Okay so here is my situation.
About a month ago my husband was in a car accident in one of his co workers car.
My husband had full permission to drive the car, as a matter of fact the owner asked him to take his car to run an errand.
Well my husband felt horrible after the fact. We paid the wrecker fee and paid to get it out of impound (about $600 all together)
Now the owner is telling my husband he wants $2,000. We called my father in law who is a cop and he told us since Marc had the okay from the owner to drive the car we don't really have to by law give him money.
The owner had the least amount of insurance legal to have on a vehicle by choice.
We feel bad but we dont just have two grand to give the guy.
Yes my husband crashed his car but accidents happen....
I dont know what to do because the guy is higher ranking and my husband doesnt want to get in trouble but LEGALLY we arent obligated to pay him..
What do you think is right?
I am at work so I cannot really reply right away... I just feel stuck!
I dont know what to do because the guy is higher ranking and my husband doesnt want to get in trouble but LEGALLY we arent obligated to pay him..
I think your husband should probably consult base legal. I don't think that rank should be considered in this here at all, since it was a personal vehicle.
Was there alot of damage to the vehicle? I also think you should consult base legal since things are handled differently in the MC.
the owner said he didnt want to bother fixing it because it was a 92 and he'd rather just get a new car
I would at least pay the deductible if not the 2,000. I would check Kelly Blue Book to see how much its worth and Id want something from the repair place stating damages.. everything he caused.. no prior damages.
Even though the it was a accident and accidents happen I think your hubby should pay for the damages because its the right thing to do. Is the 2,000 dollars for damages? I would ask to see prove that its gonna be that much to repair the damaged. This is exactly why I dont drive anyone elses vehicles and no one drives mine lol.
Your Hubby was he driver who was reponsible for the car while he had it. He should pay for it to be fixed. The owner of the car can sue for damages...But when i called my FIL (a cop) and Progressive they said since he had permission its not our legal responsibility.. however morally we feel bad.. but dont have 2gs
If your husband is his subordinate and was given the car to run an errand for him during working hours, that's a can of worms the higher ranking one doesn't want to open. He himself could be personally liable for damage caused by an 'employee'. The guy probably doesn't want to have to pay and is milking you guys for it by throwing his rank around. Go to base legal.
the owner said he didnt want to bother fixing it because it was a 92 and he'd rather just get a new car
ok.. then figure out how much the vehicle is worth. Personally I'd pay the 2,000 somehow because it was my fault it was wrecked unless there is another party responsible and he can just go after them for damages. If it was your husband's fault, its his responsiblity
But when i called my FIL (a cop) and Progressive they said since he had permission its not our legal responsibility
THATS NOT TRUE...
If I let my friend drive my car to run errands and shes in a car wreck she is LEGALLY OBLIGATED to fix the car
I asked to ride my friends motorcycle and i crashed it, it was brand new and he had not added insurance yet, do i have to pay?
Fontana, CA Viewed 1097 times. Posted 6 months ago in Car / Auto Accident
Flag as objectionable
My insurance would not pay for the accident because my insurance does not cover motorcycles. The bike was taken in for an estimate and would cost more to fix then the bike is worth. Answer this question Add to list Share this Answer this question Add to list Share this
Not what you're searching for? Get your answer
We have over 100,000 questions and answers written on nearly every legal topic. Find what you need using the options below.
SearchLegal topic City, state or zip code Just Ask!Get free, personalized answers from real lawyers.
(128 characters remaining)QuestionEnter your question here. e.g., Do I need a real estate attorney?Ask now (800 characters remaining)Question detailsRemember that your question will be posted in a public forum for all to see. Include all relevant details, but please omit any personally identifiable information.City and stateRequired
Answers (7)
Adam David Sorrells
This attorney is licensed in California. Posted 6 months ago. Flag as objectionable
This depends on several things. Your friend (of course) needs to contact his insurance company right away. If he already had insurance, there is often a grace period when a new vehicle is purchased, where it is covered by the existing insurance. I am not sure if this applies to a motorcycle, or if it applies to your friend, but that needs to be examined. Next question, was there a loan on the motorcycle? If so, the lender may have required insurance, so maybe he got insurance through the lender?
Do you have insurance? If so, it can be tendered to your car insurance, if you carry comprehensive and collision coverage.
Are you uninsured? If so, it may be covered by your friends uninsured property damage coverage.
In short, every possible avenue for insurance needs to be investigated.
You need to seek legal advice immediately.
The bottom line however; if you borrow a motorcycle, and then wreck it, you are responsible, unless you can find a source of insurance to pay for it.
Also, please read this disclaimer. The following was not legal advice, but just commentary. I can only give advice to current clients, and after receiving complete information on the specific situation. With that said, I hope you found the comments helpful, and a starting point for your situation.
Adam Sorrells
Law Offices of Adam Sorrells
Chico personal injury lawyer. 6 3 Helpful Not helpful Richard Forrest Gould-Saltman
This attorney is licensed in California. Posted 6 months ago. Flag as objectionable
Why wouldn't you have to pay? You borrowed something of someone's. It was new. You broke it. You didn't have insurance to cover it. You owe your friend. 5 2 Helpful Not helpful Lucas Eric Rowe
This attorney is licensed in Ohio. Posted 6 months ago. Flag as objectionable
My question for you would be, "do you think you're responsible?" If you think "no", I'm wondering why that would be.
If you are uninsured and your friend's property insurance won't cover it, then you absolutely owe him. You rode it, you crashed it, you owe him. 1 1 Helpful Not helpful Brad Jefferson Landon
This attorney is licensed in California. Posted 5 months ago. Flag as objectionable
Your question seems to confuse liability with insurability. Whether or not there was insurance is irrelevant. You are liable to pay your friend because you crashed his motorcycle.
With regard to the question of whether or not your friends insurance may cover the motorcycle via some sort of grace period, your friend should immediately contact his/her agent as this question can only be answered by reviewing the policy of insurance. However, bear in mind that coverage will only apply through the insurer's contractual grace period if your friend purchased the motorcycle as a replacement for a previously insured motorcycle that he was replacing
If he said he didn't want to fix it then what is the $2,000 going to?
Maybe a down payment on a new car? Op said he'd rather get a new car.
BUT either way he IS responsible, he was driving, unless he was hit by another driver, so what the owner of the vehicle does with the money is his business.
I'd say get a personal loan and give the guy his $$. Your husband was the one driving it, he is responsible. If I let someone drive my car and anything happened to it, I'd ask them to pay. (If my insurance wouldn't cover it, or the deductible).
If hes not wanting to repair the vehicle and wanting 2,000 for a down payment on another vehicle, I would let him know youll pay him what the car is worth.