Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Formula question

who's talking here?

Cayla 1
Mommeee Drest 2
Kariane 2
Abra 2
5811wife 1
Vanbam 1
MissMaggy 1
❤ me 1
Mrs. Taken 1
MelissaV 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
Crystal K 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

MelissaV --- 16 years ago -

So I've always heard if you're going to skimp on something for baby it should never be the formula. But, the other day I was at Costco and was comparing their Kirkland brand with the Similac and Enfamil and the labels are almost completely identical. Enfamil has a little more of this, Kirkland has a little more of that... They're so close and Kirkland is half the cost of Similac.
Any opinions on this? 

MissMaggy --- 16 years ago -

The ingredients could be of lesser quality even if in the the same quantities, i would ask your ped. 

5811wife --- 16 years ago -

EVERY can of baby formula must meet FDA regulations.
It’s called the Infant Formula Act . It basically means that the “safety and nutritional quality of infant formulas are ensured by requiring that manufacturers follow specific procedures in manufacturing infant formulas.” In short, whether you buy Enfamil or Target brand, your baby is getting a product certified by the FDA as good and healthy for your baby. And as long as you buy a formula with iron, you’re fine. All you’re really paying for is a fancy label…and at an extra $13 a can, that’s one pricey label.

So what are the major differences?
There aren’t any. The differences are very minor, and it all comes down to taste and texture. For instance, Enfamil Lipil provides a whey-to-casein ratio of 60:40, which is supposed to mimic breastmilk exactly. Similac Advance contains no palm olein oil, which supposedly “promotes increased calcium absorption and greater bone mineralization.” And the one my family used (until today) was Nestle Good Start Supreme. It contains 100% whey and partially hydrolyzed 'comfort proteins'; these little proteins make the milk easier to digest and help with reflux, something from which both our girls suffered.

I just googled this really quick. 

Kariane --- 16 years ago -

EVERY can of baby formula must meet FDA regulations.

That's what I told people too lol. I compared Enfamil Lipil and Parent's Choice's version. Pretty much the same. The only thing I personally liked better about the pricey formulas was the powder was a thinner consistency so it mixed alittle better. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

When people say "skimping" they aren't usually talking about brands. They are talking about putting in only 3 capfuls of formula as opposed to the required 4. Or along those lines. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

From what I learned (after spending $100s of dollars) is that the Wal-mart brand is just as good as Enfamil. 

Abra --- 16 years ago -

They are talking about putting in only 3 capfuls of formula as opposed to the required 4.

Or adding more water to make it an ounce or two more 

Kariane --- 16 years ago -

From what I learned (after spending $100s of dollars) is that the Wal-mart brand is just as good as Enfamil.

And 10x cheaper in the long run! Especially when you have two on formula lol 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

Or adding more water to make it an ounce or two more

Exactly! 

Crystal K --- 16 years ago -

I used Enfamil Lipil exclusively until someone told me the Walmart brand was just as good. My son didn't even notice the difference - but my wallet certainly did! 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 16 years ago -

I wish I would have learned that Parent's Choice Soy Formula was the exact same ingredients of the Enfamil Prosobee. I remember looking at the cans one day and seeing the exact same ingredients. My son was already off of formula by then though... 

Vanbam --- 16 years ago -

ive used the costco brand before i got on WIC with my daughter. she didnt know the difference. kirkland is good same goes with there diapers. 

Mrs. Taken --- 16 years ago -

I always use the Generic Formula....4th kid and no issues :) 

❤ me --- 16 years ago -

Our ped recommended it back in Fl! 

Cayla --- 16 years ago -

I used Enfamil with my first son and with my second I used Targets "Up and Up" formula. Seriously the SAME thing but cheaper.

I was on wic with #1 and no wic with #2. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground