Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Calif. court: Merchants can't ask patrons for ZIPs

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 1
MissMaggy 1
shesfromthevalley 1
~Lauren~ 1
Ella Mafayo 1
Momzilla 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110211/ap_on_bi_ge/us_credit_cards_zip_codes

SAN FRANCISCO – The California Supreme Court ruled Thursday that merchants can no longer ask for the ZIP codes of customers who make purchases with credit cards because such requests violate a state consumer-protection law.

The high court's unanimous decision, which says a ZIP code can be used as "personal identification information," overturned two lower court decisions tossing out the lawsuit. It delivered retailers in California a setback that an attorney for one national chain said would likely lead to additional lawsuits.

The decision Thursday came in a lawsuit filed against Williams-Sonoma Inc., whose clerk asked Jessica Pineda for her ZIP code several years ago. Pineda sued the home retailer in June 2008, saying it violated the credit card law and her privacy.

"It's a terrible decision," said Bill Dombrowski, president of the California Retailers Association, which filed a friend-of-the-court brief on William-Sonoma's side.

Dombrowski said it's too soon to know how disruptive the ruling will be to businesses that routinely require patrons to supply their ZIP codes to authorize a transaction.

"It's fraud prevention." said Dombrowski, who added that not all California merchants make the request.

William-Sonoma and many other merchants said they ask for ZIP codes, in part, as a security precaution.

Supreme Court Justice Carlos Moreno, writing for the full court, said the ZIP code is part of a customer's address, which the California law explicitly categorized as off-limits.

"First, a ZIP code is readily understood to be part of an address; when one addresses a letter to another person, a ZIP code is always included," said Moreno, who is retiring later this month. "Otherwise, a business could ask not just for a cardholder's ZIP code, but also for the cardholder's street and city in addition to the ZIP code, so long as it did not also ask for the house number. Such a construction would render the statute's protections hollow."

The Supreme Court said that Williams-Sonoma recorded Pineda's ZIP code in an electronic cash register, which was fed into the company's central database. From there, it used software to match the customer's name and ZIP code with her undisclosed address, information it can use to market its own products and sell to other businesses. That's why the Supreme Court ruled that acquiring a customer's ZIP code violated the California law.

"This really bolsters and further protects the privacy rights of California consumers," said Gene Stonebarger, Pineda's attorney. Stonebarger said not all retailers who request ZIP codes will have to stop the practice.

He said gas stations that require ZIP codes be entered at the pump are exempt because the gas station "doesn't record the transaction." Stonebarger said that information is sent directly to the banks and credit card companies as a security measure and those transactions won't be affected.

The Supreme Court returned the case to the appeals court for further action, which could include assessing damages. Merchants can be fined up to $250 for a first time infraction and as much as $1,000 for additional violations.

Mike Burns, who represents the retailer Michaels Stores in a similar lawsuit said that several class action lawsuits on the ZIP code issue are pending throughout the state. He predicted more will be filed because of the ruling.

"It's going to have a significant impact on California retailers," Burns said. He also said that it's still an open legal question over whether merchants can ask for similar information when patrons are paying with cash, debit cards and gift cards. 

MissMaggy --- 15 years ago -

California is just ridiculous. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 15 years ago -

Do you realize that the fraudulent use of ccs at gas stations are going to sky rocket now?


Why? It says gas stations can still ask for zip codes since they do not store the information. 

shesfromthevalley --- 15 years ago -

That's silly. It's not like it's that big of a deal to give a zip code. :/ 

ALEM --- 15 years ago -

i think most of the retail companies i've worked for have asked for zipcodes at one point or another.
petco
michaels
blockbuster
kohls 

Momzilla --- 15 years ago -

Besides at a gas station I've never been asked for my zip code... good to know! 

Ella Mafayo --- 15 years ago -

I'm not sure why this lady decided to SUE instead of just saying, during the transaction, "I'd rather not say."

I do agree with her that retailers are getting to be rather nosy at the time of purchase now, and it's all for the purpose of sending me junk...junk mail, junk email, and putting my phone number on calling lists (to get around the do not call list. If you have a 'business relationship' with them, they're exempt from the do not call list.)

I'm not one of those paranoid, tin-foil-hat-society kinds of folks, but I agree with the ruling here. Gas stations asking for my zip when I use a credit card are verifying / authenticating the card for the purchase. But having to give my phone number to Toys r Us and my email to Justice and my zip code to Michael's is getting ridiculous. Can I just buy the f*cking thing I came in for without being subjected to the Inquisition?

There's also the matter of the guy in line behind me, who now knows my email / phone number because I have to recite it out loud for the cashier.

I hope more states follow CA's lead on this one. Corporate America needs to settle down a bit with the info harvesting. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground