Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Gender Neutral Baby?

who's talking here?

Mrs Patch 1
FixDaPix 1
Turkeys Mama 1
sofaa 2
LakerGirl 5
DoctorDonna 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
Basia 1
Momzilla 1
Turquoise 1
Obey the golden rule 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

What do you think of this?
Pink or Blue??


Personally, I think it's way too extreme, and I also disagree with them allowing their older son to dress and act like a girl. I feel that the parents are letting their own idealism take precedence over their children's well-being. I believe a parent's role is to guide a child in the right direction, while still allowing them to develop a sense of individuality. These people are letting their son have too much control, imo. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

The "unschooling" frightens me more than keeping their child "gender neutral". I am all for letting your children be who they want to be, but they do need guidelines.

I think maybe the parents are focusing far too much on gender. Blowing the issue out of proportion. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it's too much. If I have a son and he wants to wear dresses, I will let him. I want my children to always feel they can be true to themselves. That's not to say I wouldn't explain to the son that it is not the "norm" and that kids will give him a hard time but ultimately it will be his choice. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

The thing is, he's not just playing dress up. He's almost assuming a full-time female identity. If my adult son or even teenager told me he was gay or transgendered, etc. I would respect him and love him unconditionally. I just don't think a child of that age can make that decision for themselves.
Sure I want my son to be happy, but I don't let him do every single thing he wants. Sometimes that makes him mad or unhappy, but I am acting in his best interest.
If these people's son was in a traditional school, instead of being "unschooled" at home, he would be teased mercilessly for dressing like a girl. It's not in his best interest to be allowed to forego his gender at this point in his life. Just my opinion. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

I thought this was the kid that was on Oprah. That kid knew he was a boy but always felt he was a girl. Maybe some kids just know when they're young. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

I don't agree w/ either the unschooling or the gender neutralization. If people want to raise their kids that way, that's their problem. 

FixDaPix --- 15 years ago -

I wasn't unschooled, but homeschooled and a HUGE part of our schooling was not based on what was written in books. I soaked it up like a sponge. I passed every state test with flying colors because we lived what we were taught, not just "going to school" like it's a job. If I could, I'd homeschool my boys in a heartbeat. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

So this discussion is very interesting to me, and I just have a few hypothetical questions for those who are okay with what these parents are doing.

A) Would your husband also be okay with your son assuming a female identity like the boy in this article?

B) If your son expressed to you that he wanted to dress like this at all times, would you allow it? Would you let him wear a pink princess dress to a USMC family day event? 

Turkeys Mama --- 15 years ago -

If my adult son or even teenager told me he was gay or transgendered, etc. I would respect him and love him unconditionally. I just don't think a child of that age can make that decision for themselves.

My brother is gay. He says when he was 5 he knew he was different from all the other boys he went to school with. His gay friends (both boys and girls) told me the same thing. I believe they could know they are different. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

He says when he was 5 he knew he was different from all the oth boys he went to school with. His gay friends (both boys and girls) told me the same thing. I believe they could know they are different.

Well, gay and transgendered are two different things. I guess I should have kept my example to transgendered. Most gay guys I know don't see themselves as female or want to dress as a woman. I agree with you though that many people know they are different from an early age. I still don't think a child is capable of making such a life changing decision as to assume an opposite-sex identity. There are too many social and psychological issues that accompany that type of decision, and a child is not emotionally equipped to handle something like that. 

Momzilla --- 15 years ago -

I hate judging anyone elses parenting, but I do hope they realize what they are doing may have long term effects on the kids. It's one thing in my opinion to let your kids express themselves and "be different" when they understand being socially outcasted, but for a child who may not understand, I would probably keep the cross dressing and nail painting at home. (Just my opinion though) 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

LOL Sarcasm, was that your son weighing in on the issue?

No one has answered my questions. I really want to know if anyone actually says they and their husband would allow a male child to wear a pink princess dress to a USMC family day. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

I personally think it's cruel and selfish to impose a sort of social experiment on your child(ren) like they are doing. I do not agree with it one bit and think they are going to do more damage than good with this. 

Basia --- 15 years ago -

I don't see anything wrong with the gender neutral aspect. 

Obey the golden rule --- 15 years ago -

I think that what the parents are doing is great. We start to develope our identities at a much younger age then many people think. A lot of our gender stereotypes are drilled into starteing in infancy. I think it is very healthy and inspiring for these parents to allow their son to express outwardly the gender that he feels he is internally. When I first saw this family on Oprah, I brought it up to my husband (we have lots of interesting conversations like this. We both agree that if we have a child like this boy that truly feels and consistently expresses his belief and feelings that he is a girl, then we would support him and allow him to dress as a girl in public. Granted we would explain that some people are mean or not understanding and that to many it isn't normal but who's to say what's normal. 

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

I don't really care for this parenting method. No i won't limit my daughters to girly toys/sprorts etc and the same will go for my sons however.... not identifying them as a gender seems so extreme. I feel like this is an explosion waiting to happen. What if the kid grows up believing that they are one gender only to learn that they are the opposite? What if the child feels as though they can flip flop genders? Although im not an expert on gender roles I did learn in college that they were extremely substantial to shaping a person's personality. I encourage freedom of parenting by pretty much all means but this is one case where i'd have to strongly disagree with their choice. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground