Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Opinions on car "issue"

who's talking here?

Mommeee Drest 1
Abra 7
Lavender is Good 1
MandaBabyy 2
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 2
Samantha 1
grantsmommy 1
~Lauren~ 1
emysmama 2
Trace 2
Chicago 1
Juliet Bravo 5
MasonsMommy 10
skysmommy 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Opinions on car "issue"

I have an 08 VW that due to many trips to Texas and living in 29 Palms...has 72,000 miles on it. It runs fine, has some scratches (nothing major) but the miles are getting up there. I owe $14,500 on it now and Carmax appraised it for $7k (trade in value, private party is $10,500). Should I pay it down to $7k (which I can do by October) and trade it in or just pay it off and keep it? Just curious on opinions...been going back and forth.

Pay off the car and keep it Vote
 
 85.0% (34)
Pay it down and trade it in Vote
 
 15.0% (6)
Other (please explain) Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Juliet Bravo --- 15 years ago -

I have an 08 VW that due to many trips to Texas and living in 29 Palms...has 72,000 miles on it. It runs fine, has some scratches (nothing major) but the miles are getting up there. I owe $14,500 on it now and Carmax appraised it for $7k (trade in value, private party is $10,500). Should I pay it down to $7k (which I can do by October) and trade it in or just pay it off and keep it? Just curious on opinions...been going back and forth. 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

If it doesn't have mechanical problems, id pay it off and keep it. I have an 07 toyota with 66k on it for the same reasons but I'm planning on keeping it till I can't drive it anymore. Miles don't necessarily mean the car is not in good running condition. And its nice to not have a car payment! 

Chicago --- 15 years ago -

tough decision. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

If you trade it in you will be upside down, that is never good. I am in the same boat. 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

Geez - I wish our car only had 72,000 miles on it. Ours is in the shop right now with about 120,000 miles on it - we still owe 11,000 to Carmax.

I would personally keep it if there is nothing wrong with it. 

emysmama --- 15 years ago -

Id say pay off and keep it... like abra said... being upside down isnt good.. even though u are willing to pay the negitive equity the vehicle has... is the amount you owe, the pay off amount.. or the amount with intrest? 

Lavender is Good --- 15 years ago -

Why wouldn't you keep it? I didn't see any reason in your post why you needed to get rid of it? I'm all for paid off vehicles. In 2 months we will have 2 paid off vehicles. 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

As long as you keep up the maintenance and don't skip out on getting oil changes and general maintenance most cars are going to last a good 150k you can squeeze out of em. As long as there are no electrical or mechanical issues or past accidents that is. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

My husband traded in his car in for a newer one right before I met him. Needless to say, I paid for that decision. Now with my car getting all the miles from going home and being in 29, I thought about trading it in. WHen I went in, I was offered a measley 5 grand. I owe twice that. We are paying it off eventually. 

Juliet Bravo --- 15 years ago -

If you trade it in you will be upside down, that is never good. I am in the same boat.

No I would pay the difference (I can pay $7,500 by October), so it would be a fresh loan..

Why wouldn't you keep it? I didn't see any reason in your post why you needed to get rid of it?

Just because the miles are getting up there and I don't want to run into major problems later on...

I can also tell the car doesn't act 'new' anymore. Takes longer to warm up, etc..which isn't bad, just worried about problems arising.. 

emysmama --- 15 years ago -

Why wouldn't you keep it? I didn't see any reason in your post why you needed to get rid of it?

Just because the miles are getting up there and I don't want to run into major problems later on...

I can also tell the car doesn't act 'new' anymore. Takes longer to warm up, etc..which isn't bad, just worried about problems arising..


So if that is the case, do yiou ever plan on paying off a vehicle?

I was worried abt mileage and such a few yrs back and I was an avid lessor. I would keep cars til about 36k miles and trade them back in at the end of the lease..

Now I am in a financed vehicle which was a vehicle I leased but decided to turn the lease into a purchase at the end.. 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

Firstly, is it worth it to pay 7500$ for something you'll be basically giving away for the difference? With 7500$ you can buy a fairly decent vehicle outright and keep both. I see no point in gettin rid of it. Keep up the maintenance and it will last I promise! 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

I say pay it off if it's not showing problems. Try looking up all the info on your car (model, make, year) and what it takes to maintane it teh older it gets. If it looks like too much then get rid of it, If not kepp it. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Firstly, is it worth it to pay 7500$ for something you'll be basically giving away for the difference?

I agree. 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

Think of all the other things that 7500$ could buy. I highly doubt the maintenance costs wil ever run that high. I think you might have a case of bored of car. I get it a lot. After almost 4 years in the same car I wanna new one. One that smells pretty and new. And shines. Lol. But I can't wait for another 2 years not to have a payment and still a decent car. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

Our car has 154,000 miles on it and still runs good (knock on wood). These days people are always trading in cars so it's hard to resist. We will need to get a new car before summer since our A/C doesnt work.. but we will keep this one as my husband to and from work car. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

One that smells pretty and new

I HATE the new car smell. I get a headache. I like a wiff of it but if I sit in one, I get a headache.
I am allergic to new cars, that's a great thing for our bank account LOL! 

skysmommy --- 15 years ago -

let me tell u car max sucks ! do not go threw them! 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

Lol abra! I've got volcanic cherry that makes my head pound I can't get the smell out though! I prefer black ice. Smells almost like my hubs. 

Samantha --- 15 years ago -

Vw's are good cars and will last up to 200,000+ miles if they are taken care of properly. I wouldn't even consider taking half of what I owe on it. I think you should keep your car, take care of it, and pay it off 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

I prefer black ice.

My husband has that in his truck. I carry that scentsy spray. My husband LOVES it but won't use it in his truck, too girly for him, lol. 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

Yeah we actually appraised my husbands truck with carmax and they said 12k. I sold it for 21k to a private party and it was appraised by blue book at 23. 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

And we only sold it because we couldn't afford the payment. If you're gonna get rid of it at very least sell to a private party. So much more worth it than trade though takes longer. 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 15 years ago -

I would pay it off and keep it. I know its nice to get new vehicles but if it lasts you long enough to put away enough money to buy a decent one outright that frees up that car payment money. I have had my hyndai for 6 years, just hit 135k miles. I want to trade it in so bad for something pretty but if it holds out for 2 more years we can save up enough to buy a decent used car and we wont have payments. 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

I want to trade it in so bad for something pretty but if it holds out for 2 more years we can save up enough to buy a decent used car and we wont have payments.

Same here. I think lots of people are car shopping smarter. Screw loans and interest lol. They are great when it comes to credit ratings but suck on monthly payments. 

Juliet Bravo --- 15 years ago -

let me tell u car max sucks ! do not go threw them!

I've purchased two cars from them before. No problems..

So if that is the case, do yiou ever plan on paying off a vehicle?

I was worried abt mileage and such a few yrs back and I was an avid lessor. I would keep cars til about 36k miles and trade them back in at the end of the lease..


Not really...but I drive too much to lease a vehicle, most contracts say about 10-12k miles a year. I drive about 18k..

Think of all the other things that 7500$ could buy. I highly doubt the maintenance costs wil ever run that high. I think you might have a case of bored of car. I get it a lot. After almost 4 years in the same car I wanna new one. One that smells pretty and new. And shines. Lol. But I can't wait for another 2 years not to have a payment and still a decent car.

That's true, I think I just have new car syndrome..

Vw's are good cars and will last up to 200,000+ miles if they are taken care of properly

I wasn't aware of that...and I always do everything on schedule as far as maintenance. 

skysmommy --- 15 years ago -

yeah ...but have u sold a car to them b4? 

MasonsMommy --- 15 years ago -

I really don't like leases either, I think its pointless to pay so much to rent a car basically. I think you should just save up the 7500$ and when your car is really up there sell it outright and put that as a down payment. 

Juliet Bravo --- 15 years ago -

yeah ...but have u sold a car to them b4?

Nope. I was told by a dealership though that they offer more than most dealerships.

I really don't like leases either, I think its pointless to pay so much to rent a car basically. I think you should just save up the 7500$ and when your car is really up there sell it outright and put that as a down payment.

I wouldn't mind it, because I would like to trade my car every 3 years or so anyway..plus you get a Lexus on a Toyota budget. But I can't drive 10,000 miles a year. That's only 25 miles a day... 

Juliet Bravo --- 15 years ago -

My co-worker just brought up a good point. My husband is trying to go officer in a couple years...and what if we move and I can't find a job? Will I want two car payments? (Answer is heck no..)

Thanks ladies =) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground