Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Babies watching TV - Interesting article

who's talking here?

EastCoast 2
Mommeee Drest 7
Tracy 12
ALS MommaKitty 1
sofaa 2
Kariane 1
BlackBetty 1
Vanbam 2
*Sarah H* 2
MomOf2inCali 2
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1
Life expansions 1
saywhat?! 7
whatevergirlツ 1
Patrice 1
Trace 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
smdh 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

saywhat?! --- 15 years ago -

Linky link 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 15 years ago -

That makes sense. I think it also creates habits. I watched a ton of tv as a kid so now i cant even turn it on in the mornings or i get nothing done during the day. When we have kids we are definatly limiting TV and video game time. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

My sisters and I were very limited on how much we were allowed to watch growing up or what shows. I plan on setting limits when I have kids too. As for babies.. they shouldn't be watching TV anyway. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

I just really think it depends on child and parent. We basically have the tv on all day long... mostly on cartoons for most of the day. But he does not sit there like a bump on the log and stare at it all day... he normally runs around and plays the whole time. But I don't think it is hurting him because he will answer the questions asked with the correct answers but when I ask him he just acts like he does not know. He watches the "educational" style programs on Disney and some Nick Jr shows. IMO it is not hurting him because he still LOVES to be outside and play with other childern or just out in our backyard. I grew up watching tv and feel it did not hurt me. I was a very active child playing outside as much as possible and a very active student in school with activites and sports. My motto: To each there own and raise your child the way you feel is best for you and them! 

whatevergirlツ --- 15 years ago -

My tv is usually off all day. When my kids get home it's homework, chore, then tv if it's not a practice or game night. During sport season (3/4 of the year) we just don't have a lot of time. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

I have to keep the TV on for him on quietly all day. My son has Autism and sensory issues. The background noise seems to calm him, but he is not glued to the front of the TV at all. Very much so just background noise... Silence bothers him. 

Vanbam --- 15 years ago -

my daughter is only allowed to watch PPS kids. which is sid the science kid,sesame street, some reading show, i dont let her watch nick jr, or even the disney channel. well take that back. once and awhile she'll see mickey mouse club. but i only like educational shows and TV is only in the morning for her. and most of the time shes not even watching it, its just background noise. she prefers to play and run around.

and i'll add that by the time she was 14months she was already picking up LOTS of words and had NO delayed cognitive development and language. shes VERY smart. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

nick jr, or even the disney channel.... but i only like educational shows and TV

Just curious, so do you feel that those channels and programming are not educational?

My son watches mainly Disney in the morning and I find the programming educational. I do feel some shows are annoying but still they teach some type of lesson. Nick Jr is now what was once Noggin. 

Vanbam --- 15 years ago -

sometimes i dont. i mean i LOVE disney channel, but i was watching a show and they were saying words like "stupid" i dont say that around her and i dont want her picking it up.
plus when i watch them its more for entertainment. shes smart and id rather her sing the ABC;s (which she does) watching sesame street then watch handy manny fix a chicken coop. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

Oh okay I guess I have never heard the morning programming use the word "stupid" but I know the older programming probably does but we do not watch that. My son is smart and also sings along to the ABC's and numbers when that comes on... each show has some underlying lesson or teach shapes, colors, number, etc. Handy Manny does other things then "fix" stiff IMO because of the lessons behind the episodes. I was just curious on your take. 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

Excluding H.T.T. for her son, something to keep in mind: My oldest was home during the afternoons/evenings with my husband (he worked graves) while I went to work. It was all about the tv. Even though she does well in school she still has focus isssues. My other two rarely had the tv on when they were younger and at home with me. We played, read books, went to the library, to the park. I am not a tv watcher so they never got hooked either. They do not have focus issues. It's just something to think about. I don't believe that you can tell a great deal at this age. Wait until they are in school and you will see how all the tv watching/tv's on all day effect them. And I am by no means an expert. They all watch quite a bit of tv now, but my oldest is positively glued to it at times. 

Kariane --- 15 years ago -

I leave our TV on pretty much all day with cartoons on or something I'm interested in. I hate the quiet. But my boys have NO interest in TV. If there is singing/music they will stop long enough to do alittle dance til it's over with and then right back to whatever they were doing. 

Patrice --- 15 years ago -

It's hard to compare my older two. It's like day and night with the two of them. My oldest hardly ever watched TV., atleast not until he was about 2. He has ADHD, devlopmental delay, and motor skill issues. All of those are pretty much unrelated to him watching tv or not being stimulated enough. I interacted with him as much as possible when he was an infant. Around 7 months old my mom became his primary care provider while I was layed up recovering from a major car accident. His speech was delayed, in comparison to his sister. My middle child watched Noggin pretty much exclusively from birth. It was always on for my son, basically background noise. She put her first words together very early. At 3 going on 4 she has an excellent vocabulary, and very good cognitive skills. Not saying the tv is what helped her, but she has learned to speak some spanish from Dora, she was singing her ABC's by 2, etc. I'm sure her brother being 4 years older then her, and doing all those things together helped ton's. Basically I feel TV is a supplement, not a substitute. I never parked my kids in front of it and demanded they watch it. They have picked some things up from it that have been beneficial. Nothing is a s good though as parent/ child interaction. Every child is different, and develops differently. So to be quite honest- who really knows. 

Life expansions --- 15 years ago -

They do not have focus issues. It's just something to think about. I don't believe that you can tell a great deal at this age. Wait until they are in school and you will see how all the tv watching/tv's on all day effect them. And I am by no means an expert. They all watch quite a bit of tv now, but my oldest is positively glued to it at times.

I completely agree.. each child especially at the age of such being infant to toddler is at a stage where all fine motor and gross motor skills are into development, the cognitive skills are in turn in the stages of development as well, I agree that when your child hits the school age stages you will be able to recognize the full development of cognitive and behavioral development,( I am a mother of a 15yr,11yr, and 2 yr old) and all have had and achieved different stages of developments, at a different pace.. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, shows can teach kids things but there are so many other ways that don't involve staring at a bright screen. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, shows can teach kids things but there are so many other ways that don't involve staring at a bright screen.

Yep your right there are... and my child attends preschool programs and we work on his education daily one on one. But he also likes Mickey Mouse and so him watching that and it just reinterates what he is learning is a plus in my book. Like I said he does not sit in front at it and just stares all day long... it might be on but most of the time it is background noise to him while he is playing. I do find it interesting that even if he is not staring at it (meaning he is playing) and a question is asked he will answer it so even without watching it he is at least hearing it and learning. 

MomOf2inCali --- 15 years ago -

We watch 2 cartoons a day and thats it. It is always between Dora, Diego or Kai-Lan. My 2 year old has a vocab of about 10-15 words in both spanish and chinese and can tell you what just about any animal is at the zoo or wild animal park. Not just monkey, but what kind of monkey. Its kind of funny. She can hold a conversation with my 9 year old and her friends, can count in english, and spanish and knows her ABC's. She does dance and gymnastics and we do crafts pretty much every day.
I have a friend that has the tv on all day and her 4 year old just isnt where my 2 year old is. My daughter wont even play with him or her 2 year old bc she gets bored with them. They dont play well on their own, dont talk as well as she does. There is a BIG difference between them and her. I also have a 9 year old and we were the same way with her. Now she goes stir crazy if we are in the house just sitting with the tv on. She does after school activities 5 days a week, and 2 of the days is doing 2 things. She is a honor roll kid. We dont have to fight with her about homework. She comes home and knows even if the TV is on she doesnt watch it until her homework is done, and checked, and correct. I hate cartoons, hated them as a kid and still do. I can see a MAJOR difference between kids that have a TV for a parent and an actual parent interacting with them. My daughters teachers have said the same thing about kids they have in class. 

smdh --- 15 years ago -

spend less time reading to their children or teaching them.

I think that is the key to the article. Parents who let their children watch TV all day and are not sitting with their children and reading to them are depriving them. When school time comes why sit and read a boring book with just words and no moving pictures? I used to allow my children to watch a lot more TV then they do now. However, I came to the realization that if I allow them to sit and watch TV all day now, once they get older and Nick Jr. isn't entertaining anymore they are going to want to sit in front of the TV all day watching MTV or BET. The last thing I want is for my children to be "learning" from those channels. Even Disney channel has questionable content at times. It seems like every time I turn to that channel some young kids are talking about kissing and boyfriends.

Also having the TV on all day in the background in my opinion is not very good for them either. What happens when they have to go to school and sit in a quite classroom and focus? By you running the TV all day your conditioning your children to only function in chaos.

My rule is you sit and watch or its off. You cant do 2 things at once. My little sister has the TV on all day from morning til she falls asleep. She is 7 years old and watches it for 5 minutes gets up, runs around, plays with toys makes a mess and sits back down for another few minutes. Its pretty crazy to sit and watch her go from activity to activity and not ever actually complete anything. She is also constantly wanting to be entertained and not capable of entertaining herself. Whatever happened to hours of creative play? Making forts out of blankets and boxes or finding bugs in the backyard? Since I have reduced the amount of TV my children watch its amazing the watching the games they play and things they create. Their minds were not created to sit in front of a TV all day. Children develop and learn through exploration, adult interaction and play. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

Whatever happened to hours of creative play? Making forts out of blankets and boxes or finding bugs in the backyard? Since I have reduced the amount of TV my children watch its amazing the watching the games they play and things they create.

See my son does all of this and yes the TV is on! I read at least a book to my child everyday and we work on colors, numbers, shapes and ABC's daily. He also has no problems sitting in a room with no TV (or background noise) and play. We do crafts, he loves building things, going outside and digging in the yard finding things, playing outside with other kids... and he still watches TV in the morning. I think he is well adjusted and IMO I just think the interaction with the TV depends on what the parents allow. If they just use it as a babysitter then yes I feel kids might have a harder time learning or developing. But if the parents interact with the programming and their child I think it can help enhance what you are teaching.

No one will ever agree on this topic or feel one way is better then the other so we each raise are kids the way we feel is best for them. Like they say about children reaching milestones... you can not compare your child to others because they each grow/learn at different rates. 

BlackBetty --- 15 years ago -

ditto at karine, my tv is on all day i dont really watch it, its mainly on just to be on i interact with the girls when they want me to, they will bring me books, we read i show the eye, face. whateve 

saywhat?! --- 15 years ago -

I don't think this article is about people that leave the tv on for background noise. It's about parents that let their children sit and watch television all day long. I don't care how many "educational" programs a child watches. It's my opinion that the television is not the best way to educate your child. I did not grow up watching a lot of television. My parents were very selective of what programs we could watch and even then the time was very limited. I believe that the reason I was reading by the age of 4 and writing before I started school was because my mother took the time to teach us things on her own instead of sticking us in front of a television. I think that every parent raises their children the way they see fit and there is nothing wrong with that. I was raised one way and others are raised differently. I, personally, don't feel that I will let my child or children watch a lot of television. 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

I hate cartoons, hated them as a kid and still do.

Thats me. It was very hard to find a cartoon that I actually enjoyed as a child. I would rather have been reading or I remember watching the Saturday morning stuff with my mom, like gidget and those types of movies. My husband jsut shakes his head. He says he has never met anyone who didn't/doesn't like cartoons. Hate em now too. Boringggggggggg. 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

0313Wife, I agree with everything you wrote, I just don't feel like quoting it all. 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

conditioning

This is a very important term in my book that many people many not understand. But if you realize it's importance, you would be more aware of how tv is effecting the children.

*affecting??? 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -


See my son does all of this and yes the TV is on! I read at least a book to my child everyday and we work on colors, numbers, shapes and ABC's daily. He also has no problems sitting in a room with no TV (or background noise) and play. We do crafts, he loves building things, going outside and digging in the yard finding


Tracy, see this is where you lose me. If your son does all of that, why is the tv on? I mean really think about it. Can he not do all of those things w/out the tv on? If he can, then that is awesome news for both you and him. If he cannot, then I think you are missing an opportunity. I just don't understand the whole "my child is fine, I interract with him, I read to her... but the tv is on all day" scenario! 

saywhat?! --- 15 years ago -

If your son does all of that, why is the tv on? I mean really think about it. Can he not do all of those things w/out the tv on? If he can, then that is awesome news for both you and him. If he cannot, then I think you are missing an opportunity. I just don't understand the whole "my child is fine, I interract with him, I read to her... but the tv is on all day" scenario!



x2




In my house for background noise we had music on. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

Can he not do all of those things w/out the tv on? If he can, then that is awesome news for both you and him.

So did you not understand the meaning of "He also has no problems sitting in a room with no TV (or background noise) and play." YES my son can play without a TV on... when I say the TV is on all day it is not always programming for him. I too like to watch TV and I like to have it on when I am doing things around the house. In the AM is when I normally have kid programming on for my son. Like right now I am watching TV, washing clothes, working on Christmas cards, on the computer and my son is in the backyard running around and playing. What is the big deal with having a TV on? My son is not below levels on his milestones. He has accomplished most of them early compared to the average stats. We work on his skills all through out the day. I interact with him all day long but hey he likes to watch Mickey Mouse and so! He is not glued to the TV while it is on he is normally playing trains, cars or whatever toy he wants. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

In my house for background noise we had music on.

To each their own... I personally would rather have Clubhouse Disney on in the morning then music. First off most music is not kid friendly and I really dont want to listen to the same kid songs, over and over and over again. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

I love the music channels on my TV, so does my 2 year old, shes into reggae for some reason LOL. She has two shows she watches Mickey Mouse and Handy Manny. My 2 month old does not watch TV at all and will be just like her sisters where they weren't put in front of a tv until they were at least 1 years old.

I think TV can be ok in small quantity's but ONLY after a certain age and as long as there is a lot of parental interaction as well. 

Tracy --- 15 years ago -

I think TV can be ok in small quantity's but ONLY after a certain age and as long as there is a lot of parental interaction as well.

That's my point but I guess because I said "my TV is on all day" people assume that my son is drooling in front of it all day. He watchs Clubhouse Disney and that is about it but while this is on he is not just sitting there mesmerized by it he is also playing and running around. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground