Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

REPEALING OF DADT

who's talking here?

EastCoast 3
ALS MommaKitty 12
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 7
sofaa 7
*SurroMom2Twins* 1
Lavender is Good 1
5811wife 6
laneys mommy 1
Rebecca 6
MandaBabyy 7
Doula09 2
LakerGirl 8
SusseTraume 1
Tits McGee 1
TaDa 2
Taminator 8
Allison 7
Barbie 4
Trace 2
Phragmipedium 6
PunkinPunkin 1
aswills 2
myhumbleopinion 12
smdh 5
Felicia 1
Lady Leatherneck 1
Whos 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lady Leatherneck --- 15 years ago -

I'd like to hear some thoughts on the repealing of DADT!!!!! 

PunkinPunkin --- 15 years ago -

I think it's dumb, lol. Honestly, when I was in the Army there were lots of homosexual people in and it didn't make a damn difference, everyone was doing what they were supposed to be doing. I think that no one should have the right to ask you your sexual preference in the first place and who cares if you decide to divulge it. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

I think it's a good thing in terms of basic human rights. What a person does in the bedroom or who they love shouldn't prevent them from serving their country. However, there are so many aggressive homophobics in the military that I do fear for the safety of anyone openly gay. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

It was the right thing to do, there is no reason your sexual preference should affect your job. I am glad to see equality finally come to light and that idiotic policy take a hike.

As far as people who are aggressively homophobic, its the same as those who were/are racist or against females in the military. There will always be ignorant people who take their anger out on innocent people. It will take a little time but I dont think this integration will be as hard as the previous ones. 

EastCoast --- 15 years ago -

Meh, I dont care. It just seems as if they rushed into it. And the President had to put his vacation on hold... THE HORROR!!
The living quarters thing. They havent released any information on how they are going to work that. Are they going to force someone to live with someone with the opposite sexual preference? No, they cannot. So, where are they going to put these folks when the berthings (especially on boats that are underweigh)are already cram packed? That crap didnt fly before DADT and its going to cause an uproar now. Also, there are many, many voices on both sides that feel their concerns were not heard (which is not good) and that this ruling is a 'shut-up'. The media made it sound as if the military members were all okay with it and that is untrue according to the survey results. Many said they didnt mind serving, but didnt want to know; many were never even polled.
Im not really clear on what exactly the homosexual community is planning to gain considering it still doesnt grant them the right to marry and have their same-sex dependant covered or added to their record. I have a gay friend who is AD and unclear as well. He thinks it's idiotic and pointless. So, whatever. There will be the same hate-crimes and discrimination as there was before DADT and everyone will be crying that it's unfair. 'He looked at me in the shower!' 'He called me a name!' ' She stole my girlfriend!'
Whatever. We already knew who was playing for the other team anyway. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

Rushed into it??? Its been in effect for 17 years, when it should have never been placed in the first place.

I just dont see how anyone could be ok with the ignorance of that policy, but w/e. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

I think it's good. My husband is mad because he feels it will take focus away from the war, which I can see... but I'm glad it was repealed. If straight people can serve openly, gay people should be able to too! And as I reminded my husband, DADT was brought in, like, 7 years ago... it's not like it has ALWAYS been the policy.

I don't know anyone in the military that is okay with it. No, wait, I know one person. But that doesn't change my view... Just bothers me that the media is acting like all military personnel are okay with it when they're not. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

Well the survey showed an overwhelming 70% so the majority would rule on that one. It's a matter of civil rights IMO, and our military should not be perpetuating violations of civil rights. 

Rebecca --- 15 years ago -

I am all for having your right to choose your sexuality, that is your business and no one else's. That being said here is why I don't think it's a good idea.

The reason they separate men from women in the barracks is for several reasons but one big one is to keep sexual harassment from occurring and to avoid the whole having sex with your roommate. That being said, there are a lot of men, my husband included, who will be uncomfortable rooming with a gay man. If two gay men are rooming together you have the possibility of a relationship being formed. How will that be dealt with?

Another thing, women are not allowed on the front lines due to the fact that it would make the men combat infective to see a woman blown up, shot, or killed. Most men could not handle seeing something like that. I am in no way saying it's easy to see a fellow Marine get injured or killed but my husband explained to me that it would just be different if it were a woman. That being said, if two men, in a relationship, were on the front lines together and one get's injured or killed what do you think that would do? It would essentially be the same thing.

I feel like this is a really bad time to implement a huge change like this. 51% of combat Marines said they are against this. This is mostly because during a time of war a big change like this is dumb. African Americans were not integrated until AFTER WWII. Women were not allowed in the military until AFTER Vietnam. A lot of Marines will probably leave the military over this, my husband is considering it. Some of these Marines will have combat experience and we need all our experienced combat vets. A change like this during a time of war is not smart. It's distracting.

Above all safety of these men and women is another concern. There's no need to explain that one I'm sure.

Now that I've said my piece I feel better. I know many of you will not agree with me and may even tear apart what I say and that's fine with me. I still stick by what I have said. I agree that it has to happen and that gay men and women have every right to have the same rights as everyone else. It's just really bad timing in my opinion. 

EastCoast --- 15 years ago -

Rushed into it???

Nobody I know had heard of any repeal until last year. There are things that I feel they should have organized better BEFORE repealing anything. I didnt say it shouldnt have been repealed ever. Its not like it was a hidden policy. Everyone that joined was made aware, so I dont really get why homosexuas would join and then get all butt-hurt about it, but whatever. None of that matters now. I'm interested to see how many fights are going to be prosecuted as hate crimes one way or the other. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

I can't believe someone would consider leaving the military over this. These people are already serving, probably right alongside many of our husbands. It's not like they're suddenly going to bedazzle their rifles and prance around the battlefield.

As for anyone hearing about the repeal for the first time, if you keep up with news and current events, even peripherally, the repeal has been in discussion ever since DADT was first enacted. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Yep, I'm with Laker and sarcasm on that one! 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

Repealing DADT has been around since it started and it hit fever pitch during the campaigns way back in 2007, it was discussed multiple times on the debates.

On a lighter note, the hubby says he sees a youtube video involving bedazzled uniforms and weapons in our future. 

Lavender is Good --- 15 years ago -

Quite honestly someone who would leave the military because they did not like who was serving next to them is not someone I'd want serving next to my husband anyway.

I support the repeal of DADT because of the amoubtif money the policy wastes and the fact that all the studies and surveys of both our military and our allies who have already taken this step support that it can and does work without impact to unit cohesion or morale. As I am not in the military I won't make a guess as to how those who are will react. It does seem to me, however, that as a whole the military tends to attract fairly upstanding people who are able to continue putting what is important above their personal opinions on things. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

My husband is also concerned with how housing will work. I told I dont see how separate housing could be built because gays dont HAVE to serve openly, they just have the choice. But my husband says "well, what's the difference between having two gay guys room together and a female and a guy?".

Thought I'd share that. He is not homophobic and it's not that he has a problem with gay people serving, he just doesn't see how it works right now with the Marines being on the forward lines so much/during this war. Like I said, I'm glad it was repealed so he and I have this conversation sometimes :P We actually just had it again! 

EastCoast --- 15 years ago -

I'm sure if it doesn't work out the gay guy can just request bah

That's not always the case. Some boats, for example, you cant be less than an E5 w/o dependants to live off the boat. I really dont care either way. I had a homosexual roommate and my only complaint was that she was a complete slob. Ha! It seems mal-planned, but this is the government. Im honestly scared that my husband is going to give the wrong idea because he likes to joke and act a fool. 

smdh --- 15 years ago -

Well the survey showed an overwhelming 70% so the majority would rule on that one.

That survey was flawed. The majority of people who were polled were from the Air Force. They do not share close quarters nor are they on the ground fighting like Marines. Their lifestyle is different than most of the military. I applaud General Amos for standing up for Marines. He is the only person in who is not kissing the public's behind. IMO they can't fix the economy so lets give the government a big thumbs up for "equal rights" and forget about our failing economy. I love gays but I agree with Rebecca, bad timing. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

Honestly I think people are making a bigger deal out of it then it needs to be- who do you think is rooming together now with them?

Good point!

The reason they separate men from women in the barracks is for several reasons but one big one is to keep sexual harassment from occurring and to avoid the whole having sex with your roommate. That being said, there are a lot of men, my husband included, who will be uncomfortable rooming with a gay man. If two gay men are rooming together you have the possibility of a relationship being formed. How will that be dealt with?

Not to bash what you think but having a "gay" roommate while living in the bricks I tell you it already happens. I'm a little different then others because I don't get bothered by that stuff but I don't see the big deal as long as there not doing it while I'm in the room it would be the same situation if she would have brought a man into our room. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

They do not share close quarters

Want to bet? AF has barracks just like any other service.

And I love how people think civil rights should be waived because its "bad timing". 

laneys mommy --- 15 years ago -

I don't know how I feel. I have gay friends and believe in everyones right to live their own lives. I'm not homophobic at all. But the nature of some jobs isn't black and white. This isn't a nine to five job were people go home. I think its much more complicated. Maybe thats because my ex faced the problem on a ship where they are stacked 3 high on top of each other in tiny racks. 

aswills --- 15 years ago -

i think this is a great thing. i honestly feel that it will put a lot of ignorant steretypes to rest. once service members that are currently homophobic realize that a gay man could serve his country just as well a straight man (if not better if some cases) it will open alot of closed minds. Not all homosexual males are going to let it be known even if given a chance. alot homosexual males dont chose to be gay they just are but that doesnt mean that they are going to hit on other service memebrs constantly or make the barricks situation uncortable. i just think all the comments about bedazziling and whatever is closed minded. 

aswills --- 15 years ago -

sidenote: my opinion is my opinion.if you dont agree with it dont bash or others that feel like i do. this is a dangerous subject anytime it is brought up. let just all handle this respectfully. happy holidays everyone! 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

My husband has been on a ship for 7 years total and there have always been homosexuals on the ship. Everyone knows who they are but to be honest most don't seem to care nor do they want details. To be honest I think most people who have been kicked out due to DADT have wanted to get out. There may be some that havent but I have a feeling that guy who has been on the local news isnt telling the entire story. I am glad DADT is done. Maybe we can move on and worry about the mission at hand. 

5811wife --- 15 years ago -

I'm not sure how I feel about this. What about situations where men have to shower/share a bathroom? How would you feel having an openly gay person shower with you? How is that any different than making men and women shower together? 

Tits McGee --- 15 years ago -

I see Jamie is back. 

5811wife --- 15 years ago -

I could care less that gays serve in the military. My worry is how the military is going to deal with certain situations. 

5811wife --- 15 years ago -

It is, because you don't know that he is looking at you in a different way. I know that all gay men aren't attracted to every straight guy. But tell me that you wouldn't be intimidated walking into a shower full of men, even though they might not be attracted to you. 

Felicia --- 15 years ago -

well, I think it will open up a lot of sexual harassment cases. this was definitely the wrong time to repeal this since we are in the middle of a war. i think the grunt units will have the most issues with this while in country. i'm personally against it. 

5811wife --- 15 years ago -

Get over yourself. I don't give a rats arse if some lesbian wanted to stare at my cooch in a shower, I'm saying there will be people who care and it's going to cause a lot of problems. Like I said before, I could care less if gay and lesbians want to serve. Good for them. I'm just trying to argue the other side. 

5811wife --- 15 years ago -

There will be sexual harassment claims, there will be those who do not want to shower/sleep in the same room with openly gay people. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground