Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Do I let her fail or not?

who's talking here?

Mandy May 1
*All Smiles* 1
Lil 05 1
gbob 1
Rebecca 1
Calimommy 1
CharlieWhiskey 1
YouReallyThinkSo 1
lousmom 1
southernheart88 1
Vivacious St0rm 1
shellibeth 1
Ipswitch 1
lovin my fam 1
Poe 1
HavingaBOY 3
Making Changes 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lil 05 --- 15 years ago -

So, my teenage daughter seems to failing her Ag. Biology, English, and Computers course. Math so far, she's doing good in. The classes she's failing are mostly due to not turning in her assignments either on time or not at all. I shouldn't have to be after her about her grades/schoolwork. She's in High School for gosh sake. She doesn't ask for help when she doesn't understand something. She doesn't write down any of her assignments(she has a agenda book).I'm exhausted from fussing at her about the same old stuff. We've even taking things away from her, grounded her. I don't want to see her fail, but at the same time, I feel she needs to. Maybe that will put her butt in gear. But then again, it could make her think that failing is ok, no biggie. Anybody else have this problem? Any suggestions on how to fix things? 

lovin my fam --- 15 years ago -

I go through this with my 6th grader and hope he'll grow outta it by high school. This year I told him I was not going to be ontop of all his stuff he needs to start being more responsible. So I have bit my tongue abt every bad grade he brings home. I told him if there is a d or f on his report card his xbox goes. And if grades dont come up next marking period, tv goes. And so on... Now thats its almost the end of marking period I see him panicking and studying a bit more. But he does say, I know I am losing my xbox, I see I have to work harder next MP to get it back. 

*All Smiles* --- 15 years ago -

I had the same problem with my sister in the beginning of the year last year (she's a sophomore now). She just didn't seem to care AT ALL. We ended up having a meeting with the guidance counselor and talked about why completing work/homework is so important and why caring about her grades should matter especially because she really wants to go to college. I did take away her cell phone and computer until her grades improved. I had to make her life miserable in order for it to start to click that life could be so much better if she just did her homework and projects. For her it was never a problem of not understanding the work, it was just pure laziness and the desire to spend her time doing other things. 

Vivacious St0rm --- 15 years ago -

Do you praise her for the good work she does? Or just criticize the failing grades?

The reason I ask, is because growing up I was a 3.8/ 4.0 student. It bugged me that my parents never said any praise or even that they were happy with how good of a job I was doing. It got to the point that if they didn't care and were just going to critique every little "bad" thing I did, that it just wasn't important anymore. So I stopped trying, I figure if they are going to yell/punish me for something it might as well be worth it.

I'm not saying this is something you are doing, but just giving you a different view.

I also don't think you should let her "fail" if you give up, then she really won't think it matters. 

southernheart88 --- 15 years ago -

Reinforcement ! Will there be bigger consequences if she fails ? Failing is not okay specially not in high school, just try and do what you can. 

HavingaBOY --- 15 years ago -

ehhh...its iffy because one F can hinder her going to a good college in HS, its way more important than jr high. What you could do is maybe make her REALIZE what happens when you fail...


This worked for my older sister, so it may help you out too, this is what my mom did:

she gave her the bare needs. Soap, tooth brush, tooth paste. no hair care products of any kind...


Took away:
-her make up
-blow dryer, curling iron, etc
-let her have 5 pairs of pants, 5 tops, and 2 sweaters
-took away ALL her other clothes
-one pair of shoes allowed

Pretty much what she did was give her a life of a FAILED person. She made my sister live like she would if she FAILED at life. And it WORKED haha...and whenever she got a good test, or report she would get something back. She even had her volunteering at soup shelters to witness the extremes. 

HavingaBOY --- 15 years ago -

and also, be very energetic when she does have a positive test. and reward her with an item back, or a few depending on what the test or project is 

Calimommy --- 15 years ago -

I did very bad in high school. I really had a tough time getting it. Don't give up, don't let her fail. I tried to get mini scholarship they looked at my high school grades and I did not get it. I wish my mom could and would have helped me. 

gbob --- 15 years ago -

My 6th grader is the same. She doesn't want to do homework or forgets to turn it in, etc.
I get so frustrated!! She doesn't seem to care and when something is taken away she just gets super angry. I have 2 older girls and they were nothing like this. I know I shouldn't compare but it was a heck of a lot easier raising the 2 than it is just the 1! 

YouReallyThinkSo --- 15 years ago -

Its because she isnt doing her work? So she gets it just lazy and doesnt do the work? I got like that in high school, I picked which classes I wanted to work at and ones I didnt. Squash it before it gets worse. My mom wasnt to bad with punishment for failing so it got to where I decided I would just ditch the class. After that my mom got strict. She grounded me until all my grades where passing grades. I couldnt go anywhere, watch tv, really do anything. All I was aloud to do was sit in my room and do school work. But it didnt take me long to get my grades passing cause I hated being grounded and teachers were willing to work with me as long as I was putting the effort out. 

Rebecca --- 15 years ago -

I side with GrowingAbaby's idea simply because that ish works! My mother-in-law did it to my husband once when he was a kid and he straightened up real quick and she never had a problem from him again. She may get really pissed or pretend not to care in the beginning but eventually she's gonna want something or miss something you take away. This tactic only works if you really commit to it. Under no circumstance can you give in. I think if my mom had done this to me and my brother we would have done better in school. Good luck! 

HavingaBOY --- 15 years ago -

The reason it works so well is because after a few days...you WANT your make up!! you dont want to be at school in the same clothes...its embarressing! and then they have to tell people WHY they dont get their stuff and thats even MORE embarressing! 

Making Changes --- 15 years ago -

i can agree with what everyone saying, and yes storm does have a point.. It also helps if you have ANOTHER person besides yourself,try and explain to your child that it IS a necessity to do well in school--mainly because...school is just as important as a JOB (9-5) i think that you shouldnt come down on your child because of their failures...just emphasize how it also reflects and makes you (as a parent) feel..because at the end of the day..you want to be PROUD of them, you want to help them but if they arent going to listen or take your constructive criticism,then whats the point of being their parent (besides you supporting THEM) remember that you are their first TEACHER...

I had that problem with my niece who is now 12...she was failing,talking in class,disrespecting her teacher and most important...she made my sister cry with disappointment. I had to tell her that it was wrong--to defy the trust of your mother who always supports you..i got deeper in dept talking to her..telling her that, if you dont take your brain seriously and try and teach YOURSELF knew things..no1 will. AND THAT HER FRIENDS that she has now, in her class, will move forward. Also that if she keeps acting out in class and her studies-->shell be the one theyll leave behind,instead of progressing with them..im not sure what "the excuse is" but i hope that it all works out for you...
be patient with your children..let them know that you are there for them regardless but--> tell them that failing in school and not handing in homework or assignments (not caring)is the same as YOU,mom, NOT GOING TO WORK,GETTING THAT CHK TO BUY WHAT THEY WANT...NOT FEEDING THEM... (like you dont care) but you DO...they their job is to care! Try talking to them like their adults..because that is IN FACT what you are raising them to be..
(((hope it helps))) 

lousmom --- 15 years ago -

Sit down with her and see why she isn't doing what she should be. Maybe she is having a difficult time and is embarassed to say anything. My junior year was tough. I was stressed out to the max and my parents didn't seem to care. 

Mandy May --- 15 years ago -

I agree with what has been said so fat. I just went through some of this with my daughter. My daughter who just graduated and left for college was haveing some issues during her last 4 yrs of school. Her senior year she almost failed her ap stats class. She had no motivation. To me failure is not an option or a choice this when it comes to school. We had our struggles trust me lol. It was not fun but she did it. I did everything I could to keep her going, We talked ALOT, I stayed in touch with her teachers and counselor at times I even waited in the parking lot for her after tutoring and we only live 2 blocks away from the school. Just to let her know that I am there supporting her ( checking up lol). Her senior year was tough but she knew that she HAD to make grade and GPA for get accepted into her college. towards the end she busted her rear in fear of not getting into the college of her choice. But not with out our pushing. Luckly we were blessed with a teen who hated her phone and computer and going out with her friends being taken away. So we only had do do it a few times last year and only threaten the rest lol. High School is so important and the pathway for the rest of her life. If they mess that up it maked things so much harder for them when they are older. I know as a mom I was at my wits end so many times and afraid( terrified) of her future. Its a scary time in our babies lives. But I did have to remind her and my self that to fail is not an option. To me I would let my daughter fail in sports, crafts, and other decisions that are important life lessons but not when it comes to education. Sucks going through this but this to shall pass lol. 

Poe --- 15 years ago -

Maybe she's having a hard time concentrating for whatever reason, you could always take her to a psychologist and see if somethings up that you don't know about. 

Ipswitch --- 15 years ago -

I second the make up thing
My mom did that to me! i hated it then but now i realize it worked. Good idea.
As far as letting her fail. Dont. If she doesnt care then her failing wont make a difference. I did it as a teen.
And an F will mess up her GPA.
If she plans on going to a university an F will put her out of that real quick.
I was super motivated my first two yrs of HS. I got straight A's then my jr yr i ran into some trouble with my parents divorcing and i didnt care. I got two f's an a D. Ruined everything.
I think most people wish they would have
tried harder. I wouldnt let her fail. She will so regret it later if she does. good luck! 

CharlieWhiskey --- 15 years ago -

Find someone who never graduated high school and show her what its like. I was a screw up in high school and my mom would tell me daily how ill regret my actions one day. I regret them now because rectifying my mistakes is much harder.
She also needs to learn that right now, school is at the bottom of her priority list but now isn't worth forever. Bad grades = no college or working really hard at a community college and still not being able to get into a really great college = low paying job
A lack of work ethnic now could lead to a life of low work ethnic which works now but it doesn't when she's thirty and working hard for $8 an hour 

shellibeth --- 15 years ago -

The same thing happened with my daughter. She wasn't quite failing, but her lack of responsibility was driving me crazy. I am abut to graduate from grad school with honors and I could never understand why she just didn't seem to care.

So I met with people at her school...and ending up getting her tested for ADD. Turns out since my daughter has never had any hyperactivity or behavioral issues (so she doesn't have ADHD) we missed seeing her need until she was 12. Her doctor told me a lot of kids are diagnosed in middle and high school.

Now my daughter takes a pill every school day and she has made a complete turn-around. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground