I am off for the night. The decision of a revolt or adding mods (I will do so mysefl) will be made tomorrow.
I just need more feedback from Ash Logan's, Mrs. Patch and all of you.
If you want to be a MOD, pm me your reasoning and why you would be good at it.
We want the right people in the MOD position(s) that will follow the guidelines. I don't want to have to do this all over again. This is why this is taking time to get an answer. I want to make you all happy.
As a past MOD said, "this is not a popularity contest."
First the community proposes people to be elected (I think everyone on the site is automatically proposed, I could be wrong), the people that are proposed either accept or reject the offer. The ones that accept to be in the election are than voted upon amongst the community.
Ultimately, the Admin and Adam can decide who goes in or goes out. I can even decide if I wish, to add MODs at my own discretion without having a revolt or any voting at all.
As a moderator the lines were never ever clear of what you guys wanted moderated. Every time we would ask the response would be a C&P of the same vague guidelines.
As long as you are going by the guidelines of the site, everything will be fine.
Again: Will there ever be less vague guidelines? The community needs them, and so do the mods, in order to have a leg to stand on when the 'backlash from the community' occurs.
The admins on this site are undermining the authority of their volunteer mods by not being more concise.
You are either missing, or purposely avoiding the question.
Your definition of a personal attack and an opinion are probably different from mine...
But I think you should be able to distinguish between the two.
I think one thing that new/present MODs need to keep in mind is to try not to take part in things that will turn into a fight. MODs need to stick to the guidelines and keep the thread from getting to an attacking level.
You can have your own opinion but no one should ever be afraid to post something in fear of being attacked by someone on this site.
So, is there a difference between "IMO, Shelly looks like a whore" and "Shelly is a whore". The first is clearly an opinion and the second is a personal attack, obviously.
Yes, but nobody should be calling anyone a Whore in the first place.
Kara, i'll help you understand what people are talking about in regards to "What guidelines do the mods follow?"
Here is the famous "rules" that are always quoted that everyone on here agrees are vague and left to personal interpretation which ultimately causes issues with MOD inconsistency when editing/deleting/locking & icing.
Quote:
They set a good example of fairness, kindness, and goodness for the rest of the community. They remove pornography, swearing, bad language, explicit sexual references, and other inappropriate comments. They ice users that need to be removed from discussions due to rude, mean, or personal attacks. .
Okay what is the ADMIN definition of the following terms?