Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Marriage Counseling.

who's talking here?

Vod Kaknockers 2
alfulkerson 1
Giggle Butt 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 1
Kariane 1
*Sarah H* 1
BitBit 2
VA♥girl 1
LakerGirl 1
REDJUMPSUIT 1
BadMomma 1
Lupe 2
SinCityGRL 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Marriage Counseling.

Do you think any couple, no matter what the age, how long they've been married, etc, should go to marriage counseling? Especially if both parties agreed to it.

Yes Vote
 
 88.2% (45)
No Vote
 
 11.8% (6)
LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

Do you mean if they're having problems, or just in general?

If the marriage is in trouble, sure. It doesn't hurt to exhaust all options IF both parties are on board with wanting to fix things.

I will say that I've personally never seen it help long-term. Usually when a marriage is at that point, it's just a matter of time. 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

I don't think it is for everyone, no. I mean if one person doesn't feel comfortable it will generate a whole new set of problems, like resentment, etc.

However, I am starting to think that counseling is great for people in general. Even if you don't go to a marriage counselor together, I think being able to talk to a third party is helpful. For me personally I can tell my friends anything and they will understand. However, sometimes, because they are my friends I won't tell them everything: either because I can't articulate it well enough or for a variety of other reasons.

I think counseling is good because you can just go an talk with someone who doesn't know you, so they won't have any preconceived ideas. They are legally bound to confidentiality and they are probably more inclined to give you a reality check if you need it because they are hearing the story as an impartial 3rd party. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]In my case, my marriage isn't on the rocks or in serious trouble, we're just going to work out a little kinks and to better understand where each other is coming from. Communication isn't our best attribute, unfortunately.
[/i]

Hubby and I went to a marriage retreat hosted by CREDO and it helped alot. Not because we were on the rocks because we weren't but because it allowed us to see what other people are going through and learn a little from them. We also saw that things weren't as bad as we thought.

We both were trying so hard to make it work that we didn't realize we were trying too hard. A lot of the principles the chaplin was discussing were things already in place with us so it was reassuring.

Maybe you should try one of these, the MC pays for the entire retreat including your hotel and meals. 

REDJUMPSUIT --- 16 years ago -

Yep, we go to counceling as a whole family.
We didn't have any problems, it has just given us the tools to communicate with each other and how to deal with the blended family situation. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]BitBit - I agree. I can talk to my mother, my friends, but they are biased. Same goes for him.

We both feel it would do good having a neutral, third party perspective, one who isn't biased, to help us out.
[/i]

This was a major point in the retreat. Don't allow outside influences into your marriage.

A lot of times people tell their friends/family about their marital problems and then their opinion or perception of your spouse is skewed. 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

A lot of times people tell their friends/family about their marital problems and then their opinion or perception of your spouse is skewed.


THIS! This is why I absolutely refuse to ever vent about my husband to family/friends. I love the man and respect him more than anything. That doesn't mean I don't occasionally think he is being an idiot or want to strangle him. There are times that I am an idiot and he should want to strangle me. But, regardless of how upset I am at him, I do NOT want others thinking poorly of him, because a fight or a vent isn't representative of who he is.

That and what is between a husband and a wife should stay between a husband and a wife. **With the caveat of: abuse, adultery, illegal issues, and counseling, lol. I really can't commend a legal obligation for silence enough. 

alfulkerson --- 16 years ago -

If BOTH people want to fix whatever is wrong. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

THIS! This is why I absolutely refuse to ever vent about my husband to family/friends. I love the man and respect him more than anything. That doesn't mean I don't occasionally think he is being an idiot or want to strangle him. There are times that I am an idiot and he should want to strangle me. But, regardless of how upset I am at him, I do NOT want others thinking poorly of him, because a fight or a vent isn't representative of who he is.


I totally agree. My golden rule is you should never badmouth your spouse in front of anyone.
It is just bad juju.

An occasional vent to a close friend about how annoying they are being that day maybe, but no badmouthing. Making them out to be a bad person or sharing their faults is just a no-no.

I must go to bed now. Night! 

Kariane --- 16 years ago -

We talked about it a few months ago. Luckily he was able to discuss things with his father and work out his issues on his own. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

I will say that I've personally never seen it help long-term. Usually when a marriage is at that point, it's just a matter of time.

Not always true, we went to marriage counseling almost 4 years ago and since finishing counseling everything is better, yeah we still have our arguments but it is nothing like it use to be. We actually can sit down and talk it out instead of yelling and shutting down and then not speaking to each other for days.

My parents also went to marriage counseling around their 7 or 8 year mark and they are about to hit 27 years. 

VA♥girl --- 16 years ago -

Not always true, we went to marriage counseling almost 4 years ago and since finishing counseling everything is better, yeah we still have our arguments but it is nothing like it use to be. We actually can sit down and talk it out instead of yelling and shutting down and then not speaking to each other for days.

I agree. DH and I went to counseling 2 years ago, and our marriage is stronger and better than it has ever been. I think a lot of it depends on how good your counselor is. I also think if you have a good counselor, who knows what they are doing, even if both parties are not aboard, it can still work.

Our marriage was on the rocks when we went and the last thing DH wanted was to go share our problems with a stranger and have him/her "judge us". But he went, because I was adament about it, and then at least we knew we did everything we could. Our counselor was soooooo good! DH didn't even realize he was talking to him about our problems and we were finding solutions. It helped A LOT that the counselor had military background and knew exactly how to talk with him.

Hubs now, will even admit it helped wonders having someone there who could point the finger at both of us, instead of one of us (like our friends and family would), and keep us calm to actually listen to each other, instead of getting mad and then shutting down all communication. 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

Do you think any couple, no matter what the age, how long they've been married, etc, should go to marriage counseling? Especially if both parties agreed to it. 

Yes. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

I think a lot of it depends on how good your counselor is. I also think if you have a good counselor, who knows what they are doing, even if both parties are not aboard, it can still work.

Exactly, I really think it depends on the people going to counseling and the counselor.

I don't think that counseling is right for everyone, even if both parties agree to it, I think there are times that it is over no matter what. 

SinCityGRL --- 16 years ago -

My husband and I have been....we weren't on the verge of divorce....just needed to discuss some issues! Lol 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

ive often suggested counselling to people but i also say that counselling does not mean you have a bad marriage, its a means to help people communicate differently/better 

Giggle Butt --- 16 years ago -

We did a short couples thing at church. More of an enrichment type thing. Couldn't do it the whole time because he was training for deployment. We just want to make sure we appreciate eachother. 6 years and still running strong! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground