Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

PTSD or just normal?

who's talking here?

Su ^_^ 2
B*Bright 1
Lebowski 2
2Gems4Ever 1
grantsmommy 1
Mary Swanson 1
Lupe 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

grantsmommy --- 16 years ago -

so i know someone who got back about less than a year ago and im noticing more angry outbursts and agitation over simple everyday things. its starting to worry my and affect our friendship. From what i know there was no direct combat during the deployment but who knows. Anyone? 

Lebowski --- 16 years ago -

Maybe you just annoy them so they have a short temper while dealing with you. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]From what i know there was no direct combat during the deployment but who knows
[/i]

PTSD is not only combat-related it can be any stressfull, traumatic experience that can trigger it. Perhaps you should approach your friend with your concerns directly. He may not be aware of his new attitude. Also, that person may be taking steroids and has roid rage...have you noticed this person bulking up at a faster than usual pace?

I knew someone in a similar situation and we weren't sure if it was PTSD or steroids because he was taking them briefly. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]Maybe you just annoy them so they have a short temper while dealing with you. [/i]

lol! 

Lebowski --- 16 years ago -

People not qualified should not attempt to diagnose or assume a condition. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]People not qualified should not attempt to diagnose or assume a condition.
[/i]

true. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

People not qualified should not attempt to diagnose or assume a condition.

But at the same time they should reach out and try to voice their concerns to the person they think has a problem. Like, if I have a friend who seems down all the time and is letting herself go and doesn't ever want to hang out anymore, I should "assume" or "attempt to diagnose" that she may be depressed or even suicidal. I would go to her and voice my concerns that I think she may be depressed or have something else wrong with her. That she isn't the same as she used to be and if she feels she can't talk to me then I would encourage her to talk to a professional. Well, I would encourage her to talk to a professional either way, if she chose to talk to me or not.

I guess what I'm saying is while I understand that people trying to diagnose themselves or someone else may not be the smartest idea if they were downplaying something that could be bigger, for example.. if I thought I had appendicitis and they said "oh your just cramping trust me I know" and then I end up almost dying because I really did have appendicitis and my appendix burst. That kind of trying to diagnose someone I could see is bad, but over diagnosing something like PTSD or Depression or someone whom you think may be suicidal could potentially save their lives. If they turn out to really be suicidal or really have PTSD and you intervened then you could potentially have saved their life. Whereas if you said "Oh I'm not a psychologist, how am I to know if thats really PTSD or Depression...she's probably just a little down..she'll be better in a few days." Then she goes and offs herself...how would you feel then because you didn't intervene when you knew you should have but someone told you "you aren't qualified to make that diagnosis".......



Sorry for sounding all crazy in the above post but I don't know how to word it in a less harsh way....besides saying that I think you are wrong for saying underqualified people shouldn't attempt or assume something. 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

if i see warning flags, I'll act. Waiting to see if those flags are real or not, is waiting too long.

This is the same reason I won't speak to my in-laws anymore. They are the type that want proof those 'flags' are real and I believe waiting for proof is waiting too long.

I understand what you're trying to say BBright. 

Su ^_^ --- 16 years ago -

Giving birth gave me PTSD!! Having a little person coming out off you, was some traumatic experience!!!

One example that PTSD is not always combat related! 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

[i]Giving birth gave me PTSD!
[/i]

Isn't that also referred to as postpartum depression? 

2Gems4Ever --- 16 years ago -

One example that PTSD is not always combat related!

Also, it can come from someone being in a terrible car accident or having something traumatic happen to them in their life. Anyone can develop PTSD. 

Mary Swanson --- 16 years ago -

it can come from someone being in a terrible car accident

yes.. i have issues from a car accident that happened 10 months and 1 day ago 

Su ^_^ --- 16 years ago -


Isn't that also referred to as postpartum depression? 


Not necessary depression and PTSD can be related but they are not te same. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground