Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

curious...religion and children?

who's talking here?

Cupcake Addict 1
O G docswife 2
JavaMama 3
FixDaPix 1
ALS MommaKitty 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 5
Lavender is Good 1
Trixie St James 1
Aria 1
Hollaina 1
Megan 1
Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* 7
Mama22Angels 2
Mary Swanson 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

My husband and I are not Christian, so we don't really do anything for Christian holidays. My family is Catholic and they keep pushing me to baptize my daughter even though I do not share their beliefs and have no intention of taking my daughter to church (unless she asks). I keep being told that keeping her from things like Christmas and Easter celebrations is selfish on my part. Now, I don't stop anyone from involving my daughter in these celebrations we simply do not make big productions of these holidays in our house. What I want to know, is how do you feel about involving children in religion or religious holidays even if you yourself do not believe in said religion? Might sound kind of confusing but it's hard to word my thoughts on the subject. I'm just curious to know how others feel about a situation like this. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

I think you should do whatever you believe in. Plus in the christian religion there is something (cant rem what the term is) but basically if a person is never exposed to jesus or whatever then it is not counted as them rejecting them. They will not go to hell bc of not having religion bc they were innocent and didnt know any better. Something to that effect. I know im not right on. Also....I dont thik you should demonize anything or tell her she isnt allowed to participate in things with family etc....but I dont think it needs to be pushed either. If your family wants her babtized then too bad. She is your child and you do as you wish. Dont get pressured into doing something that you dont want to do. It is not going to hurt your daughter. I let my kids practice religion with our family, however, we do not practice ourselves. They are allowed to believe whatever they want to believe. They have the information and if they want to believe in god then they are welcome to it and if they do not wish to believe, then they are welcome to that too. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

I am a Christian but I believe the only beliefs worth anything are beliefs that someone chooses for himself once they are old enough to truly make that choice. 

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

i totally agree. we don't plan on forcing our kids into any beliefs and we also won't stop them in exploring their own. It always kind of irked me when people confuse their kids with religion. I know a girl who got all of her kids blessed in the Mormon church, but she NEVER takes them to services and DOES NOT follow any of the normal Mormon practices. It just seems kind of disrespectful to the church IMO 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

I am a christian and I was brought up to believe in something. We went to church but my mom and dad never forced any of us to go. We were free to attend any service we wanted to. But they gave us a solid foundation. Maybe let your family and your husbands family teach your child their beliefs as well. Its JMO though. I do the same with my children. I am giving them a foundation for religion. I don't force it upon them but I show them what i believe. And I let my family show their beliefs as well. I don't subject my children to my inlaws beliefs because they are "baptist" so they say..... but the church they go to is all about greed and praying for material things instead of for health and guidance. 

Trixie St James --- 16 years ago -

Hubs and I are catholic, but non practitioners. I'd prolly burn once I step into a church LOL. I agree with Priv8, do what you believe in and not what family members(outside of immediate)want. I had my girls baptize cause then I was still a practitioner and superstition stuff ( -part of the way I was raised) 

Aria --- 16 years ago -

I'm was raised a cradle catholic did all my stuff catholics do even got my oldest baptized. But my other kid's aren't. As I grew older I realized that I was no longer going to be the one to make the decision on religion for my kids. They will choose to practice what they want when they are ready. My husband doesn't go to church and I at times will head over to a non-denomintational. my oldest prefers to go to an adventist and I am ok with that. you can't allow your family to push you to baptize your child. It is your decisionand when your children are older they can decide what do to when it comes to religion. 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

i was raised catholic, baptized the whole shabang. my husband was raised southern baptist, baptized. i decided a few months ago to begin attending a church again after many years f not going. my kids had never been exposed to religion before now, and they love it. they always had asked questions about heaven and god from hearing it being talked about, and now they are able to have answers. you just have to do what you feel comfortable with. i was baptized and attended catholic school, and mass for years. my parents then left the church for certain reasons. i don't feel it was a waste to have been baptized though like vals mom said about the lds thing. 

Mary Swanson --- 16 years ago -

one of my children is baptized and ive been trying to get the other one baptized, not because they have to have religion or im forcing it on them. I truely believe its a blessing and would like them to have it done. When they're old enough to choose their own path they can but i would like to teach them the values religion instills. 

FixDaPix --- 16 years ago -

We are Christians and we go to church, but we never tell our kids what they are supposed to believe in. We answer their questions, share what we believe and encourage them to share what they believe. My boys are well grounded and they both have a solid "no doubt about it" faith in God. I am proud of them and the way they are growing up. That is the best that I can do and it shows. 

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

my biggest speed bump (for lack of better words) is that I personally do not hold monotheistic beliefs. There aren't exactly churches or anything that I could expose my kids to as far as showing them what I believe. 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

one of my children is baptized and ive been trying to get the other one baptized, not because they have to have religion or im forcing it on them. I truely believe its a blessing and would like them to have it done. When they're old enough to choose their own path they can but i would like to teach them the values religion instills. Ditto..... We are getting our girls baptized this September so that all of our family can be there. I think it is a special thing.... and something that can be done more than once. People tend to fall out of touch with their beliefs and religion. I know I have. I love going to church the sermons mean a lot and are really good when you hae the right person preaching the gospel to you. 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

eople tend to fall out of touch with their beliefs and religion. I know I have. so true. it had been probably 17 years since i had actively attended church. i found a church that had the same beliefs i have, and want my children to be exposed to and it is great. i personally could not go back to the catholic church, because as an adult i do not share those beliefs. but when my kids get older and they want to attend a catholic church then i would never say anything about it. as of now i have no plans of baptizing my kids, if they ask to be i will. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

I was raised in the Catholic and Jewish cultures. My parents made sure as I got older that I was exposed to all sorts of religions so that I could have views from many different sides. I was not pushed to believe in one thing or another and was given the choice to follow my own heart. I myself am Jewish, although I am not currently involved in a temple (bad girl I know). My kids celebrate all the Jewish holidays. They are exposed to Christmas because their cousins celebrate it and we don't want them to not know what it is. But we do not believe Jesus is the messiah so its more of a good mans birthday and a time for family, (which our family respects). We do not do Easter, it is against our beliefs, but we celebrate Passover and spring. Our kids are young so they do not understand holidays at this point. As they grow older we will allow them to explore whatever they choose. My only goal is for my children to have a spiritual side to their life no matter what path they choose to take in order to gain that peace. 

JavaMama --- 16 years ago -

I definitely wouldn't do anything based on what my family wanted me to do. If I were you, I would simply explain to my family that I didn't share their beliefs but that when my kids are older, I will let them choose what path they want to take. I was raised Independent Baptist and my husband was raised Assembly of God so we found middle ground with a great non-denominational church that we both feel comfortable with. The only thing we do when our kids are born is have them dedicated which doesn't really have anything to do with them, it's more about us making the commitment to raise our kids in a Godly home. We actually just got a letter from our church last week saying our son who is six got saved in his class which was very exciting for me. ( I was five when I got saved and remember it as if it were yesterday). Now when he comes to us and is ready he will get baptized but we don't push anything. It's all about when they are ready to make that decision for themselves. 

JavaMama --- 16 years ago -

Oh and what you are talking about Priv8 is the age of accountability which basically means that a child who is young enough to not understand or comprehend religion will automatically go to Heaven when they die. Until someone has actually heard the gospel and chosen to reject it, they will not go to hell. (I understand not everyone shares this belief but I am assuming that's what you were refering to). 

Cupcake Addict --- 16 years ago -

My husband and I were both brought up going to church-------both of my boys are active in our church now & even when I feel like a slacker and want to skip early service THEY are the ones begging to go. I believe as a parent is is my responsibility to raise my children with the beliefs and values of a Christian household. Though I will be open to the directions they may choose to take down the road, I believe they need our (my husband and I) guidance until they can make that choice for themselves. 

Hollaina --- 16 years ago -

I believe as a parent is is my responsibility to raise my children with the beliefs and values of a Christian household. Though I will be open to the directions they may choose to take down the road, I believe they need our (my husband and I) guidance until they can make that choice for themselves. Agree 100%. 

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

I'm kind of apprehensive about exposing my daughter(s) to my beliefs because I get a lot of crap for it and have had a lot of hardships with people that can't accept it. I wouldn't want my kids to feel alienated because of it. 

Mary Swanson --- 16 years ago -

to my beliefs because I get a lot of crap for it and have had a lot of hardships with people that can't accept it. I wouldn't want my kids to feel alienated because of it. what do you believe in? 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

Oh and what you are talking about Priv8 is the age of accountability which basically means that a child who is young enough to not understand or comprehend religion will automatically go to Heaven when they die. Until someone has actually heard the gospel and chosen to reject it, they will not go to hell. (I understand not everyone shares this belief but I am assuming that's what you were refering to). Yes that is it. Also I think it goes for any age though right? As long as they havent actually heard and rejected it? 

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

I'm Pagan. Kind of broad, I know, but I haven't committed to a denomination. My beliefs somewhat parallel Wicca. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

I think it would be fine to introduce your children to it. I just wouldnt go all gung ho on it and expect them to follow it, or tell people that is what they believe, etc. Same with someone who is christian or morman etc. Those have the potential for people to think the kids are weird too. It is just all on how you come off. I think anything can be seen as creepy if it is being jammed down your throat...whether it be a standard "normal" religion or a more unconventional "new age" religion.(based on societys terms) I think the best thing is balance. You also dont want your kids to think that what you believe is wrong by acting ashamed of it. I would introduce all of it and just always let them know they have the freedom to choose what they like. 

Megan --- 16 years ago -

My husband and I are of different religions. Im Wiccan while he is Christian. We simply alternate holidays. One year we will celebrate Yule and Easter while the next Christmas and Ostara. We dont force my son into either of our religions. We want him to see what we both believe and let him know there are other religions out there and let him decide what he wants. 

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

True. I'd just really hate for them to deal with some of the things I had to go through. My family especially hates the path I've chosen. It got so bad at one point that my parents stopped talking to me. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

True. I'd just really hate for them to deal with some of the things I had to go through. My family especially hates the path I've chosen. It got so bad at one point that my parents stopped talking to me. What doesnt kill us, makes us stronger. I mean really....if it is not that it will be something else. Pretty much growing up no matter how awesome of a person you are at some point everyone will feel some sort of rejection from others. Every child usually has an awkward stage. There are worse things that she "might" get made fun of for. I say might in quotes bc perhaps she wont catch any flack for it at all. Some kids get made fun of bc of the way their face looks, or that they wear glasses, etc. You can always change your religion lol. It really wont be that bad. As long as she doesnt go to school pushing every sterotypical cliche about pagans etc then I am sure people wont even care. 

Val's Mommy *Simply Elated* --- 16 years ago -

As long as she doesnt go to school pushing every sterotypical cliche about pagans etc then I am sure people wont even care. Yeah. I don't really get any flack for it now that I've moved out here, but in my hometown people would freak when they found out. I used to get people quoting scripture to me and offering to save me. People never knew my beliefs unless it was brought up in conversation. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

I think she will be fine. I just think people dont like fanatics. So whatever she decides to believe, as long as she isnt fanatical about it, I think she will be fine. lol 

JavaMama --- 16 years ago -

Yes that is it. Also I think it goes for any age though right? As long as they havent actually heard and rejected it? Yes, I would imagine that it would go for anyone although the Bible just talks about a child reaching the age of accountability, but it doesn't say specifically what age. I believe it just depends on the child because obviously some kids would understand at a younger age than others. Also, I don't believe that anyone dies without first hearing the gospel. If they choose to reject it, that's their choice, but I believe God gives everyone a chance to make the choice on their own regardless of age. I also agree with what everyone has said about being fanatical about religion. I am a very strong Christian but I don't push my beliefs on anyone. If someone has questions, I am more than happy to answer them as best I can or point them in the right direction if I don't have the answer. It drives me crazy to see how some Christians behave because they think they are doing God's "work" when really all they are doing is pushing people away from Christianity. It's sad that what one person does can gives us all a bad name. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground