Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Spinoff from Selfish POLL.

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
KeyboardWarrior 1
MylilZombie 1
Texicano 1
Dorothy Mantooth 1
3Js mommie 1
LakerGirl 2
Jane Wayne 12
Mary Swanson 1
Green Chick 3
Barbie 2
Trace 1
JAZZ 6
DoctorDonna 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
Mrs T Goin to Jail 1
Aidens Momma 1
Whitness Protection Team Betty 4
xVivaLaDollx 1
Sarah H 1
justvisitin 1
Momma2Fur 1
Scrappy 3
Doo Schnugget 3
a1826532uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Spinoff from Selfish POLL.

Dou you think it is selfish to have an epidural during childbirth?

Yes Vote
 
 2.9% (2)
No Vote
 
 88.4% (61)
Other Vote
 
 8.7% (6)
Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

Dou you think it is selfish to have an epidural during childbirth? 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

what they do to their body?? 

ahh, but it's not just THEIR body. That's where it gets tricky.... 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

I just gotta say, i love the anonymous polls... on another forum I'm on when someone votes on a poll it bumps it to the top to show they're the last one that voted.

It's much more truthful this way. 

Texicano --- 15 years ago -

The 'ol lady had one with our first son but with our second one I'm sure she felt it all. He just came too fast. They gave her a different shot that would help but I don't even think that kicked in on time. She's #1 in my book! 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

I would have to say other... Because it is all a matter of opinion. I wanted to do it au natural, but they couldn't keep his heartbeat on the monitor, so I was confined to the bed. I think if I would have been able to walk around, I could have done it all the way.

After the epi tough, I progessed fairly quickly, and once I got down how I needed to push, he was out. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

but they couldn't keep his heartbeat on the monitor, so I was confined to the bed.

The research on this is really interesting.

It says that a continuous fetal monitor is no more effective at monitoring a baby than a handheld doppler used once an hour. 

Mrs T Goin to Jail --- 15 years ago -

She's #1 in my book!
awwwwww


I chose other. Ive never really thought about it. My son was born via emergency c-section and was a month early. I can see both sides of the argument, though. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

It says that a continuous fetal monitor is no more effective at monitoring a baby than a handheld doppler used once an hour.

Except the baby could flatline while waiting an hour for the next doppler check up. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

got most of my belly slimy. 

and then it starts to itch!!! 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -


Except the baby could flatline while waiting an hour for the next doppler check up. 



Just what the research shows.... The American Association of Birth Centers doesn't allow continuous monitoring during labor because of this. 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

what did this poll spinoff of? 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

I would rather have the fetal monitor as opposed to my baby's heartbeat dropping and not knowing until an hour later when it was too late. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Here ya go... From this source

Main results
Twelve trials were included (over 37,000 women); only two were high quality. Compared to intermittent auscultation, continuous cardiotocography showed no significant difference in overall perinatal death rate, but was associated with a halving of neonatal seizures although no significant difference was detected in cerebral palsy. There was a significant increase in caesarean sections associated with continuous cardiotocography. Women were also more likely to have an instrumental vaginal birth. Data for subgroups of low-risk, high-risk, preterm pregnancies and high quality trials were consistent with overall results. Access to fetal blood sampling did not appear to influence the difference in neonatal seizures nor any other prespecified outcome.
 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

what did this poll spinoff of?

THIS one 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

So this "selfish" thread came from someone who has never herself had a baby naturally? I am asking because it is easy as heck to say "I am sticking this out and not getting epi" way easier said than done. Many women want to have the baby naturally and in the midst of pain decide they are unable to. Unless you have felt the pain and had a baby naturally IMO you can't say you would be able to handle. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Here ya go... From this source


See, this is the type of stuff nobody wants to know about. It always amazes me that people will ignore the facts because of a predisposed idea that has been placed into the mind. In this case, the medical community has convinced our society as a whole that birth is dangerous... or that it is an illness. It's really not.... it is because we make it so.

And, when facts do arise, change takes so long because people are not willing to learn or change. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

So this "selfish" thread came from someone who has never herself had a baby naturally?

did you even read it? 

MylilZombie --- 15 years ago -

No I said I never wanted one until I had amanda kidney infections and labor DO NOT go together! so at least it helped me some but I'd still like to go all natural again like I did with my 1st daughter, if I ever get the chance to have kids again lol 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

did you even read it?

Read the link green chick posted. You started that one right? I was asking if you have had a baby naturally. You said you had one with an epidural unaware of the side effects it could have on your baby, I didn't see where you wrote you had a baby naturally. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Read the link green chick posted. You started that one right? I was asking if you have had a baby naturally. You said you had one with an epidural unaware of the side effects it could have on your baby, I didn't see where you wrote you had a baby naturally. 



It wasn't started as a condescending thread and nobody made it that way so don't jump in and turn it ugly. 

3Js mommie --- 15 years ago -

I had my first with an epidural, but I had a great nurse standing by my side the entire 6 hrs telling me to breathe!

My 2nd and 3rd one both had epiduals, with the 2nd one I held out until I was in tears and screaming, the 3rd on I got because my dr didn't think I could handle the pain(and I ended up having a bad reaction to it)! 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

See, this is the type of stuff nobody wants to know about. It always amazes me that people will ignore the facts because of a predisposed idea that has been placed into the mind.

Or it could be that it was useless information to most people? I am very into trying to do things as naturally as possible, but I also like to live in the reality that less babies die now than during times where they did not have good OB care, and good hospitals. I realize you are a crusader for having babies the old fashioned way, but not everyone is comfortable with that.

Who cares whether a study was done showing that monitoring a baby once an hour is just as good as sitting on the monitor during labor? Unless you go take your case to the hospitals to change things, it isn't really an issue. It does not affect the baby to be on a monitor. If it was something that was risky, or unsafe then ok. So really, you don't have to just assume no one wants to know "facts" when it is irrelevant. 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

It wasn't started as a condescending thread and nobody made it that way so don't jump in and turn it ugly.

Since we are on computer and you can't tell my tone, I will say I am honestly asking a question. I was wondering if you yourself had a baby naturally. It was a question not "making it ugly" 

justvisitin --- 15 years ago -

Well said Green Chick! 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Who cares whether a study was done showing that monitoring a baby once an hour is just as good as sitting on the monitor during labor?

I care =/ I care because I wish more people had cared before ME so that I didn't have to go through what I did.

The study is saying that there is an increased risk of cesarean and use of instrument such as forceps because mom is not able to get up and move around to 1. manage pain and 2. speed up labor by physical activity such as walking. For people who DO want to do it the "old fashioned" way, the way our bodies were meant to do it, it's useful information.

It's not irrelevant that the US has the 2nd highest infant mortality rate of developed nations... there is a reason why. And it's the way we're treated in labor and the way that our babies are delivered, or cut from us. I guess I don't get why with such shocking numbers women don't want any change. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

I say, let the mothers do the research and make the decision they think is best for themselves and their baby. It's not our place to judge, or say what is best. Every woman's labor is different... 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

I was wondering if you yourself had a baby naturally

I had a traumatic 13.5 hour labor induced by cytotec, hyperstimulation of the uterus with tripled contractions with less than 45 minutes of epidural. And yes, I pushed him out 'naturally' with the epidural off.

There was nothing natural about my birth, it was all synthetic. But if you mean did I feel the pain of labor and pushing a baby out unmedicated? Yes I did. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

The study is saying that there is an increased risk of cesarean and use of instrument such as forceps because mom is not able to get up and move around to 1. manage pain and 2. speed up labor by physical activity such as walking.

Because of a monitor? Maybe these people are not having their babies in a Naval Hospital. They don't want you coming in until your baby's head is hanging out ;) lol 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

Well I will be having my second baby in July. I would like to have my baby naturally. I am hoping I am able to, if not then I know that an epidural is there for me and I won't feel bad at all if I need to have it. Guess I am one selfish bish. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Guess I am one selfish bish. 

Guess I did interpret your tone correctly by your other posts :) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground