Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Your choice to or not to reproduce

who's talking here?

Kristin 1
MylilZombie 1
CourtesyFlush 3
team brian 4
FurMama 9
julie 2
shesfromthevalley 2
Taminator 1
Green Chick 1
Trace 6
Ashley828 1
Jack Hass 8
BadMomma2 10
AJx2 1
DocsWife 2
Cruising4Fun 1
CluelessWonder 8
Bugbite 3
Doo Schnugget 2
LullabiesButterflies 2
SweetThang86 1
LilShutterbug 3
ChefsDoItBetter3 2
Maynard G Krebbs 1
Julianna 2
littlesilverheart 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Your choice to or not to reproduce

I was reading this article on MSNBC -> [url=http://moms.today.com/_news/2011/07/25/7161493-one-womans-childfree-status-update-ignites-facebook-free-for-all]safe linky :)[/url] and it got me thinking, why is the choice to not have children still considered a "taboo"? Why is my choice to live a child-free life for now considered "ridiculous"? I've actually had someone call me selfish before because I don't want children (if at all) for a loooooong time. What do you think (putting aside the "it's not my life, so it's not my right to say anything" option)?

I do think choosing not to bring children into the world is selfish (explain). Vote
 
 8.3% (6)
I think some people were meant to be parents and some weren't, it doesn't make them selfish either way. Vote
 
 87.5% (63)
Other (explain). Vote
 
 4.2% (3)
Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

I have to say other because I felt like you before I had kids.. now that I have him I couldn't imagine life without him. You never know what it's like till you experience it ya know.. so I don't think it's "selfish" but I think life is empty without them. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

I can see how a mom would see it that way.. but I dunno, to each their own. We both thought we didn't want kids, now we are considering a second one. Waiting is a good idea. Get all that stuff out of your system, and see if you're bored yet. My son is currently cuddling my arm and watching wonder pets. I don't even remember what life was like without his little annoying butt. He's like a little tiny friend that just loves me. 

CourtesyFlush --- 15 years ago -

Its not selfish. I never even thought about having kids, and I actually wasn't even sure I ever wanted them. Then we were surprised with my son, and I love him to death, but wish I could waited for sure. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

That's silly for anyone to judge your choice. It doesn't affect them, so why should they care. Of course, the would be grandparents have a little reason to be irked, but nonetheless it's your choice. Before I had kids, I didn't really know whether I wanted to have them or not. If I had known what it would do to my body I would have totally thought twice, but now that I know what it's like to have two amazing little people in my life I would trade anything and everything in the world for them. I just couldn't ever understand that before actually meeting them. Either way, there's no reason for you to rush into it unless you're sure. Experience all you want to, because once you have a kid that all gets put on hold indefinitely. I do wish we had done a little more before having kids. 

SweetThang86 --- 15 years ago -

I think it it perfectly ok to wait to have children or to not have any at all. It is your choice. :) I have a daughter and we are trying for another one. I had my first child at 23 and I am now 25 and I wanted to have all the baby making done by 25 but that was my personal choice. Enjoy and live life to the fullest whether it be with children or without them. :) 

Jack Hass --- 15 years ago -

Betty, you're super selfish for not wanting kids! GAH! ;)

Plus I think you and your husband might implode if you can't get it on whenever, lol. 

FurMama --- 15 years ago -

Betty aren't you 21ish...? I'm 24 and i still don't have kids, by choice. I say your young and you have plenty of time to wait for the right time to have kids. :) 

AJx2 --- 15 years ago -

I laugh at people like that. Just like the ones that say we havnt had kids so must be because we have a troubled marriage. Yea. Whatever. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

i have non breeding friends and its not a issue and ive never questioned it or shoved my spawn into their arms declaring that they will change their minds - some people simply do not want children

personally i didnt think i would ever be a mom, i didnt want children and didnt think i was maternal but then i met my hubby and bred like a damned rabbits 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

If you do not want children and/or do not intend to take full and proper care of them (and not the bare minimum of food/clothes/shelter---i'm talking interaction, love, education, support, etc), then

PLEASE DO NOT HAVE THEM!

I don't care whether you choose to have kids or not, honestly. Although, anyone who tells me I'm dumb for having them because they are so expensive and now I can't afford to go on cruises, etc is going to get a punch in the nose. I'd rather have my kid every day than a cruise a couple times a year! Although, I know 100% that not everyone will feel that way, I do! 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

Although, anyone who tells me I'm dumb for having them because they are so expensive and now I can't afford to go on cruises, etc is going to get a punch in the nose

Lil, i would rather give birth without drugs than go on a cruise - heck i would rather slit my wrists than go on a cruise

dental work

inserting anal thermometers

cleaning public toilets

my list would be very long :) 

CourtesyFlush --- 15 years ago -

Betty saying she's not sure of she ever wants children doesn't mean she is incapable of being a great parent. 

Cruising4Fun --- 15 years ago -

My oldest sister is 45 and she never had kids. She did not have a desire to be a mother. My kids think she is the coolest aunt though because they have a ton of fun with her. She has a great career and enjoys having the freedom to spend her money and time on whatever she pleases. She is happy with her life and that is all that matters. 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

My son is currently cuddling my arm and watching wonder pets. I don't even remember what life was like without his little annoying butt. He's like a little tiny friend that just loves me.


My son is totally my excuse to color and play in the wading pool in my back yard and cuddle and watch cartoons and go to the park/pool/etc. Hehehe. Maybe because I never forgot how to BE a kid :D 

Jack Hass --- 15 years ago -

If you do not want children and/or do not intend to take full and proper care of them (and not the bare minimum of food/clothes/shelter---i'm talking interaction, love, education, support, etc), then

PLEASE DO NOT HAVE THEM!


Slow your PSA roll homeslice, lol. 

julie --- 15 years ago -

My husband and i get asked why we don't have kids all the time. We have been married almost 7 years and just don't want kids right now. My mom had me when she was 35 so waiting another 5 years and being 30 having my first baby doesn't bother me. I think it's everyone's personal choice. For people to say you are selfish for not wanting kids is ridiculous. That argument could be turned right around on them for having kids.
Although, anyone who tells me I'm dumb for having them because they are so expensive and now I can't afford to go on cruises,
Haha that is a horrible argument to not have kids. I have been on one cruise and would Never go on one again. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

in all my years ive only met one woman that told me that she wished she had children and it was her one regret of her life - which saddened me, no going back and do overs in that situation 

team brian --- 15 years ago -

I'm so glad there are other women in the world like me!!! lol I am from Utah and it is DEFINITELY taboo that I am 23 years old, been married 4 years, and don't have any kids and am not planning on having them any time soon. I have been judged and questioned about it. Every one of my friends back home has at least 1 baby, if not 2 or 3, and they are my age. They are always on my case about when i'm going to have a baby, and why I don't want them. I DO want them, but what's the rush? To me it's like, I am 23 years old! What do I want kids for??? I'm enjoying being young, and free from all that responsibility. Idk, just because I'm not all gung ho about having a baby right now doesn't make me wierd, in my eyes anyway. 

CluelessWonder --- 15 years ago -

Me and my husband want to wait until we are a bit older (and I have finished school and stuff) to have kids but yeah there are tons of people that think that because I got married young that we will have kids young. A girl I've known since High School told me the other day "You jumped the gun on getting married so I'm pretty sure you're going to jump the gun on having kids too" Excuse me??? Since when does someone tell me when I'm going to have MY kids??

Every time I say I am going to wait they literally scoff at me and say "Yeah, right". Hey, if we have one before I'm 25 because birth control failed or something then fine, but apart from that I want to wait and I don't think that's selfish at all. 

CluelessWonder --- 15 years ago -

Love? Pffft. All the love they'll need is the intimate interaction between their hiney and the switch off the tree of their choosing.


LMAO 

julie --- 15 years ago -

What i don't get is why people care so much about other people having kids? I don't badger people about why they have kids so back off about me not having any. 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

Lil, i would rather give birth without drugs than go on a cruise - heck i would rather slit my wrists than go on a cruise

I have never been on one other than a dinner cruise. I'd LOVE to go on one. But I love my Smidget way more than I could ever love a vacation. Part of my enjoyment of life is through watching his wide-eyed joy and awe in seeing/learning/doing new things! I never new how magical an anthill could be or how exciting my water-hose was. My son totally helps me appreciate the little moments in life. And those come every day, not just when you're on vacation!

Betty saying she's not sure of she ever wants children doesn't mean she is incapable of being a great parent.

Absolutely! She may someday decide she wants them...or she may be like my best friend and just like to borrow her friends' kids now and then...or she may say "eh, kids are weird, no thanks" forever. NONE of that changes whether she's a good person or a bad person. She's just not the same kind of person as me---and I am fine with people different than me...non-parents can afford to treat me to lunch when we hang out ;) Hehehe. KIDDING :D


My oldest sister is 45 and she never had kids. She did not have a desire to be a mother. My kids think she is the coolest aunt though because they have a ton of fun with her. She has a great career and enjoys having the freedom to spend her money and time on whatever she pleases. She is happy with her life and that is all that matters.

My brother is 25 and if you ask him if he wants kids he just says 'No, my kids would be f'd up!" and then spoils my son rotten! I can live with that :D 

LullabiesButterflies --- 15 years ago -

My aunt never had kids. I don't see anything wrong with choosing not to have kids. Why bring a child into the world if you aren't absolutely sure you want it? To me, that would be selfish. 

Kristin --- 15 years ago -

Both of my brothers in their 40's never want to get married or have children. They prefer to have their careers. 

CluelessWonder --- 15 years ago -

What i don't get is why people care so much about other people having kids? I don't badger people about why they have kids so back off about me not having any.

Thank youuuuuu 

FurMama --- 15 years ago -

I am from Utah and it is DEFINITELY taboo that I am 23 years old, been married 4 years, and don't have any kids and am not planning on having them any time soon. I have been judged and questioned about it. Every one of my friends back home has at least 1 baby, if not 2 or 3, and they are my age. They are always on my case about when i'm going to have a baby, and why I don't want them. I DO want them, but what's the rush? To me it's like, I am 23 years old! What do I want kids for??? I'm enjoying being young, and free from all that responsibility.

X2, I know how you feel. I'm Mormon, 24, married for 3.5 years and no kids. 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

His parents are getting ancy about grandchildren, but my parents are the opposite. My dad had me young and my stepmom had hers young, so they want us to experience as much as possible.

I guess it's because I don't judge someone for having kids, so why should anyone judge for not having kids? I honestly don't believe this society is as "advanced" as it claims to be. It's still kicking around primitive ideas of the roles a woman and man have in the world.


I forgot, you just turned 20 right? No parents should be pushing you to have kids that young. You have so much time. Just because you're married doesn't mean you have to start poppin' out babies, even if it's the norm in the military. I, myself, have somehow fallen into the trap lol But I love my babies and wouldn't change it for anything.

And the more time I spend on the PU the more I learn that people judge others based off of the most minute, silly things. It's a fact of life and I guess it just makes a person feel important and superior. So, you'll be judged for having them too young by some and not having them by others. 

Jack Hass --- 15 years ago -

I know how you feel. I'm Mormon, 24, married for 3.5 years and no kids. 

Really? I always pictured you as being a salty wife Pizza. 

CluelessWonder --- 15 years ago -

It's just right now, a one-year-old pitbull is child enough for us right now! Lol


That's another thing, we have a 15 month old very hyper Siberian Husky puppy. If I had a baby right now I'd be freaking out about her and baby getting along, etc, etc 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

forgot, you just turned 20 right?

if any of my kids wanted to make me a grandparent when they are only 20 i would want to smack them behind the head! there is SO much to do in your 20's - travel, education and experience life before you have to get serious raising another human

power to those that did become parents in their early 20's (my siblings included) but im guessing there arent many people that sit back and say "geez i wish i didnt party, travel and enjoy life at college so much" 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground