The ending to the book would have made the movie better,
x 2!
i was sitting on a plane reading this, sobbing (i mean SOBBING) my heart out and the hostess was concerned and asked if i was ok. i held up the book and she teared up and said "oh i KNOOOWWWWWWW". i was a mess - i was also pms'ing but i loved the ending because it was so anti-hollywood
did we watch the same movie? I dont see that movie as beautiful, I thought it was disgusting what they put that child through. I cant imagine justifying doing that to a healthy child just to prolong the life of one of your other children. I just thought it was selfish and disturbing.
cant imagine justifying doing that to a healthy child just to prolong the life of one of your other children
the part in the book where the lawyer gets a huge file on the sick sister and asks where is the healthy childs file and they say they dont have one/she doesnt have a case worker - that rams it home how she was a grow your own spare body parts child for me :(
as a parent I know we all would want to do whatever we could to save our children but I could never do that at the expense of another one of my children.
It wasn't about her not wanting to help her sister or being used by her parents, guess I saw it differently since I HAVE had cancer. ITs my opinion as we are all entitled to,
I dont have kids. But I could imagine i would fight tooth and nail to save my child. But the fact that they went out of their way to make another child for the purpose of a donor. Wow.
It wasn't about her not wanting to help her sister or being used by her parents, guess I saw it differently since I HAVE had cancer.
I never said she didnt want to help her sister. I was just saying that its sick and cruel to do that to your child to try and save the other.
If she was grown and could choose for herself it would be different but she was a child who had her childhood taken away and spent so much of it weak and sick because of the choices her parents made.
It doesn't matter what the point of the movie was, everyone views a movie and comes up with an opinion of it for themselves. Thats my opinion about that movie.
for me it was about the healthy child never having a choice. sick sister needed a kidney (i think it was the kidney) and mom instantly starts booking surgery to take the spare from the healthy child without even discussing it with her!
plus the sick child was over all the procedures - as horrible as it is, not everyone is meant to survive an illness. we all have our time/path and we cant ward off the inevitable
BadMomma2 --- 4 sec ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments for me it was about the healthy child never having a choice. sick sister needed a kidney and mom instantly starts booking surgery to take the spare from the healthy child without even discussing it with her!
plus the sick child was over all the procedures - as horrible as it is, not everyone is meant to survive an illness. we all have our time/path and we cant ward off the inevitable
i have very little empathy for the mom in the book
Sweetcheeks --- 4 sec ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments Great scRappy so why did u start an argument about MY opinion? Please re-read your response to my opinion and insert foot in mouth ;)
I wasn't starting an argument I was asking why it was a beautiful movie and I meant that towards anyone that thought that. I was voicing my opinion because that's what everyone does on this site. They read a thread and discuss. I disagreed with your comment and said what I thought about the movie.
I wasn't starting an argument I was asking why it was a beautiful movie
i remember having a disagreement with a friend over the movie Awakings. she thought it was beautiful because these people were able to come out of their catatonic state for a short amount of time and spend time with their families where i saw it as cruel to give their families a few weeks of happiness and then take it away