Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: good idea?

who's talking here?

Mrs Patch 1
Mommy2Angels 1
FurMama 1
Giggle Butt 1
Kariane 1
BlackBetty 4
Lavender is Good 2
DPkindaGIRL 1
MissMaggy 1
MrsFear 1
Jay Elle 1
Jane Wayne 1
USMCFunSize 1
Barbie 1
Just Sayin 1
DoctorDonna 1
Paula 1
JessesGirl 1
Jack Hass 1
NoSugarAdded 6
Momzilla 1
LLLong12 1
DocsWife 1
Momma2Fur 1
Scrappy 1
MasonsMama 5
Chocolate Sprinkles 1
ImHisPrincessL314 1
GuessWho 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: good idea?

so my girls have been wanting to be more independent out of the stroller and walking, which is fine with me except for the fact that there is two of them and one of me most times. I have always hated those little harness backpacks but not im seriously thinking about investing in them. I just have a mixed feel like i feel bad having my children on a leash but at the same time i cant continually be bending and grabbing and chasing, not to mention the stroller is heavy enough and they HATE it they would much rather walk. what are your feeling on these backpacks? do you view parents that use them as not "having control"? do you think they are degrading?

I think they are a bad idea and degrading to the child Vote
 
 16.1% (9)
I think they are a great idea Vote
 
 46.4% (26)
Mixed feelings towards them as well Vote
 
 37.5% (21)
BlackBetty --- 15 years ago -

so my girls have been wanting to be more independent out of the stroller and walking, which is fine with me except for the fact that there is two of them and one of me most times. I have always hated those little harness backpacks but not im seriously thinking about investing in them. I just have a mixed feel like i feel bad having my children on a leash but at the same time i cant continually be bending and grabbing and chasing, not to mention the stroller is heavy enough and they HATE it they would much rather walk. what are your feeling on these backpacks? do you view parents that use them as not "having control"?
do you think they are degrading? 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I can see why some people may need them but all I can think when I see them is good lord your child is not a dog lol. 

DoctorDonna --- 15 years ago -

It is a good idea when you have to handle two and are going for a walk.

But I still feel bad for any kid who is wearing one, lol. 

Chocolate Sprinkles --- 15 years ago -

I think they are pretty smart actually I would love to get one for my littlest BUT the only thing im worried about is what other people will think about me as im "walking" my children (i know i shouldnt worry what they think though but...) Its easier than having to bend over and hold their hand or chase them around when out in public.

They are better than they use to look they use to just be a harness. Now they have cute little back packs. :) 

NoSugarAdded --- 15 years ago -

 

Mommy2Angels --- 15 years ago -

My girls loved theirs. We don't use them anymore(they're 5 &3), but when we did, my youngest would get mad if she saw hers and I told her she couldn't wear it. We had the cute animal ones. We had a monkey and a pink dog. 

NoSugarAdded --- 15 years ago -

holy mess i cant even read my own post sorry ladies :/ 

BlackBetty --- 15 years ago -

It is a good idea when you have to handle two and are going for a walk.

But I still feel bad for any kid who is wearing one, lol.

see me too like i think its soo cool to give them that "freedom".... but i have seen so many ppl abuse them and i just feel like they have a bad rep. I would never like drag my kid in it ever but i have seen it done. I just dont want it to backfire like, the girls come up with some sinister way to make the harness an evil sinister twin game against mommy lol. Im thinking about just going for it cause my belley isnt getting smaller and the girls arent getting any calmer, we just need a happy medium lol. 

Just Sayin --- 15 years ago -

Gripsterz , but this doesn't allow for you to wrangle your kids and they can just let go anytime... 

BlackBetty --- 15 years ago -

ya i like that for an older kid but my girls would lose interest wayy to fast with those lol 

MrsFear --- 15 years ago -

Gripsterz
They have ones similar that they were on their wrists so they cannot get separated I think things like that are a lot better then a leash lol 

Kariane --- 15 years ago -

Don't worry- I'm thinking about getting something like that too. The boys want to walk everywhere if they can but usually one is going one way and the other is going the other. 

MasonsMama --- 15 years ago -

So, I totally thought they were absolute evil. Until I had my own kid. It's my theory now that I would rather have a kid who CAN'T get out of my reach than a kid who takes two steps into the street and gets hit and killed by a car. I would rather people look at me as THAT parent than him be injured in any way. My son is 15 months old, he started walking at 9 months so he is good at running and fast. I can't ever keep him within arm's reach and he will NOT hold hands. He hates being in his stroller as well. I bought him the backpack one which is actually just a regular kids backpack that you can hook the line to. He loves wearing it. And when he is out with lots of other kids or in busy places or potentially dangerous situations it's been a lifesaver. There are times when I can't always be holding him, and he's struggling to get down and walk at times, and this has been a lifesaver. I do NOT overuse it and rely on it to watch my child, but I do keep it with me in the car so if he is just really wanting out of the stroller or to walk then he has the ability. I see no harm in using it when you have more than one child or a child who is absolutely insane and refuses to hold your hand. How old are your girls? 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

I love them my girls like to run opposite directions and it's hard to catch both of them and drag my son around in a stroller. They love wearing them they carry there leapfrogs around in them. 

LLLong12 --- 15 years ago -

My Mom had me on a leash thingy because I was apparently hell bent on trying to kill myself. I once knocked myself unconcious in Target from running into an I-beam. She also liked to by me jackets or shirts with hoods on them so she could grab the hoods to stop me. If my kid is anything like me, and my Mom hopes they will be, I will be using one too. 

MasonsMama --- 15 years ago -

My Mom had me on a leash thingy because I was apparently hell bent on trying to kill myself. I once knocked myself unconcious in Target from running into an I-beam. She also liked to by me jackets or shirts with hoods on them so she could grab the hoods to stop me. If my kid is anything like me, and my Mom hopes they will be, I will be using one too.

This is how my son is. I always put him in the large part of shopping baskets because he will jump out. He still tries in the bigger part, one time I turned to put the bags in the car and when I turned around I caught his ankle while he was on his way head first to the concrete. He has absolutely no sense of fear. 

FurMama --- 15 years ago -

one of me most times.

this made me giggle.

My parents use them on my sister and i when we where younger. it was an older style though, it was a strap that went around our wrist. i personally liked it because it meant i could walk on my own and i didn't have to hold their hands... 

MasonsMama --- 15 years ago -

I also tried the wrist strap but my son sees it the same as holding hands, and he flips out and throws a fit. So it was a no go for us. 

Paula --- 15 years ago -

Both of my boys had them, and LOVED them. My boys are 19 months apart. For me, with my husband being gone quite often, it was a safety issue, especially in large crowds at amusement parks, festivals, and such. My boys do NOT run off, and they always willingly hold my hand. I'm very overprotective, so I just have this fear of my child being snatched away even if I'm holding their hand. So, this gave me added comfort, since they were holding my hands while wearing these.

I had this man yell at me for child abuse one time while I was coming out of Walmart. I put my youngest in the stroller since he was sleeping, and my oldest asked if he could walk. I didn't want to push a buggy and a stroller, maybe that was lazy but oh well. So, I let him wear his backpack and he was SO happy he got to walk around with it. We were coming out, and this man with only 1 child yelled at me that it was child abuse to have my kid on a leash. My child was safe, yet he didn't have ANY control of his child, that was acting out and not listening and ran in to the parking lot. I went off on him and told him that my child was perfectly behaved even while wearing the harness, yet his was acting out and was almost hit by a car. Then I asked him if he wanted my sons harness so that he could control his child. He had NOTHING to say after that, and the 2 greeters standing at the door started laughing and told me they thought it was wonderful that I was so responsible and had control over my child. It wasn't about that, my boys just loved the freedom of being able to walk, and they loved their little backpacks! 

DocsWife --- 15 years ago -

I think most parents will agree that they are a good idea when used properly. It doesn't mean you can drag your child around like an untrained puppy or just hold onto the strap and not pay an ounce of attention to them. It's just a way to keep your child safe and secure while simultaneously allowing them a sense of freedom. I think most of the people that think they're "degrading" most likely don't have a child that is of walking age but doesn't know how to keep themselves safe. 

BlackBetty --- 15 years ago -

How old are your girls?
18 months and sky has been walking since 8mos and marley around 9. and like youu said they get booking! not to long ago marley was running down the couch and totatly didnt stop soon enough and flipped forwad off the couch. uugggg they are my monsters lol 

Jay Elle --- 15 years ago -

I would rather use those, then have my kids run out in the street and get hurt. I think they're perfectly fine. 

NoSugarAdded --- 15 years ago -

In my case I have a 14 mnth old and she learned very quick you walk with mommy or you go straight back into the stroller there are alot of times when she test that i dont use one because I do only have one. 2 would be a whole diff story you cant be in to diff places chasing kids so I think it could be usefull in teaching them limits IMO 

Momzilla --- 15 years ago -

I ALWAYS used one in airports, carnivals, piers, etc. Anywhere it would be real easy for her to hurt herself or get lost/kidnapped. I've been yelled at countless times for treating my child like a dog. If that were true, the "leash" would be around her neck. We called ours the love rope or safety rope. Leash is so negative. It was a life saver in the airport. It only means you realize you are human and can't ALWAYS control your kids. Keeping them happy, under control and safe should be the #1 priority and anyones opinion shouldn't be the deciding factor. 

DPkindaGIRL --- 15 years ago -

I've been considering getting one for my oldest, she's 20 months and HATES being in the stroller now. I also have an 8 month so it's difficult for me to hold him and chase after her. Hubby thinks they are mean and degrading so he's been fighting me on it, but he's always gone and I feel trapped because I'm scared to let her walk around in public places. 

MissMaggy --- 15 years ago -

I think they are hilarious. I can't help but giggle every time I see one. On a more serious note, to me they show a certain level of laziness on the parents part and/or lack of parenting skills. 

Lavender is Good --- 15 years ago -

When my youngest got to the point that he always wanted to walk but I was nervous about being in very busy public places allowing his independence while still keeping him and his siblings safe I decided to purchase a kinderkord. It has a wrist strap for both parent and child so nothing can be accidentally dropped. The cord retracts and lengthens as the child moves around, and you can still hold hands etc. It is simply another level of safety while allowing them to feel big and independent. 

NoSugarAdded --- 15 years ago -

those who do use them or have at what age does dicipline take the place of the backpack leash or wrist thing ?? Just wondering not trying to be sh!tty 

JessesGirl --- 15 years ago -

I felt the same way, I have two little ones and the youngest hates to hold my hand when we are walking! She runs away from us and doesn't like to stay close at all!! The last time we went to the zoo it was a nightmare! Neither of them wanted to be in the stroller where I could keep them safe and when they were out I spent the whole time looking back and forth from child to child and chasing the baby around!

We will totally get one the next time we go to anyplace that is that busy!

For me it is about safety, I would not use it for everyday stuff, like shopping or anything, just for places like the zoo or going for a walk when we are near the road! 

MasonsMama --- 15 years ago -

I honestly don't know when I'll stop using it and use discipline instead, I don't know when he will be old enough to understand because he is my only one. I assume around 2 yrs though he will start understanding safety and knowing his limits for the most part. Right now though he has no idea.

OP, I think your girls are perfect age to use them. I don't believe in using them on a 4 year old (the kids should know better not to run in the street by then.) as long as my son is safe I don't care what people think. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground