I'm NOT trying to start anything but what do y'all think about the Pendleton 8? For y'all that don't know who or what the Pendlton 8 are about go to pendleton.com. I'm just curious...
If you go in the afternoon or mid morning they are sometimes outsidethe gate sitting in their lawn chairs with signs. Hubby and I usually see them when we go to the comm. in the afternoon on Sat.
I dont mind them being out there they are supporting our troops and it great to know that there are people out there that arent military that support our men and women in uniform. now on the other hand if they were against our troops i would be very upset that they are out there
No one answered the question so I will. They are in there for a violation of article 32. They are being accused of killing a man and making it look like he was planting a bomb and lying to investigators
One has already been set free. I believe that if they did it, than they should be procecuted, if they didn't than they will be let go. Does it suck that they are in there.... yes, but I do believe that if they are innocent they will be let free. That is my stand, can't really talk about it too much.
One has already been set free. I believe that if they did it, than they should be procecuted, if they didn't than they will be let go. Does it suck that they are in there.... yes, but I do believe that if they are innocent they will be let free. That is my stand, can't really talk about it too much.
100% agreed
I am a conflicted about the situation. Part of me understands the thinking behind what they did. It must be a frustrating thing to capture the bad guys, hand them over to their government, for them to be released again. The man they intended to assassinate was a man responsible for many of the killings on military personel. When they went to carry out the assassination the man they wanted wasn't there so they took his uncle, who was involved, instead. They killed him and set it up to look like they were in a gun fight with him.
Does it make it ok? Not for me to decide. I would imagine it to be difficult to follow our laws when the enemy is not bound by the same laws. The same rules.
I couldn't say what I would do until I was in a simular situation. I do know it would be very hard for me to stand idle while fellow Marines were being killed and some of the people responible kept being released from custody.
Side note: I thought that there was only one man left in jail. Didn't the commander turn over the other two's conviction? I thought the main guy was the last on in. Sgt. Hutchins ? I believe was his name.
My opinion on the whole story that the uncle was unarmed and had nothing to do with it is very simple. There are no innocent people in a war. If he had nothing to do with what was going on, he wouldn't have been there when the Marines got there. Secondly, in the situation the Marines were faced with that night, I would've killed them all and let God sort them out. I 100% think that if the guys did anything other than what they were ordered to do, they will be held accountable. However, there seem to be lots of holes and questions left unanswered in the whole thing.
To be honest, I don't follow it because I think it's BS. A lot of these guys being charged with war crimes are being charged because they did what they were trained to do. You train a person to kill, kill, kill and then, when the time comes where it's them or the Iraqi, it's a war crime because they guy was unarmed at that second. Nevermind the fact that two hours earlier, he just set off a car bomb or was seen setting an IED.
How about the guy who has been out for a while, was going to be interviewed for a police job, and was arrested. He's been out and is just now going to trial over a war crime he allegedly committed years ago. It came out when one of the other guys he was there with spilled the beans during an interview for the FBI. According to this new law, retirees, dependants, and contractors can be charged with war crimes and prosecuted by the government. This dude has lost everything and is so pinched for money that his wife has to work right through his trial.
To be honest, I don't follow it because I think it's BS. A lot of these guys being charged with war crimes are being charged because they did what they were trained to do. You train a person to kill, kill, kill and then, when the time comes where it's them or the Iraqi, it's a war crime because they guy was unarmed at that second. Nevermind the fact that two hours earlier, he just set off a car bomb or was seen setting an IED.
I feel the same they train them and tell them to do something then they prosecute them??? Idk doesnt make much sense to me but w/e I hope the best for that guy though.
Yes... but there is a reason why they aren't letting this guy out. With all this press they aren't going to keep him unjustly don't you think? I am sure in a few years when the stuff is unclassifed we will find out
I feel the same they train them and tell them to do something then they prosecute them???
It does make sense if you think about it. We have to be governed by some sort of law or rules or else there would be no order.
I am not saying I agree but it does make sense.
Why is he being held? I tried to find an article but couldn't didnt want to go do a full search trying to do HW at the same time lol i get distracted too easily with you girls lol
they were all charged for the innocent murder of a man in which they tried to cover it up and look like he was trying to plant a road side bomb. but it seems that Hutchinson is the only one they wont let out... so like I said we will see when it becomes declassified
1hotmama~ your confused. It started out with 8. Hence Pendleton 8. After trial there were 3 (I believe) that was given time. The commander overturned the other two leaving Sgt. Hutchins the last one. The ring leader so to speak. That is what I remember.
oh lol idk like i said i didnt read a full article from what i read they were only talking about 3 guys lol that and im typing 3 letters lol its fun getting HW and life mixed up lol