw them it looked like she has just done it the night before or even maybe the same day I visited her.
Talk to her and be their for her. And maybe also tell her husband so she can get help. Who knows if her child has seen her do it that way she gets help for herself and her family.
If I had it my way I would have taken her to the hospital...but I wasn't too sure on how her reaction would have been and I don't want her to take drastic measures.
I would talk to her she is your friend. Even if you dont say much just listen to her. If you think its SERIOUS I would contact her husband because she could be in some serious need of help.
I wouldn't tell the hubby. The best thing you can do is look her straight in the eyes and ask her, sincerely, if she is ok. If she breaks down, just let her cry. Don't offer advice unless asked! She may just need someone to vent to. If and when she does vent, don't vent to her, just accept that she wants to get it off her chest and not compare life stories.
Also, it could be more of a control issue than a suicide issue. Cutters sometimes cut because they feel like that they can at least control the pain. While everything else in life is out of their hands, they can control something. (Some bulemics and Aneorexics have the same thought process)
This is how I see it, and I'm not trying to be heartless or cold, but take it that way if you want to. If she really wanted to kill herself, she would do it. She would not be having friends over and leaving cuts uncovered. She obviously wants attention and isn't mature enough to go about it the right way. In my opinion she is an idiot who needs to grow up and learn how to deal. So what I would do, and have done in the past is confront her. Tell her you are there for her to talk to and she needs to stop cutting because it is just plain stupid.
This is how I see it, and I'm not trying to be heartless or cold, but take it that way if you want to. If she really wanted to kill herself, she would do it. She would not be having friends over and leaving cuts uncovered. She obviously wants attention and isn't mature enough to go about it the right way. In my opinion she is an idiot who needs to grow up and learn how to deal. So what I would do, and have done in the past is confront her. Tell her you are there for her to talk to and she needs to stop cutting because it is just plain stupid.
Wow you need to read up on cutting and understand if you confronted a true cutter this way you would only push them to do worse. PLEASE DO NOT approach this issue in this manner, its completely unnecessary and will only do harm to attack her.
OP, before you do anything, I would talk to someone, a professional about how to handle it. The last thing you want is to say something and your friend completely shut you out. I honestly think this is something that the PU shouldn't weigh in on unless they've personally dealt with it. None of us are professionals, that I know of.
I dont think you all understand how serious it is when someone cutts themselfs. Its VERY important to get her HELP. Yes Magii if she wanted to kill herself she would but also if she continues to cutt there could be that ONE time when she cutts too deep not meaning to and kill herself.
She needs help, Yes you should let her talk to you and "vent" but what if she looks you straight in the face and says shes fine. Alot of people can hold back from breaking down because her cutting is releaving the PAIN of whatever she is going through. She needs Medical help.
I hope she gets the help she needs. And truthfuly this is something her husband needs to know about.
Also if there is a child involved she should get help.
BTW Cutting is NOT about killing ones self, cutting is NOT about attention (most cuts are hidden) cutting is NOT about immaturity. Any person who truly gave a crap about people would know this.
To MissMagii.....I understand that I took a huge risk by posting something like this. If that's how you feel about the situation...honestly, I feel very sorry for you. If you knew the background behind everything that has happened to her throughout her life...maybe just maybe you wouldn't be so quick to judge. I hate to say this but if you a best friend, a sister or maybe ev/en a family memeber go through something like this surely you probably wouldn't want people to the situation you were dealing with "immature" you want to know what's immature? Everything you just said is.
Cutting is NOT about killing ones self, cutting is NOT about attention (most cuts are hidden) cutting is NOT about immaturity.
This is true. But it takes ONE time to cutt too deep, People cut to hide pain, pain that can get worse and end in taking their life, cutting can end in many diffrent ways. But you are right its not about killing yourself,attention,or immaturity but sometimes it can end in one taking their life because eventualy cutting isnt going to numb the pain anymore, and they could start cutting deeper.
Someone with cutting issues needs real help. PERFESSIONAL HELP. NOT a friend talking with them because guess what the reason someone cuts isnt because of little things its deep down usually tramatic pain or events they are suffered from. Someone who cuts probably has been doing it for awhile but nobody has noticed it cause like you said they HIDE it. Im just saying she may need some serious help.And it would help if her husband is here to help her through this.
Someone with cutting issues needs real help. PERFESSIONAL HELP. NOT a friend talking with them because guess what the reason someone cuts isnt because of little things its deep down usually tramatic pain or events they are suffered from. Someone who cuts probably has been doing it for awhile but nobody has noticed it cause like you said they HIDE it. Im just saying she may need some serious help.And it would help if her husband is here to help her through this.
I think having friend talk to her and persuade her to get professional help can be good.
I think having friend talk to her and persuade her to get professional help can be good.
This could be true but most cutter like addicts wont admitt they have a problem friend or not. Thats why im saying maybe her husband should know, maybe he can help talk to her. Plus I know if I was going through this and my husband was deplyed he would want to know. And he would want to be her for me. Depending on how long and they have been married and such maybe she could talk to her husband!
Magii I cant believe you. Im guessing you have NEVER had any experience so keeping your mouth shut would be a good idea so you dont looks stupid.
Ya know what, go ahead and attack my opinions, but I have dealt with this stuff in my life and in more than one aspect. I'm not just pulling crap out of my asss, and I'm not talking about every cutter there has ever been. To me, someone who is inviting friends over and leaving cuts uncovered is looking for someone to talk to.
My aunt died two years ago from cutting herself. There were so many cries for help but nobody took extreme enough measures. She left behind not only a husband but her 8 year old son. People like you Magii truly make my effing blood boil. Someone cutting themselves for attention? Grow a damn brain and find a heart.
Magii from what you said above it doesnt sound like you have ever experienced this. And yes she may have left them uncovered hoping someone would help her but that doesnt mean...She obviously wants attention and isn't mature enough to go about it the right way. In my opinion she is an idiot who needs to grow up and learn how to deal.
Socalbabyy- This is what I was talking about above. Cuters do it to hide pain and numb therselfs, And in some cases it stops numbing them and they cut deeper and deeper and it ends in this. So sorry for you lost.
Grow up and "learn how to deal" I wish you could have been at the funeral and seen her little boy crying hysterically because his mommy is no longer in this world. You should have seen her husband fall to his knees because the love of his life was now gone forever. You should have seen my mom (her sister) and my grandma (her mom) I wish you could of.