Phoenix, Arizona (CNN) -- At a vigil protesting the passage of Arizona's tough new illegal immigration law, a young man in Army fatigues and a beret lit a candle at a makeshift shrine.
Pfc. Jose Medina, an Army medic, came to the Arizona capitol while on leave, to express his sadness over the law, signed by Arizona's governor on Friday.
"I'm here because this is something that's close to my heart," said Medina. "I went off to protect this country, to protect my family. That's what hurts."
The new law, signed by the Arizona governor on Friday, requires police to determine whether a person is in the United States legally. It also requires immigrants to carry their registration documents at all times and requires police to question people if there is reason to suspect that they're in the country illegally. Some fear the law will result in racial profiling.
Medina, 20, is from El Mirage, a working class Latino community northwest of Phoenix.
"When I first joined the military, they would ask us where you from, and I would say 'I'm from the great state of Arizona,' " Medina reflected. "I was raised here, I grew up here. Now I don't know if I can say that so proudly. I don't know if I want to live here anymore."
Medina says he came to the United States from Mexico illegally when he was 2 years old.
When he was 11 years old he became a legal resident of the United States and now has a green card.
"I felt I had a huge debt to this country that's given me so much," Medina said. "When I heard the law that passed, I couldn't believe it. Because the America I know, freedom, liberties we enjoy, are for everyone and then this law passes and I'm like 'wow.' It's a shame; it's a state that doesn't even want you here? If I take this uniform off I'm just another person who came here illegally."
Just six hours before shipping off, Medina's family and friends gathered for a farewell feast. The Mexican barbecue could be smelled a block away.
Impassioned conversation about the controversial law could be heard over the scratching of forks and knives on plates of tangy barbecue.
"You may go to Afghanistan, you may go to Iraq," said Medina's close family friend Victor, who did not want his full name used. "After this night man, we may not see you again. You can give your life for this country. But your mom may be stopped by Joe Arpaio (the Maricopa County, Arizona, sheriff known for aggressive policing.)
"That's true," Medina answered. "But it's my duty to go."
"You're Mexican," Victor said.
"I am of Mexican decent," said Medina. "But I have grown to be an American."
Ricky, 22, a friend who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, is white and stops eating.
"We are all brothers over there," said Ricky, who did not want his full name used.
Before the sun rose over Arizona on Sunday morning, Medina left El Mirage for deployment to Germany.
Jose Medina wondered if some of his family members or friends, some of whom are undocumented, would still be in El Mirage when he returned.
"I worry will my family live in peace," he said. "What good is keeping us safe here ... if we lose a part of what makes America so great? If we drive fear into our own peoples' hearts?"
I don't understand the outrage of Americans of "hispanic" origin towards Arizona. There should be more outrage towards those who come over illegally and cause trouble.
lol i agree he shouldnt have done it in his uniform... but i think its sad that he might come back and some of his family might be deported.... i dont think people realize how hard it is to become a citizen, especially coming from south america...
I'm sorry, but I don't feel sorry for his family that might be deported. If they want to come to our great country, they should follow our laws and procedures to do so. I had a roommate that came here and received a citizenship from the Military for his service. He learned english and speaks it well. Not only that, but he's in college. He respected our laws and did it the right way. That is honorable and I respect him for it.
One of my teammates on my college debate team immigrated from Mexico. Her family did it the right way and she got super irritated hearing about stories like these because she spent ALOT of time and money on workin on her citizenship. Her reasoning was that if her family could do it, so could everyone else.
when did she immigrate? 15 years ago it was a lot easier than it is now.. the way immigration works, is only a certain number of people can become citizens each year, from each country. within the last 10 years, the numbers of people trying to immigrate has risen drastically.. some people dont have the money, dont have the knowledge, etc...
I am from AZ and the way I see it is....if it wasn't such a problem then they wouldn't have to resort to this. They have this new law for a reason and I agree with it.
Also...a couple of my friends on FB make comments like "I wonder if I will be driving in my car and get pulled over and asked questions about being an illegal" uumm....if you don't break the laws then you will be ok. They're not going to be pulling over random people, lol.
actually thats the point of the law... is to create a loop hole to probable cause.. now if they suspect you might be illegal, they can pull you over, they dont have to have a reason to anymore.
when did she immigrate? 15 years ago it was a lot easier than it is now
I dont know exactly when, she isnt a citzen yet, she has hr green card. She is still going through the process.
now if they suspect you might be illegal, they can pull you over, they dont have to have a reason to anymore.
I'd have to read the wording of the law to beleive that. In my years riding along with officers and through my criminal justice studies that raises a red flag for me.
actually thats the point of the law... is to create a loop hole to probable cause.. now if they suspect you might be illegal, they can pull you over, they dont have to have a reason to anymore.
Seems like you didn't read it correctly then or you just simply don't understand it.
If they're not illegal, then there's nothing to worry about right? I think people are getting offended and thinking it's a racist law when it really isn't. It's just reinforcing our security and the penalities towards anyone who breeches them.
I'm sorry, but I don't feel sorry for his family that might be deported. If they want to come to our great country, they should follow our laws and procedures to do so
I also agree with this. There is no reason they shouldn't do it the right way.
If they're not illegal, then there's nothing to worry about right? I think people are getting offended and thinking it's a racist law when it really isn't. It's just reinforcing our security and the penalities towards anyone who breeches them
exactly. and something needs to be done, it's obviously a huge problem. I asked one of my friends that's against it what she thinks could be done instead and she said "make it easier for them to come here" sorry but that just seems crazy to me.
A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, WITHOUT A WARRANT, MAY ARREST A PERSON IF THE OFFICER HAS PROBABLE CAUSE TO BELIEVE THAT THE PERSON HAS COMMITTED ANY PUBLIC OFFENSE THAT MAKES THE PERSON REMOVABLE FROM THE UNITED STATES.
FOR ANY LAWFUL CONTACT MADE BY A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL OR AGENCY OF THIS STATE OR A COUNTY, CITY, TOWN OR OTHER POLITICAL SUBDIVISION OF THIS STATE WHERE REASONABLE SUSPICION EXISTS THAT THE PERSON IS AN ALIEN WHO IS UNLAWFULLY PRESENT IN THE UNITED STATES, A REASONABLE ATTEMPT SHALL BE MADE, WHEN PRACTICABLE, TO DETERMINE THE IMMIGRATION STATUS OF THE PERSON. THE PERSON'S IMMIGRATION STATUS SHALL BE VERIFIED WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT PURSUANT TO 8 UNITED STATES CODE SECTION 1373(
It's sad mexican immigrants have a stereotype. But if you have ever been to or lived near an area where the stereo type is true, you become thankful laws like this are coming into play. I am of Mexican, American Indian, and Puerto Rican decent. Second generation in my fam to be born here on my mothers side and third on my fathers. My family did it legally. I have a friend who is an immigrant and not from Mexico, she is also doing everything legal and she is in no way financially well off to easily afford everything.
There are few people like this Army guy who give back to the country they love. There are MANY that do nothing but take take take.
A little off topic, but it really boils my blood when people come up to me and just start speaking to me in spanish and get angry at me that I don't, when they speak zero english.
if she isnt from mexico its a lot easier to get papers.. the trouble is mexico has so many people coming that theres a waiting list.. it can take years.
Exactly....probable cause. If they're breaking the law or acting suspicious...if they're driving or walking down the street and they're hispanic, they're not going to be arrested.
A little off topic, but it really boils my blood when people come up to me and just start speaking to me in spanish and get angry at me that I don't, when they speak zero english.
AMEN, woman!!!
lol i agree he shouldnt have done it in his uniform... but i think its sad that he might come back and some of his family might be deported.... i dont think people realize how hard it is to become a citizen, especially coming from south america
We have rules and a way about going to become an actual citizen. Those who go around our rules and borders, no matter what country they come from, should be deported. Having a family member serve in our Armed Services has nothing to do with people illegally coming here.
if she isnt from mexico its a lot easier to get papers.. the trouble is mexico has so many people coming that theres a waiting list.. it can take years.
Mexico needs to fix something if that many people are wanting to come over here. I mean, d@mn!
you need reading comprehension.. what do you think : REASONABLE SUSPICION EXISTS THAT THE PERSON IS AN ALIEN WHO IS UNLAWFULLY PRESENT IN THE UNITED STATES, A REASONABLE ATTEMPT SHALL BE MADE, WHEN PRACTICABLE, TO DETERMINE THE IMMIGRATION STATUS OF THE PERSON means?
barney style:
if you get stopped and the po pos think you may be here illegally you must provide proof of citizen ship/ green card.. if you cant, they can arrest you right then... there were plenty of times i walked out of the house with no id, especially as a teenager.