Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Breed Specific Legislation

who's talking here?

Donny 4
Skittles 2
Taminator 2
Barbie 1
Smile 2
sheBERRY 1
Amurikan Lunatic 1
CharlieWhiskey2 1
Love My Doxies 12
alwaysright 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Breed Specific Legislation

Hello PU, I am doing a paper on Breed Specific Legislation Laws and I would like your thoughts on the issue since some of us live in a banned breed community. I am open to any opinion or insight you may have, either for or against the issue. For those of you that would like to help me by allowing me to conduct an interview (via phone or in person) please PM me. THANK YOU EVERYONE =]!!!

Agree with Breed Banned Laws Vote
 
 38.5% (15)
Disagree with Breed Banned Laws Vote
 
 53.8% (21)
Thinks other breeds need to be added (specify) Vote
 
 5.1% (2)
Neither (Please state) Vote
 
 2.6% (1)
Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

Hello PU, I am doing a paper on Breed Specific Legislation Laws and I would like your thoughts on the issue since some of us live in a banned breed community. I am open to any opinion or insight you may have, either for or against the issue. For those of you that would like to help me by allowing me to conduct an interview (via phone or in person) please PM me. THANK YOU EVERYONE =]!!! 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Please tell me why you do or do not agree with these laws. 

Skittles --- 14 years ago -

I don't think there should be a generalization. I think housing developments and insurance companies should do it case by case. I think every dog no matter what the breed should have to pass the good canine citizenship test and if they can't then they shouldn't be allowed on base. I also think in order to identify passed dogs there should be a special tag like that of a rabies tag that is added to the collar with a number and it's inputted to a data base so if a dog is caught without the tag it is immediately quaranteened until the owner can provide proof of passed test and if they can't provide proof they should have to pass there on site of impound. If they can't pass the test I think the owner should be told you either surrender the dog or vacate the property and only then be allowed to retrieve their dog. Granted, that would take a lot more effort on people's part, but it would do the job of weeding out the bad dogs from the good. My dog was attacked by a golden retriever, my neighbors dog was attached by a bull mastiff and a miniature schnauzer. This is all just my feelings towards it though. 

Skittles --- 14 years ago -

To add to my comment, I also think it should have to be mandatory for them to retest annually. Some times dogs develop issues over time. 

sheBERRY --- 14 years ago -

I think they should add other lil dogs. Just because it's 'cute' doesnt mean it's not aggression. I nearly had my face ripped off by two different little dogs on two separate occassions and neither was provoked.
We own a dog that has the coloring of a rott. He is a therapy and alert dog. I think its crap that we may lose benefits and entitlements because other people couldnt take care of their dogs.
Also, from what we are being told, there are loop holes in the order. Possibly... lets hope so. 

Donny --- 14 years ago -

Breed banning is ridiculous, but i agree with temperament testing.

Honestly EVERY breed should be temperament tested in my opinion regardless of where you live. Aggressive dogs come in all shapes and sizes.

0 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

Awesome info Ladies =] Thank you 

Donny --- 14 years ago -

The CGC is not a true temperament test, though. It's primarily a test of obedience training. If it were a temperament test, you'd be able to use the suffix TT with your dog's name (example "Capone, TT").

You are correct, and Capone's title is actually: Capone, ATTS
:) 

Taminator --- 14 years ago -

I put think other breeds need to be added...anything that is less than five pounds and yipps every where it goes should be on the list ;) 

Barbie --- 14 years ago -

Honestly EVERY breed should be temperament tested in my opinion regardless of where you live. Aggressive dogs come in all shapes and sizes.

x2 

Taminator --- 14 years ago -


Honestly EVERY breed should be temperament tested in my opinion regardless of where you live. Aggressive dogs come in all shapes and sizes.


This is very true, I have a pug that has a bit of an attitude. My neighbor has two small dogs that are mean as heck, I cant take my dogs out without them yipping at the windows or trying to lunge at them. 

Amurikan Lunatic --- 14 years ago -

I think chihuahuas need to be added to that list. They are more aggressive than just about any other dog out there. They get away with acts that would have a larger dog put down, only because they are small. I think that is no excuse, they should be handled with the same accord larger breeds are. 

alwaysright --- 14 years ago -

I am all for BSL 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

I am all for BSL

Alwaysright- Can you explain why? If you feel your opinion is too sensitive for PU you can always PM me, I am trying to get every side =] 

Donny --- 14 years ago -

I am all for BSL

Alwaysright- Can you explain why? If you feel your opinion is too sensitive for PU you can always PM me, I am trying to get every side =]


Be leery of new accounts, most times it's someone bored trying to stir a pot. 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

Thanks Donny. Hey would you be interested in doing an interview since Capone is one of the breeds that's banned. I would love to get an owners perspective that has had to go through all the legalities and testing. 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

BSL is nothing more than socially sanctioned discrimination born of fear, hysteria and ignorance.


can I quote you in my paper BabyBear =] 

Donny --- 14 years ago -

Thanks Donny. Hey would you be interested in doing an interview since Capone is one of the breeds that's banned. I would love to get an owners perspective that has had to go through all the legalities and testing.

Sure, most of my story is already on here though.

Thread Link #1

Thread Link #2 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

Thank You =] TONS!!!! 

CharlieWhiskey2 --- 14 years ago -

I understand why they do BSL. I understand that due to money they don't do as suggested above.
That being said, I don't agree with BSL. Yes, ' some dogs are more inclined to aggression than others and yes, they are sought out by bad owners who use them only for those aggression undertones but if the owner is responsible and pays for whatever proof of good behaviors people may need then why not? Well, its because most owners aren't responsible and don't do as needed so they had to solve the issue and blanketed entire breeds.
My opinion is proved if you go to aa dog park in Stuart Mesa. Some dogs are so aggressive and their owners don't care. There is a sign of rules right there that says no aggressive dogs.
I think BSL will stay until a better solution that is cost effective is found. 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

One of the problems with the BSL's is the extra expense of enforcing these restrictions. This is going beyond Camp Pen, and looking at this as a national issue. Italy has deemed such breeds as Welsh Corgi, Border Collies and Newfoundlands as Dangerous breeds, and has banned them.
I do agree with you Charlie, that MOST of the issue is misuse of the breed, ignorance on the owners part, or just plain old irresponsibility. But we are essentially punishing a certain breed(s) because of a human variable, these breed laws are similar to racial profiling of humans... and the fact is that no one county, state or country (in the case of Italy) can agree on what constitutes as a 'dangerous breed' by identifying the same breeds. 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

I can tell you as a vet tech that I would much rather deal with a angry german shepherd or pit bull, than to have to take a chihuahua out of Mom's lap. I have been bitten by a variety of breeds (goes with the territory of being a Vet tech),and I am way more cautious of a Chihuahua or a Jack Russel than I am of a deemed dangerous breed. I have been bitten by these two breeds repeated times, once requiring a hospital stay. 

Smile --- 14 years ago -

i believe all breeds should be required to be tested. the owner should also have the dogs on the home insurance policy. it should all be on the owner [cost wise] if they can not do those simple thing or are not willing to the do not deserve to be dog owners. 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

I would really like to hear from those who are FOR Breed Specific Legislation Laws. Why are you for them? Have you been attacked? What good do you see in them? Do you believe they should be reformed?

Both sides are greatly appreciated =] 

Smile --- 14 years ago -

see i am for them but they should have exceptions that i listed above. i say make all dogs dangerous until proved otherwise. 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

see i am for them

I understand Smile =] I need more like you in the PRO/FOR category =]

I have to take a side and be able to defend said other side as well 

Love My Doxies --- 14 years ago -

BUMP =] 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground