Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

How do you break your baby's heart?

who's talking here?

Kristin 2
Mrs.Mommy 1
Kariane 1
Abra 2
MomOf2inCali 2
hailstorm 1
UnicornsR4Gangstas 1
Hokey*Pokey 4
Nyki 10
~Lauren~ 3
Green Chick 1
Patrice 1
Pics Photography 1
ImHisPrincessL314 1
Doo Schnugget 14
emysmother 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

and take away the pacifier?

My son is an avid binky user. He's 16 months old and I kept telling myself I would take it away at 8 months, then 10, then a year, then after my birthday. It's time that thing has to go. He doesn't talk at all, even though he only uses the binky for naps and car rides and rarely through the day when he's cranky. He just seems to have absolutely no interest in talking and I am going to do everything I can to get him up to where he should be for his age. He is way far ahead in every other area but talking.

How did you do it? I took it away tonight, and he has been in his crib an hour talking to himself, then he'll cry for about 2 minutes, then quiet, but he can't seem to get to sleep without it. He's not screaming though.

Any tips? 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

I was about to say I would not, but I reread and saw the not talking bit.

Have you talked to his doctor about it? I would see what the doctor says first... 

Kariane --- 15 years ago -

I've heard cutting the tips off make it so they don't want them anymore. 

Patrice --- 15 years ago -

Just cold turkey it. It will take a few days to a week. You'll go crazy, but it really is the best way. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

take it now while you can lol. If he isn't screaming then just take it.

If that doesnt work then ONLY give it to him when he's going to bed. I had to do that with one of mine. He was obsessed. I'd tell him it was only for night night (he was old enough to understand - so embarrassed I just admitted that) and if he wanted it, he was going in his crib. Eventually the bink wasnt as awesome as he thought if he had to have it only when sleeping and eventually he quit using it all together.

Stop buying new ones too (not saying you do) when you lose one. 

UnicornsR4Gangstas --- 15 years ago -

Don't give in. All kiddos will fall asleep sooner or later. Might just take him longer. Good luck! 

Pics Photography --- 15 years ago -

My mom used to tie ours to the back door and if we wanted it we's have to sit there and watch everyone play...she said if we fell asleep sitting there she'd just pull it out, we'd cry so she'd rock us and sing, and then put us in our bed once we fell asleep again. 

emysmother --- 15 years ago -

mine is 20 months and is still on the binky... only in the car and while sleeping..we are weaning her now, with hopes of it being gone 100% by her birthday :) Before we cut it down to bedtime and car rides, she would remove the binki from her mouth to speak, and then put it back..lol awww I cant break her little heart.. but the dentist said by 2 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Have you talked to his doctor about it? I would see what the doctor says first...

I haven't. But I don't really like his doctor. And she seems to always be in a hurry. I tried to ask her yesterday, because he has had like 5 ear infections and when he was seen at the NH last week they said he had scarring in his ears, so I thought maybe it has to do with hearing. His doc at the follow up said his ears are fine and not to worry about it. Ugh. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

My mom used to tie ours to the back door and if we wanted it we's have to sit there and watch everyone play...she said if we fell asleep sitting there she'd just pull it out, we'd cry so she'd rock us and sing, and then put us in our bed once we fell asleep again.

This is really weird, lol I have never heard of doing this. It seems like it would work though! 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

take it now while you can lol. If he isn't screaming then just take it.

If that doesnt work then ONLY give it to him when he's going to bed. I had to do that with one of mine. He was obsessed. I'd tell him it was only for night night (he was old enough to understand - so embarrassed I just admitted that) and if he wanted it, he was going in his crib. Eventually the bink wasnt as awesome as he thought if he had to have it only when sleeping and eventually he quit using it all together.

Stop buying new ones too (not saying you do) when you lose one.


Gah, I don't want to get to the point where he is old enough to ask me for it. I take it and hide it whenever he has it during the day but he will walk around whining looking for it. I didn't buy any new ones for the longest time but the one he had got all cracked and gross so I got him two last month. That's the only ones he has, and it took me a good half hour to decide to even buy those ones lol 

Hokey*Pokey --- 15 years ago -

if you only use it during nap times and car rides it shouldn't be keeping him from talking. At 16 months some kids just don't do a lot of talking. My eldest didn't, and now I can't get her to stop! lol! all kids do different things at different times. I wouldn't worry about it 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

I cut my son binky n he put in his mouth then took it out like wth mom. Then I said its yucky throw it a way n he did never used one since. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

I cut my son binky n he put in his mouth then took it out like wth mom. Then I said its yucky throw it a way n he did never used one since.

wow, maybe that's worth trying! I'm just soooo sick of having to rely on it. Like when he was younger he couldn't do ANYTHING without it in his mouth. It was a lifesaver when he was tiny, but now it's a pain in the butt and makes me feel like I failed as a parent for giving it to him so much when if he didn't have it maybe he would be talking more. 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

Ick - I love having my daughter see a civilian Pediatrician who takes his time with us/her.

Good luck with whatever you decide to do!!! I am not looking forward to that day when it comes... 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Have you tried giving it to him in only certain places?

First start at home, if he wants it, he can have it but he can't go outside.

then move onto a single room, if he wants it he has to stay in that room.

Then move onto one spot, like a chair, if he wants it, he can stay in that room and on that chair.

Eventually he'll get tired of being there and let it go so that he can play or w.e. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

if you only use it during nap times and car rides it shouldn't be keeping him from talking. At 16 months some kids just don't do a lot of talking. My eldest didn't, and now I can't get her to stop! lol! all kids do different things at different times. I wouldn't worry about it

I guess mostly I feel bad because we have like 4 or 5 friends with kids the same age as my son, and they are ALL talking at least a little. Mine doesn't even say mama yet. He doesn't say anything at all. He pretends to talk in his baby language, but my friends' kids at least say mama, dada, bye bye, no.. little words. He won't say anything. It makes me feel like I failed him. 

Mrs.Mommy --- 15 years ago -

I've heard cutting the tips off make it so they don't want them anymore.

This is what i am going to do 

Abra --- 15 years ago -

Never compare your child to other children. If you have a concern, get a better dr. and talk to them. Children develop differently. 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

I was amazed at how good he did. He didn't even cry for it at night.

Or you could tell him the binky fairy needs them for the new little babies. Have him collect them all put them in a bag go outside n put them somewhere after couple hours go outside n check to see if the fairy came . Replace the binkys with his favorite treat. I saw this on supernanny. 

Hokey*Pokey --- 15 years ago -

I guess mostly I feel bad because we have like 4 or 5 friends with kids the same age as my son, and they are ALL talking at least a little. Mine doesn't even say mama yet. He doesn't say anything at all. He pretends to talk in his baby language, but my friends' kids at least say mama, dada, bye bye, no.. little words. He won't say anything. It makes me feel like I failed him.


my daughter didn't say mama until 17-18 months. then once she started talking, every day she would learn more and more. maybe he's just focusing his attention on learning other things right now 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

Some kids develop slower. He will talk soon enough then u will wish he didn't 

Hokey*Pokey --- 15 years ago -

Or you could tell him the binky fairy needs them for the new little babies. Have him collect them all put them in a bag go outside n put them somewhere after couple hours go outside n check to see if the fairy came . Replace the binkys with his favorite treat. I saw this on supernanny.


i did that! I even had the nuk fairy "call" and told her what my daughter wanted instead of her nuk. so that night, the nuk fairy came, took her last nuk, and gave her a teddy bear in its place. my daughter asked for it a couple times after that, but was satisfied that I didn't have it, so she didn't beg for it. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Or you could tell him the binky fairy needs them for the new little babies. Have him collect them all put them in a bag go outside n put them somewhere after couple hours go outside n check to see if the fairy came . Replace the binkys with his favorite treat. I saw this on supernanny.

I've heard this idea, I just think he's too little to understand it quite yet.

Never compare your child to other children. If you have a concern, get a better dr. and talk to them. Children develope differently.

I know I should not. But it's really hard not to. I'm going to change his doctor to someone I think will have a little more time for him, because it concerns me. I don't want to turn a blind eye to something that looks like a problem and find out it's much more of a problem than I had thought. I had a cousin who didn't talk until very late and later they found out that he had tumors in his brain that inhibited his speech and caused him to have aspergers syndrome, but they didn't find out until he was 4 and they took him to a speech pathologist for his delayed speech. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

my daughter didn't say mama until 17-18 months. then once she started talking, every day she would learn more and more. maybe he's just focusing his attention on learning other things right now

This is what I'm hoping. He's way better at doing things with his coordination and fine motor skills than other kids his age, like he can put a key in a car door and he can put his own shoes on, but he just will NOT talk. I talk to him all day long too, and try to get him to say things when he is wanting something. 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

Your are not a bad mommy. I know its hard not to think. But your not if u were you wouldn't care he isn't talking at this age. Or if his Dr cared. Kids are different. My husband likes to compare a two year old who knows the alphabet to our son saying he is late n not on time. No that child is just more advanced. I hate when he does it bc our son is intelligent. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Your are not a bad mommy. I know its hard not to think. But your not if u were you wouldn't care he isn't talking at this age. Or if his Dr cared. Kids are different. My husband likes to compare a two year old who knows the alphabet to our son saying he is late n not on time. No that child is just more advanced. I hate when he does it bc our son is intelligent.

Thanks :) I think I'm going to get rid of the stupid binky anyway, just for my own sake to not feel like I caused it in any way. And he's going to the doctor again to talk about whether he has bad ears or just doesn't feel like talking. 

Hokey*Pokey --- 15 years ago -

. I don't want to turn a blind eye to something that looks like a problem and find out it's much more of a problem than I had thought. I had a cousin who didn't talk until very late and later they found out that he had tumors in his brain that inhibited his speech and caused him to have aspergers syndrome, but they didn't find out until he was 4 and they took him to a speech pathologist for his delayed speech.

Is this your first child? Just wondering because with the first, the moms tend to do a lot more worrying :) I think 16 months is too young for you to be worrying about his speech and possibly having medical problems because he hasn't talked yet. Just relax and enjoy him, and enjoy the silence while you still have it, because it won't last much longer :)

At his 18 month check up, if he still hasn't said anything yet, bring it up to the doctor.

For what it's worth, at my daughter's 18 month check up, they referred her to speech therapy. But I wanted to give her a little more time before I did that. By her 2 year check up, she was talking talking talking and the nurses were even surprised at how well they could understand her 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

I believe its he just doesn't feel like talking. Did you teach him sign language when he was a baby? Bc I heard if you did they just use that instead of words. He is fine just take one day at a time. 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Is this your first child? Just wondering because with the first, the moms tend to do a lot more worrying :) I think 16 months is too young for you to be worrying about his speech and possibly having medical problems because he hasn't talked yet. Just relax and enjoy him, and enjoy the silence while you still it, because it won't last much longer :)

At his 18 month check up, if he still hasn't said anything yet, bring it up to the doctor.

For what it's worth, at my daughter's 18 month check up, they referred her to speech therapy. But I wanted to give her a little more time before I did that. By her 2 year check up, she was talking talking talking and the nurses were even surprised at how well they could understand her


Yep, he's my one and only. I worry about every thing. I'm a worry wart by nature, so when it comes to him it's like x1000. You're right, his check up is coming up soon anyway. I think I'll bring it up then and hopefully he will be saying a little more by then. I have always felt so blessed that he was born healthy, so anything that messes with that scares me to death. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground