The commandant of the Marine Corps has asked Congress to put off its planned vote this week on lifting the policy that forbids gays from serving openly in the military.
In a letter to Arizona Republican Sen. John McCain, Gen. James Conway said lawmakers should wait until a Defense Department study on removing the ban is complete. McCain is the ranking Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee and has expressed reluctance to changing the Clinton-era "don't ask, don't tell" policy.
An "organized and systematic approach" to studying the issue is the best way forward, Conway wrote.
"Further, the value of surveying the thoughts of Marines and their families is that it signals to my Marines that their opinions matter," said the four-star general, whose four-year tenure as the chief of the Marine Corps will end this year. "We must make logical and pragmatic decisions about the long-term policies of our armed forces."
Conway's letter, dated Tuesday, echoed ones written by the chiefs of the Air Force, Army and Navy.
In March, Conway said he would oppose forcing heterosexual Marines to share living quarters with gay troops at bases such as Camp Pendleton and Miramar Marine Corps Air Station.
The Senate Armed Services Committee has enough votes to approve a bill overturning the ban and a vote is expected Thursday, according to supporters seeking an end to the 17-year-old policy.
In 1993, opponents of President Bill Clinton's proposal to lift the ban on gays argued successfully that it might hurt military effectiveness. Facing resistance in Congress, Clinton settled for "don't ask, don't tell," which allowed gays to serve so long as they kept their sexual orientation a secret.
If approved by the committee, the bill would still face scrutiny by the full Senate. But an endorsement by the committee would be a crucial first step.
Several lawmakers on the panel signaled their support for the bill this week after a provision was included that would let the military decide when and how to implement the change.
In the House, the legislation is expected to come up as an amendment to the 2011 defense authorization bill.
Defense Secretary Robert Gates supports the repeal, but also has said Congress should wait to vote until he can talk to the troops and chart a path forward. The study ordered by Gates is due on Dec. 1.
Members of North County's congressional delegation repeatedly have expressed concern about lifting the ban.
Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Vista, is opposed to changing the policy absent the results of the Defense Department study, his spokesman Frederick Hill said.
Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-El Cajon, will vote against it if the bill comes before the House this week. Hunter also will vote against the defense spending bill if the policy is attached to that measure, said his spokesman, Joe Kasper.
How Rep. Brian Bilbray, R-Solana Beach, would vote will depend on the specific language, his spokesman Fritz Chaleff said.
San Diego Democrats Susan Davis and Bob Filner have said they support lifting the ban.
Also Wednesday, the nation's top uniformed military officer repeated his support for repealing the "don't ask, don't tell" policy.
"Personal opinion? I believe it's time. I believe we need to change it," Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told about 500 service members at Peterson Air Force Base in Colorado.
However, Mullen stressed that the change had not yet been approved. And if it is, he said he wouldn't make any final determinations on how to implement it until the military studies the issue and gets input from troops
Max Disposti of the Oceanside-based North County Lesbian, Bisexual, Gay and Transgender Coalition said a repeal is long overdue.
"We are hoping for the best and really happy the president has finally addressed this issue," he said Wednesday. "It's a very important and historic thing and we are working full time in contacting lawmakers and others to help make it happen."
The coalition also wants the Defense Department to create a process for former members of the military who were dismissed for being gay to be able to rejoin the service if they wish, Disposti said.
It's worked fine. Gays can be in the military...just don't talk about it. You're not supposed to talk about sexuality anyway due to 'sexual harrasment' issues....not that it stops people.
MY sister served in the army in 2001 after 9/11 . She is gay and woul love to go back becaues she loved her but when wants child and she is about to get married and her soon to wife want be on INS or be able to be depends . I just think anyone should be able to protect there family
That's it, I officially dislike this man, his time as commandant has marred by his quest to turn the entire corps into nothing but uber conservatives, rather then actually pay attention to what Marines REALLY say. Marine Corps times did a survey of 5000 marines and 85% said get rid of the policy its not worth it, they have spoken.
Gahh get the frick over yourself Conway and leave it alone.
ssica Ree --- 41 min ago - quote - flag comment
It's worked fine. Gays can be in the military...just don't talk about it. You're not supposed to talk about sexuality anyway due to 'sexual harrasment' issues....not that it stops people.
Tell that to the chick in my shop that told all the guys she loves it when her husband.....and I quote "Fucks her in the ass" and followed it with saying...and I quote "If he found out about my girlfriend he'd flip".
I agree. If it ain't broke don't fix it ;)
It IS broke that's the point, people are kicked out because of who the choose to love. Being gay is not illegal anywhere else, its a friggin idiotic policy that should have never been in place. How about I kick your husband out for being straight.
MY sister served in the army in 2001 after 9/11 . She is gay and woul love to go back becaues she loved her but when wants child and she is about to get married and her soon to wife want be on INS or be able to be depends . I just think anyone should be able to protect there family
What in the fu(k does that say?? Please try it in English this time.
It IS broke that's the point, people are kicked out because of who the choose to love. Being gay is not illegal anywhere else, its a friggin idiotic policy that should have never been in place. How about I kick your husband out for being straight.
Wrong. DADT works fine. People serving openly gay would put them in danger. The military is pretty conservative still and isn't ready to "Accept" that lifestyle.
Wrong. DADT works fine. People serving openly gay would put them in danger. The military is pretty conservative still and isn't ready to "Accept" that lifestyle.
I disagree, this was that same dipshit answer given when women were openly added to the military and guess what THEY WERE WRONG. It's discrimination and its just plain WRONG.
If two adults choose to be in a consensual relationship its should be NO ONES business, and they shouldn't be treated like second class citizens for it.
How would you like to be kicked out for loving your wife? But that's right, they aren't allowed to do that, only to gay people.
I disagree, this was that same dipshit answer given when women were openly added to the military and guess what THEY WERE WRONG. It's discrimination and its just plain WRONG.
It's very different as that was an issue of equality. To many DADT is an issue of Morality. There is a HUGE difference. Many believe that it is a lifestyle that people choose and that it is immoral (based on their religion). You can separate men and women. Men on 1 side, women on the other. How do you begin to separate men, women, homosexual men, lesbians, bi-women, bi-men, Transsexuals, transgenders...etc etc etc
It's very different as that was an issue of equality.
THIS is an issue of equality, how can you act as though its not.
And its called the division of church an state, one religions "morals" should have no effect on everyone else. What someones religious beliefs tells them about gays should have nothing to do with the situation.
And its called the division of church an state, one religions "morals" should have no effect on everyone else. What someones religious beliefs tells them about gays should have nothing to do with the situation.
You need to do some research and understand what the "Separation of Church and State" is before you try to use that as your argument. You are in left field with that argument.
You need to do some research and understand what the "Separation of Church and State" is before you try to use that as your argument. You are in left field with that argument.
I fully understand what the division of church and state means, but I thank you for assuming that I don't. It's not a left field argument if YOU actually understood what it meant. Part of the division means the government does not have the right to impose one particular religions beliefs on the people as law, that would apply in this case. Having fought this particular argument in court (and won) I know fully well what my argument means.
But either way DADT is an idiotic policy and when it is repealed I will celebrate.
I fully understand what the division of church and state means, but I thank you for assuming that I don't. It's not a left field argument if YOU actually understood what it meant.
But either way DADT is an idiotic policy and when it is repealed I will celebrate.
If you are arguing that separation of church and state should apply then no, you don't know what it means.
But either way DADT is an idiotic policy and when it is repealed I will celebrate.
I hope you celebrate the assaults and deaths of openly gay service members. I can ASSURE you that it will happen.
I hope you celebrate the assaults and deaths of openly gay service members. I can ASSURE you that it will happen.
Aww so they should live in the shadows ignoring thier family's and loved ones because of a bunch of biggots? Thats what black people, women and jews alike have been told over the years and they ALL stood up against that stupidity, just as the gays are willing to do now.
The only way you can assure that is if you are willing to take those idiotic actions yourself. Which I sincerely hope you wouldn't.
IMO....DADT is just fine, if they don't like that policy then too bad...no one forced them to join the Military, they should get a different job if it's that big of an issue with them.
IMO....DADT is just fine, if they don't like that policy then too bad...no one forced them to join the Military, they should get a different job if it's that big of an issue with them.
AGREE..once they start with being open about it and having people come back if they got kicked out for being gay.. i think there will be a huge issue
IMO....DADT is just fine, if they don't like that policy then too bad...no one forced them to join the Military, they should get a different job if it's that big of an issue with them.
And in IMO thats the answer of a biggot, if you don't like then tough, noone forces you to be one.
Aww so they should live in the shadows ignoring thier family's and loved ones because of a bunch of biggots? Thats what black people, women and jews alike have been told over the years and they ALL stood up against that stupidity, just as the gays are willing to do now.
That's not what I'm saying. I'm saying that can love WHOMEVER they want....at home. If they want to put themselves and there families in danger by making a political statement, that's on them.
The Black, Jew argument doesn't apply. You don't have to tell anybody that you're black...you just are. Nobody is rounding up people that are gay and putting them in concentration camps and throwing them in the oven like a Digiorno pizza.
The only way you can assure that is if you are willing to take those idiotic actions yourself. Which I sincerely hope you wouldn't.
Wrong again, I am realistic.
i think there will be a huge issue
It would be an issue. If it wasn't an issue then they wouldn't have this regulation. They have guidelines for a reason! Suck it up or work somewhere else.
All the answers against repealing are the same biggot answers that people said against women and against blacks in the military. Just as wrong and just as stupid.