Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Soymilk?

who's talking here?

Picky Vicky 2
CourtesyFlush 3
sofaa 1
Abra 12
TweedleDee 1
Carolyn Brown CMT 3
Samantha 1
Jay Elle 2
silverlightstar 1
NotPhased 1
Lupe 1
Sei Con Me 3
snowcrispie 4
Cellulite City 1
Kwalagirl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Abra --- 16 years ago -

I am thinking of switching the entire family (with the exception of the baby) to soymilk. IDK though, I have looked it up through and through on the internet but there are conflicting reviews, opinions, and even "facts". Some sites say it has less fat than cows milk while others say it has more or the same. I also found one site that said it wasn't good for men? That was weird but IDK. I've tried it and it's not so bad, a little taste adjustment for the kids but not bad. I do like it's benefits but don't know if I like that it has more fat than cows milk.

So anyway, I guess my question is.....do you drink soy milk, why or why not? 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

soy milk tastes too chalky for me. Even the stuff from Trader Joe's tastes chalky. I'd rather just drink fat-free milk. 

snowcrispie --- 16 years ago -

Soy milk does not contain animal fat. 

Picky Vicky --- 16 years ago -

I drink Light Vanilla Silk. It takes some getting used to but I like it. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

Soy milk does not contain animal fat.

Yeah I know that but fat is fat, lol. and this is a quote from the internet:

Contrary to belief, soy milk is not fat free. Depending how it is produced, it may have more fat than cow’s milk. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

I drink Light Vanilla Silk.

That's the one I was looking to switch to. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

I give my daughter Silk... her tummy is very sensitive to real milk and she has acid reflux. I ok'd it with her pediatrician first. She likes it. 

Picky Vicky --- 16 years ago -

Buy a carton and try it. Now that I've switched, Lactaid is just gross. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

I give my daughter Silk... her tummy is very sensitive to real milk and she has acid reflux. I ok'd it with her pediatrician first.

How old is she? I won't be switching the baby's milk, she is going to stay on whole for now. The youngest of my others is 6. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

Buy a carton and try it. Now that I've switched, Lactaid is just gross.

I did but it's been a while. I tried to do the switch when my husband deployed (less resistance) but it didn't stick. I like that it can be frozen b/c it's less trips to the store if I buy in bulk. 

snowcrispie --- 16 years ago -

No "fat is not fat". Good fat in your diet is necessary. Animal fat contributes to heart disease. Consider rice milk? 

TweedleDee --- 16 years ago -

I drink Light Vanilla Silk. It takes some getting used to but I like it.


Me too once n awhile...but with a family of 5 who goes through 5 gallons of reg milk a week...soy milk by the half carton wont work :(

Ive had Silk Vanilla and the Chocolate. To ME its thicker and creamier but most people Ive talked to is the consistency that they have to get used to.. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

She is two. She had to have Nutramigen as an infant, and I would give her milk sparingly after she turned one, because she would often spit it up. I still try and give her whole milk every once in awhile, and it doesn't go over well. I ok'd the Silk for her when she was 1 and a half. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

No "fat is not fat". Good fat in your diet is necessary

Ok I didn't word that correctly. I do know that some fat is required in your daily diet.

Consider rice milk?

Didn't think of that....i'll look into it. 

snowcrispie --- 16 years ago -

It also lacks lactose which is difficult for some people to digest.

notmilk.com 

Cellulite City --- 16 years ago -

I had to drink it during my pregnancies. I like it when pregnant. The thought of it now makes me cringe. 

snowcrispie --- 16 years ago -

Good fat: avocado and nuts for instance. Helps raise your good cholesterol which is needed to help "clean your arteries". 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

but with a family of 5 who goes through 5 gallons of reg milk a week...soy milk by the half carton wont work :(

We go through milk fast too. Sam's has a 3 pack for about $6 which is the same cost as 2 gallons. You get a 1/2 gallon less but I am thinking it's healthier. 

Carolyn Brown CMT --- 16 years ago -

I drink soymilk everyday. I hated the taste when I was younger, but now I'm really into it. My mom does as well. I dont think we switched for any health reasons, I just started to like it in espresso drinks because the vanilla soymilk covers up the bitterness of the espresso, in my opinion (and makes "health" cereals less bland).

I haven't noticed any side effects, but I have read that soy mimicks estrogen. That is most likely why they say its not great for men (in large quantities though, small amounts probably wouldn't do anything). That's good that you're not switching the baby, once again the estrogen factor can supposedly make children hit puberty faster.

I also recently learned that too much estrogen can be a risk factor for breast cancer? For that reason I've considered switching back to regular milk, but I need to do more research. Its something to consider though.

As for the fat component, they sell light soymilk with reduced fat. The "plain" soymilk also has less sugar but its more of an acquired taste.

My college anatomy teacher who is also a personal trainer is in love with soymilk more than I am. He says his favorite treat if he wants something sweet is a glass of chocolate soymilk. So I dont really know how much it actually affects men or if it is just a possibility. He's a very health conscious man too and brilliant, so I trust his opinion on almost anything, lol.

Chinese medicine as a whole also tends to stay away from dairy products and lactose, so since soymilk isn't dairy some people believe its better than regular milk.

It's good that your doing your research, I guess in addition to asking on here you can ask a nutritionist? They would probably be able to give you a pretty solid answer on whether to switch your whole family. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

Thank You C. Brown, M.T.! I read about the estrogen and men being worried about the breast factor (their breast growing out like a women's if they drank too much of it). I however didn't read anything about it puberty hitting faster and that is something to seriously consider in a house full of girls.

I also recently learned that too much estrogen can be a risk factor for breast cancer?

Didn't read about that either. I did read that it wasn't a proven statement but it is also something important when I am already at a higher risk.

I guess in addition to asking on here you can ask a nutritionist?

Yes, I am actually trying to find someone out here I can schedule an appointment with. 

Carolyn Brown CMT --- 16 years ago -

They should have nutritionists on base, I'm in Colorado right now but my doctor said I could go talk to the nutritionist on the AFB near here. If this base has one, Pendleton for sure has 'em :) Check at the gyms, I think Paige Fieldhouse has nutrition programs. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

I'm not in Pendleton anymore. I am out in 29 and same week appts out here are hard to come by...well at least at the hospital. Haven't looked into the nutritionist on base, thanks for the info though. 

Carolyn Brown CMT --- 16 years ago -

Oh okay :( Well if I meet with one before you do I'll send the info your way :) 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

Thank You! 

Sei Con Me --- 16 years ago -

My two year old has to drink soy or rice milk. The casein in dairy products is horrible with him. As for me and the Hubby, we drink organic milk. 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

Are you trying to be organic? A lot of soymilk isn't organic and therefor is no better than regular milk. I drink both, honestly... but I try to buy it organic.

There are a lot of scary facts out there about soy especially for women. I just have it in moderation aka not daily. 

Samantha --- 16 years ago -

I drink soy milk, but I'm lactose intolerant. At first it was an adjustment, but now I'm fine with it. I actually like it. 

NotPhased --- 16 years ago -

Soy Milk is all that my husband drinks. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

Are you trying to be organic

No. I don't buy into the Organic hype :/ 

silverlightstar --- 16 years ago -

The nutritionist that Bee sees at Pendleton also goes to 29 and Yuma; she's a great lady (Chris).

Anywho, I used to drink soy milk, but I can't get past the taste; we switched to organic whole milk (I'm not too worried about the fat in milk; I barely drink it.).

You should look into rice milk; it's not as bad as you might think (and if there's problems with lactose, rice milk doesn't have it.). :) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

recommendations

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground