Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Dream Act

who's talking here?

Su ^_^ 2
::♥::andrea::♥:: 6
El Doosho 10
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1
Spork Fight 4
Lupe 2
Friday_Night_Lights* 4
Trace 2
JAZZ 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

So I know illegal immigration has been a topic on here before. I am wondering if anyone has seen this and if so what are your thoughts on it?


The Holland Sentinel

Posted Sep 20, 2010 @ 01:06 PM
Holland, MI — Area leaders this morning called for U.S. Senators to approve the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act, or the DREAM Act.



The bill — which will likely be voted on by the Senate this week — would allow high school students who are illegal immigrants to earn U.S. citizenship through service in the armed forces or completion of a college degree.



Area pastor Luis Ruiz, non-profit director Bert Jara and college professor Fred Johnson were among those speaking in support of the act at a press conference organized by lobbying group Reform Immigration for America.



“This act can do a lot toward addressing the issue of injustice, inequality,” Johnson said. “Why wouldn’t we want people to have as much opportunity to contribute to their own country as we do?”



An estimated 2.1 million students would qualify for the program created by the Dream Act, according to Reform Immigration for America.

Copyright 2010 The Holland Sentinel. Some rights reserved


Sorry if it has been posted before! 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

link 1



dream act.com 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

I disagree with it 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 16 years ago -

Nope, I disagree with it as well. Too many loopholes. 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

I am trying to find more info on it, but everything I am finding is from 2007. 

Trace --- 16 years ago -

Don't get me started all the stuff that could go wrong if this is passed! 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

LA times 

Friday_Night_Lights* --- 16 years ago -

I think its a good idea. Why not allow Illegals to become legal if they are working for it? 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

[i]I think its a good idea. Why not allow Illegals to become legal if they are working for it? [/i]

Because if we reward them, what is to discourage OTHERS from coming here illegaly??? 

Friday_Night_Lights* --- 16 years ago -

Its not like it will be for all illegals, It will be for high school students. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

[i]Its not like it will be for all illegals, It will be for high school students. [/i]

OK illegal none the less right?? What's the difference? 

Friday_Night_Lights* --- 16 years ago -

People who will work and pay taxes. 

Friday_Night_Lights* --- 16 years ago -

People that will help the economy, and help our military by joining and serving. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

[i]People who will work and pay taxes. [/i]

With our current unemployment rates?? Do we really need MORE people applying for the few jobs that are out there?? 

Trace --- 16 years ago -

I read somewhere it would apply to anyone under 35 who got a high school diploma or GED.

Talk about opening the flood gates. My mother married someone from Australia three years ago. She's currently living there (legally) and going through the process to become a citizen. In Australia just getting married isnt enough. She has a lot of stuff she needs to do first. We need to take a page from their book! 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

Why reward breaking the laws? Is that really how citizenship should start? 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

[i]People that will help the economy, and help our military by joining and serving. [/i]

IF recruiting was an issue I MIGHT agree, but it isn't. On the contrary, we are cutting our numbers down as well. So why bring more people in when we can't keep the ones we currently have? Not only that, but per the DREAM ACT, they just have to serve 2 years. If this act were to pass, I think it should be a minimum of 4 years, ONLY HONORABLE DISCHARGE and their MOS selection should be limited to Combat Arms MOS's. 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

Sorry I got busy at work.

Too many loopholes.

Agreed on that part, it was already turned down in 2007 for that reason among others.

I think it will not go through this time either, especially with the DOD involved.

I get what they are trying to do, but think the bill needs some revisions. I know some of you might “hang me” for this, but illegal immigration is not going to slow down or stop anytime soon. Some of these people do not immigrate for the sole purpose of mooching of the government or selling drugs , some of them actually came here to provide their children with better lives.

I think if they add some more provisions it could happen in the future.

Then again I am a bit bias on the subject being a daughter of immigrant parents who were granted amnesty in the 80's. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Then again I am a bit bias on the subject being a daughter of immigrant parents who were granted amnesty in the 80's.

I too am a child of immigrants and although they weren't granted amnesty in the 80's, they are citizens now.

I think that we need to take away anything that may be appealing to illegals. Everything from jobs, to benefits, to an education. We can not show a sign of weakness or we will lose......like we aren't already. 

JAZZ --- 16 years ago -

I may be wrong but for right now can't an illegal get citizenship through military already???? I remember this when I was in and i thought it was like this. 

::♥::andrea::♥:: --- 16 years ago -

I too am a child of immigrants and although they weren't granted amnesty in the 80's, they are citizens now.

How long did that take, if you don't mind me asking?

I think that we need to take away anything that may be appealing to illegal’s. Everything from jobs, to benefits, to an education. We can not show a sign of weakness or we will lose......like we aren't already.

So pretty much you want “America” to cease to exist? LOL. You know it wouldn't matter either way.


I may be wrong but for right now can't an illegal get citizenship through military already???? I remember this when I was in and i thought it was like this.


I am not sure, but I thought they were only granted residency. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

I too am a child of immigrants and although they weren't granted amnesty in the 80's, they are citizens now.

How long did that take, if you don't mind me asking?


I think that we need to take away anything that may be appealing to illegal’s. Everything from jobs, to benefits, to an education. We can not show a sign of weakness or we will lose......like we aren't already.

So pretty much you want “America” to cease to exist? LOL. You know it wouldn't matter either way.


I may be wrong but for right now can't an illegal get citizenship through military already???? I remember this when I was in and i thought it was like this.


I am not sure, but I thought they were only granted residency


It took them several years and a bit of money.

Quite the contrary, I want America to survive, but the freebies and opportunities for illegals need to cease to exist.

You can not enlist without being at least a legal resident. 

Su ^_^ --- 16 years ago -

I may be wrong but for right now can't an illegal get citizenship through military already???? I remember this when I was in and i thought it was like this.

I would hope not!!

But I know for sure if you have a green card you can join the military and become "naturalized" for free b/c the Military pays for it :) 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]But I know for sure if you have a green card you can join the military and become "naturalized" for free b/c the Military pays for it :)
[/i]

My mom's godfather went to Vietnam when he got here from Cuba and was granted citizenship later in his enlistment. There are a lot of people in the military who are not citizens but they do eventually become. 

Su ^_^ --- 16 years ago -

My mom's godfather went to Vietnam when he got here from Cuba and was granted citizenship later in his enlistment. There are a lot of people in the military who are not citizens but they do eventually become.

Yes, it's one of the benefits. It costs a lot to obtain a citizenship. It's about 700-800 now and I heard the price is going up. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

i for one think that it can work... i feel reawlly bad for these kids who come here at 2.3 .4 years of age, who know nothing of where the come from- america is home for a lot of these children, and when they hit college they are sol. i think we shouldnt back date it, but move forward with it with kids today... also i think that instead of just armed services, that if they can prove that they are an asset (grades, volunteerism) that that should count for something... for all those that say, oh they are taking our jobs, become more competitive... if anything more jobs are being taken with outsourcing, factories in china, call centers in india. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

I think if they are willing to do 4 years and get deployed then they should be able to get citizenship. There are a lot of YOUNG homeless people who don't want to better their situation, they just want to be bums.

There was a whole piece on the younger homeless people out in PB because of that whole sticker saga --Don't feed our bums-- or something like that. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

There are a lot of YOUNG homeless people who don't want to better their situation, they just want to be bums.


x 1000000 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Sarcasm, since you think it can work, where should those funds come from? 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

Funds for what exactly? Personally, I think that this could open the window for positively... Kids see a chance that if they work hard, whether in school, or work hard for their country, they can gain their citizenship, instead of hiding in the shadows doing nothing productive. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground