Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

riddle me this

who's talking here?

Liz~*Celebrating Home *~ 1
Mrs Patch 7
Ruthie 2
Thread Killer 2
B*Bright 1
Mrs. Tiki 2
sofaa 3
BlackBetty 1
Lavender is Good 2
*Sarah H* 2
Crimson Nape Duchess 5
Dorothy Mantooth 1
jacqueline4 1
Starshine79 1
BadMomma 2
whatevergirlツ 7
Lula Belle 3
Housewife Say What 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

If polygamy is illegal in all 50 states why in the world would you do a reality show about it? I get why the producers wanted to do it but why would they risk it all for tv? Sister wives stares are under investigation for felony bigamy charges. The were quoted saying something along the lines of the gain out weighed the risk. 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

That's what I kept asking!! My husband said they probably weren't actually married and just used the title for the show but I wasn't sure. Not very smart... I don't mind people wanting to have multiple partners, that's up to them, but 1 wife per person makes sense as far as legality goes. 

Dorothy Mantooth --- 16 years ago -

Ive never seen the show but maybe they're only "married" by a ceremony/in their hearts, not on paper or legally/officially. 

Liz~*Celebrating Home *~ --- 16 years ago -

I doubt they are legally married, maybe they vowed to each other, but not in a legal ceremony. I dont understand that way if living and how it works. I dont know how some towns get away with it when tv shows have showed how they run reported out of town and such. 

Thread Killer --- 16 years ago -

well... I'm sure there are plenty of men/women out there who have multiple SO's, but how come the married ones are the only ones to be punished? Just IMO.


Technically, he is only married to one of the women so I would think that his local pd would want to try and bring him up on adultery charges, but I thought that polygamy meant that you had multiple husbands or wives so how could any of them be charged for it? 

Mrs. Tiki --- 16 years ago -

I *think* he is only technically married to his first wife and the others are spiritual marriages... 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

From what I am reading he is married to all three of them. Why else would they talk of the risk of possible legal action? 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

In response to the investigation, the Brown family issued the following statement to PopEater: "We are disappointed in the announcement of an investigation, but when we decided to do this show, we knew there would be risks. But for the sake of our family, and most importantly, our kids, we felt it was a risk worth taking." 

Lula Belle --- 16 years ago -

I heard that his father in law is the one who talked him into it or something like that. What I don't get is why would you encourage your daughters husband to basically cheat on her? It all seems very crazy to me. Also he says he wants to come out of the closet so to speak. Why was he hiding it? 

Mrs. Tiki --- 16 years ago -

I heard that his father in law is the one who talked him into it or something like that. What I don't get is why would you encourage your daughters husband to basically cheat on her? It all seems very crazy to me.

His first wifes dad had multiple wives as well.... She grew up in the polygamy lifestyle 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

I heard that his father in law is the one who talked him into it or something like that. What I don't get is why would you encourage your daughters husband to basically cheat on her? It all seems very crazy to me. Also he says he wants to come out of the closet so to speak. Why was he hiding it?

If you watched the show his first wifes father practiced polygamy hence the reason for her lifestyle decsions. 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

I dont know, but they seem happier and more well adjusted than a lot of "normal" marriages I have seen. 

Lula Belle --- 16 years ago -

Oh I see! I haven't got to watch it yet, but I plan to tomorrow. So do the kids call all of the women mom or just their real mom? 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

article from CNN 

Starshine79 --- 16 years ago -

"We are disappointed in the announcement of an investigation, but when we decided to do this show, we knew there would be risks. But for the sake of our family, and most importantly, our kids, we felt it was a risk worth taking."

How would the risk benefit the kids? Financial gain at the risk of possible charges and/or jail time. 

Thread Killer --- 16 years ago -

I dont know, but they seem happier and more well adjusted than a lot of "normal" marriages I have seen. 

Well... when a man has one to cook, one to clean, and one for the boudoir, why wouldn't he be happy? 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

How would the risk benefit the kids? Financial gain at the risk of possible charges and/or jail time.

Has to be a money issue. Why else? To enlighten the world, doubt it. 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

Well... when a man has one to cook, one to clean, and one for the boudoir, why wouldn't he be happy?

Lol. I am talking about the family dynamics and the women. But I see your point. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

Ok...
So please correct me because I am confused ...

SO Bill can be married by a court of law to Suzy. Then he can have a religious ceremony to "marry" himself under the eyes of his God to Anna, Anne, and Anni ---- and that is illegal? Yes/No?

I would think that as long as when he files for his taxes he files as Head of Household for the marriage w/ Suzy and whatever kids they have it would be legal.

Y'know because then Anna, Anne, and Anni can file Single with dependents.

Does that make sense? 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

And another thing - why isn't it ever a woman w/ multiple husbands? It always seems to be a man w/ mulitple wives. Is there an actual reason for that? Or is that just the way it is? 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

I think that's the way polygamy is, Mrs. Patch. Apparently doing the opposite never caught on haha 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

Here is my thinking. He must have legally married all 3 of the wives. How else can the be thinking of bigamy charges? Bigamy by definition is marrying while one has a wife or husband still living and no valid divorce has been effected.

To me it sounds like he actually legally married all the women. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

It always seems to be a man w/ mulitple wives. Is there an actual reason for that? Or is that just the way it is?

butt ugly old men at that

i guess because generally its the menfolk that are the prophets and decipher the double secret probation scriptures/texts that no one else is allowed to read because an angel told the guy to keep the scriptures secret *roll eyes* 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I think that's the way polygamy is, Mrs. Patch. Apparently doing the opposite never caught on haha

haha I can't wrap my mind around how it would even work. 

Lula Belle --- 16 years ago -

why isn't it ever a woman w/ multiple husbands? It always seems to be a man w/ mulitple wives

From all of the stories I've ever heard before this show it's mainly to have more kids and bigger families from my understanding. 

jacqueline4 --- 16 years ago -

I think it's bs that Utah is Now trying to do something about. Everyone in Utah knows where the plys live. Heck they have there own school . The big issue the government had was that thr men wouldn't marry any of the wifes at the court house and all the wives could get welfare and food stamps. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

And another thing - why isn't it ever a woman w/ multiple husbands? It always seems to be a man w/ mulitple wives. Is there an actual reason for that? Or is that just the way it is?

I know someone who has 2 husbands. It is not for religious reasons. She is only legally married to one though. She does call both her husbands. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I don't think I could deal w/ all that man PMS. omg. And the video games! ahhhh no. Well at least they would have someone to always play with. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I know someone who has 2 husbands. It is not for religious reasons. She is only legally married to one though. She does call both her husbands.

Is she happy? 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

Is she happy?

Apparently very happy. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground