Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

since when did spanking.....

who's talking here?

♥my£ife 3
ALEM 1
Pasha 1
Avash1177 2
✧cristina✧ 2
TheNinja 7
Mommeee Drest 1
All Abouts 3
FixDaPix 1
San Antonio Bound 3
PPCTMistyLa Diabla 1
Kariane 1
Lexi-*Ind.*S*Director* 2
Trixie St James 6
UnicornsR4Gangstas 3
trish 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ALEM --- 17 years ago -

lower the IQ of kids? Being spanked as a child is linked to having a lower IQ, according to a study presented today at the International Conference on Violence, Abuse and Trauma in San Diego. The relationship between spanking and intelligence is found in children around the world, said the lead author of the study, University of New Hampshire professor Murray Straus. Children in the United States who were spanked had lower IQs -- by 2.8 to 5 points -- than those who were not spanked, Straus found. Straus studied 806 children ages 2 to 4 and 704 ages 5 to 9. Both groups were retested four years later. How often parents spanked influenced IQ score. "The more spanking, the slower the development of the child's mental ability," Straus said in a news release. "But even small amounts of spanking made a difference." Straus and his colleagues looked at corporal punishment practices in 32 countries by surveying 17,404 university students. The analysis found a lower average IQ in nations in which spanking was more prevalent. The strongest link between corporal punishment and IQ was for those whose parents continued to use corporal punishment even when they were teenagers. "It is ... time for the United States to begin making the advantages of not spanking a public health and child welfare focus, and eventually enact federal no-spanking legislation," he said. How would spanking impact intelligence? Straus suggests that the chronic stress created by regular spanking creates post-traumatic stress symptoms in children. PTSD is linked to lower IQ. Economic status also underlies both spanking practices and IQ, Straus said, a leading researcher on corporal punishment. His studies were funded, in part, by the National Institute of Mental Health. Another study, reported earlier this month in Booster Shots, found that many poor children are spanked at ages as young as 1 and that the practice is tied to more aggressive behavior by age 2 and delayed social-emotional development by age 3. -- Shari Roan Link to Article. 

Pasha --- 17 years ago -

many poor children are spanked at ages as young as 1 That is f*cking disgusting. 

Avash1177 --- 17 years ago -

My husband was spanked as a child and he has a 4.0 GPA in his college classes right now!Just sayin. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

I am not going to say.. spanking is right or wrong.. but to me even smacking a hand of a baby(less then 2) in not necessary 

San Antonio Bound --- 17 years ago -

Ok, this sounds like a bunch of propaganda to justify those parents who coddle their children and never discipline. They're trying to force their views on the rest of us, and a federal no-spanking legislation would be a huge mistake. Where do you think most of the problems we have nowadays are coming from? Not enough parents disciplining their children! People are so paranoid that if they're caught popping their kid on the butt for misbehaving that they'll have CPS called on them and they'll lose their child, so the children learn that they can get away with stuff. I was spanked whenever I was bad as a child, and I've got a high IQ, same for my husband and 3 of my 5 brothers, and all of my brothers in law. The occasional pop on the butt won't hurt your child, it'll definitely get their attention, and let them know that they did wrong. Children under the age of 4 cannot connect cause and effect when the effect is still a theory, and a quick pop gives them an immediate effect that invariably keeps them safe. 

San Antonio Bound --- 17 years ago -

I am not going to say.. spanking is right or wrong.. but to me even smacking a hand of a baby(less then 2) in not necessary So, you'd allow your child to reach for something hot and burn themselves even though you repeatedly told them no? If smacking an 18 month old's hand will keep them from getting injured, you damn well better believe I'll do it. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

So, you'd allow your child to reach for something hot and burn themselves even though you repeatedly told them no? If smacking an 18 month old's hand will keep them from getting injured, you damn well better believe I'll do it. I have gates up for that one.. and redirecting is my approach. 

San Antonio Bound --- 17 years ago -

redirecting is my approach Good luck with that. It's not always effective with young children, but if it works for you, more power to ya. 

All Abouts --- 17 years ago -

Good luck with that. It's not always effective with young children, but if it works for you, more power to ya. I dont say spanking is right or wrong.. we all the best we can and hope it works.. so far so good.. 3 down 2 to go :) 

Kariane --- 17 years ago -

Well just as a precaution I think I better tell my hubby to stop spanking me 

Avash1177 --- 17 years ago -

Well just as a precaution I think I better tell my hubby to stop spanking me HAHHAHAHAHHA!!! 

Mommeee Drest --- 17 years ago -

Devildoc.... THANK YOU... couldn't have said it better myself. Our society is going in the wrong direction because parents want to be "friends" with their children and coddle them. There is no fear anymore. 

PPCTMistyLa Diabla --- 17 years ago -

Imagine how smart I would have been had my mom not beat my azz. Thanks mom for ruining my shot at MENSA. Those 5 points would have got it. I blame my mother. 

Trixie St James --- 17 years ago -

Iz sowwy iz spankded wen iz a keed dats y iz typ lyk dis, coz Iz stopud.. O_o I agree with ilovemydevildoc.. growing up in a traditional Filipino household my sister and I grew up being spanked if we did something wrong. Instilled fear and respect towards elders at a very young age. And for that I'm grateful for, cause I dont think I'd have raised my gremlins right. I have two wonderful kids and the hubby and I have always gotten good and positive compliments at how theyre so well behaved. And all I got to say to that is, we try.. we try our best to raise them right. If it means spanking them, well by all means, I'd do it. But I dont really have to anymore, their old enough to understand right from wrong.. lol I just do empty threats.. "Settle down or else I'll come over there and break your fingers." or "Settle down, I'll shove you in the closet that has spiders." 

✧cristina✧ --- 17 years ago -

I spank (not beat) my daughter, though it's not something that happens often. And she's way ahead of the curve intellectually, and she's only 2. I don't think spanking is wrong, though it can be if taken to the extreme. I agree with Ilovemydevildoc about the whole propaganda and pushing of opinions. However, I can see how spanking could psychologically lower a kid's IQ because it does cause submission, and possibly lower self esteem if done excessively, and that could affect the way a kid expresses their knowledge (or holds back on expressing it because they may have doubts, i.e. low self esteem). It doesn't seem to me that spanking a kid would be directly and physically connected to the IQ portions in the brain and really cause low IQ, though. IMO 

TheNinja --- 17 years ago -

I can see how spanking could psychologically lower a kid's IQ because it does cause submission, and possibly lower self esteem if done excessively, and that could affect the way a kid expresses their knowledge (or holds back on expressing it because they may have doubts, i.e. low self esteem). It doesn't seem to me that spanking a kid would be directly and physically connected to the IQ portions in the brain and really cause low IQ, though. IMO Totally agree! Although I think that as long as parents PRAISE for good behavior as well, it'll teach the kids to be confident when they are right and second guess themselves when they are unsure?? Idk, just something I've thought about. My parents spanked me when necessary and praised me when appropriate. That's how I plan on raising my kids. They will know when they are doing good and when they aren't. I won't rely on PURELY spanking. But I'll avert the behavior if I can and then take the necessary steps to correct their action. 

TheNinja --- 17 years ago -

I agree with ilovemydevildoc.. growing up in a traditional Filipino household my sister and I grew up being spanked if we did something wrong. Instilled fear and respect towards elders at a very young age. And for that I'm grateful for, cause I dont think I'd have raised my gremlins right. I have two wonderful kids and the hubby and I have always gotten good and positive compliments at how theyre so well behaved. And all I got to say to that is, we try.. we try our best to raise them right. If it means spanking them, well by all means, I'd do it. But I dont really have to anymore, their old enough to understand right from wrong.. lol I just do empty threats.. "Settle down or else I'll come over there and break your fingers." or "Settle down, I'll shove you in the closet that has spiders." I agree with you! Plus, your kids are amazingly behaved. That's why hubby and I look up to you guys so much. Not only are they well-behaved, but the young one has Ninja Skillage. Lol! 

✧cristina✧ --- 17 years ago -

Definitely, TheNinja. I always praise and give positive reinforcement. If my daughter does something she knows she's not supposed to (I only punish when she is intentionally doing something bad), she gets punished. But the moment she corrects herself I'm all over the positive reinforcement. And for my daughter, usually time out is worse punishment than spanking, so I use it more, though there are times I feel spanking is necessary. 

TheNinja --- 17 years ago -

But the moment she corrects herself I'm all over the positive reinforcement. Exactly! I think people forget about positive reinforcement sometimes. But man, spanking lowering kids' IQs...Lol! That statement just makes me laugh. 

UnicornsR4Gangstas --- 17 years ago -

I grew up as an Army Brat and my dad would spank my a$$ if I did something bad..but if I did something good and I behaved myself I got positive reinforcemnets. I gain respect and discipline. I am glad my parents raised me like they did or I definately would not be the person I am today. As for lowering kids' I.Q., I don't think so. I had a 4.0 in high school and graduated as honor grad. And I'm a full time student in college with a 4.0. So wherever they got that information, they must have but a spin on it so it can fit their point. 

♥my£ife --- 17 years ago -

I can see how spanking could psychologically lower a kid's IQ because it does cause submission, and possibly lower self esteem if done excessively, and that could affect the way a kid expresses their knowledge (or holds back on expressing it because they may have doubts, i.e. low self esteem). Good points! I think that saying it lowers a child's IQ is a stretch. IMO, it's more of a socio-economic correlation, which could also explain why a child who is spanked might be performing poorly academically. Lower socio-economic classes tend to spank more, and those are the children that struggle in school and are unlikely to go to college. For the record, I wasn't spanked and don't believe in it as a primary form of discipline. 

trish --- 17 years ago -

crazy 

UnicornsR4Gangstas --- 17 years ago -

It's a no go to spank young children. But as they grew up, there are other forms of discipline. So no one form of discipline is better then the other. Good thing there are options so you are able to choose what fits your parenting style better. :D 

Lexi-*Ind.*S*Director* --- 17 years ago -

My mom beat the hellion out of us when we were children...and ALL of us are rather intelligent people. Like someone else said, this is just non-spanking propaganda. Let's all go hug tree next. I agree that parents don't beat their children enough (lol). Our society focuses much too much on being a child's friend, and only showing them love. I think it is all well and good to love your children and make sure they know how much you do love them, but taking it to such an extreme as to never discipline? I know there are other forms of discipline, but sometimes, nothing is more effective than a good pop on the butt. 

♥my£ife --- 17 years ago -

I think it is all well and good to love your children and make sure they know how much you do love them, but taking it to such an extreme as to never discipline? Just because someone doesn't spank doesn't mean they don't discipline. There are many alternative and effective forms of punishment that don't involve hitting your children. 

FixDaPix --- 17 years ago -

Damn! Here it was me thinking those kids watching all that tv and being addicted to video games might have something to do with a lower IQ score. Gosh, maybe if my parent hadn't of spanked me, my IQ would be 150 instead of 148. Thanks Mom!!! Seriously, it's the lack of parenting these days that have contributed to our failing students and lower test scores, not parents that play an active roll in their child's life. A swat on the booty isn't going to make your child a walking idiot. I have two gifted boys to attest to that. 

Lexi-*Ind.*S*Director* --- 17 years ago -

Just because someone doesn't spank doesn't mean they don't discipline. There are many alternative and effective forms of punishment that don't involve hitting your children. You MUST have missed the part where I said THIS: I know there are other forms of discipline, but sometimes, nothing is more effective than a good pop on the butt.  

♥my£ife --- 17 years ago -

You MUST have missed the part where I said THIS: I know there are other forms of discipline, but sometimes, nothing is more effective than a good pop on the butt. No, as I quoted, I was addressing the other part of your comment. :) 

Trixie St James --- 17 years ago -

Plus, your kids are amazingly behaved. That's why hubby and I look up to you guys so much. Not only are they well-behaved, but the young one has Ninja Skillage. Lol! Aaww thank you! Like I said, we try our best to raise them right :3! I'm sure you and Tightey will do a great job at raising Little Ninja! Even if my children of the corn are old enough to know from wrong and right, theyre still growing and we're (D and I) growing with them, so we will be continuing to discipline them. Still cracks me up at that time Tightey freaked out at the hospital when I scolded the little girl and she stood in parade rest. 

TheNinja --- 17 years ago -

Tightey freaked out at the hospital when I scolded the little girl and she stood in parade rest. OMG! That was freaking amazing! LOL! He was like, "Now THAT is what I call parentinng!" LOL! It was just automatic for her! HA HA HA HA! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground