bringing the paddles back to schools? I was reading an article about a school in Temple,TX wanting them back! I remember when I was in in Elementary school (so many years ago..lol) and they used have them and used them as well! Would be for or against it?
If we aren't allowed to use them at home (in this state we aren't) then they shouldn't be using it in school. If anyone hits my child I will hit them back and harder.
I know I would not let the teachers paddle my kids, we barely spank them so no one else is going to. That being said I think the teachers need to be able to do something, teachers can hardly look at a kid funny without being sued or something you know what I mean? I think if a parent is ok with a teacher paddeling thier kid, then maybe it should be done.
I have no problem with spanking my kid as long as I'm the one doing it. If anyone hits my child I will hit them back and harder.
I'd feel the same way if any1 else tried to do it.
the moment anyone tries to hit my kid, all hell will break loose. its one thing for a parent to spank their kid, its a whole other thing to have an other adult do it.. i think its sick.
We had it when I was in Elementary school, too. The parents had to sign a form at the beginning of the year giving the principal permission to use the paddle. I'm not sure if I'd be for or against it since I don't have kids. Sometimes spankings don't even work for some kids. The parents know what works and doesn't work for discipline and if they give someone written permission... also should probably be notarized in case it does happen and the parents flip out I don't see why not.
When I was a freshman in TX it was allowed at the school I went to. They couldn't just paddle anyone. It was an option for students to opt out of lunch detention. MANY students took the paddling instead of lunch detention.
and im not against spanking, like jennikins said, as long as i (or my husband) am the one doing doing it.
OK cause you confused me with your comment about TX sucking. I hate the way CA handles spanking, its idiotic IMO.
My husband will get to spank our future kids :-) The one we have now is mine from a previous relationship and his father would flip if my husband spanked him. I definitely would NOT send my son to a school like that but to each his own.
Um, absolutely not. I would not send my son to a school that practiced physical discipline. I'm proud to live in a state that would hopefully never allow that to happen.
tx imo should have more in place... if i recall right, it doesnt matter where you hit them, its not illegal unless you punch them.. which is wrong.
Actually it is only on the butt with an open hand my sister just went through this not too long ago.
Definitely against. It's one thing for parents to spank their own kid, it's a whole other thing for teachers (or anyone else) to do it. I don't even plan on spanking my future kids although that's not to say it won't EVER happen it just won't be the go to form of punishment for us... so obviously I wouldn't want someone else doing it to them!
I would definitely not send my children to a school like that. I don't believe in any type of physical or punitive forms of discipline, and I would probably go beserk if someone tried to spank one of my kids.
My mom has been a teacher for 15+ years and I love her to death, but I think she would brutually(sp) beat the kids over and over if she got her hands on a paddle.. lol.. She LOVES her job, don't get me wrong and she does her job right. But working with High Schoolers everyday gets tiring and irritating.. Their mouthy, horrible attitudes. I think any high school teacher would be the same- lol
No way would I allow another person to spank my child. However I do agree that teachers need some way to punish kids. My favorite teacher in grade school would do the name on the board thing, and if you had a certain number of days in a row with name and 3 check marks he would tape a piece of string on your desk and cut some off everytime you misbehaved (how much depended on how amd you made him) once you were at the end of your string it was off to the principals office.
When I was a freshman in TX it was allowed at the school I went to. They couldn't just paddle anyone. It was an option for students to opt out of lunch detention. MANY students took the paddling instead of lunch detention.
Once you are out of grade school it seems silly to have spanking as a form of punishment.
I think just the threat of a paddling should be allowed. My principal in kindergarten and the first grade had a paddle hanging in his office, and EVERYONE in the school swore up and down he used it, and it was intimidating looking, and most of the kids were well behaved with just the threat of it.
My husband will get to spank our future kids :-) The one we have now is mine from a previous relationship and his father would flip if my husband spanked him. I definitely would NOT send my son to a school like that but to each his own.
Is this child from your previous marriage living with you and your new husband??
I think it would be interesting to ask our grandparents what happened when they went to school when it came to discipline.
Does everyone think that the way kids act in school is a lot worse than back in the day when this was allowed?
I believe that if a parent is involved with their child's life, has discpline at home, then there is not a need for this kind of thing at school. I feel like a lot of times the way kids are in school are a direct reflection of their home life.
Yeah, he lives with us full time and see's his dad every other weekend. He IS allowed to punish him, just not spank him. If it gets to that point then I have to step in and take care of it. Its not the ideal situation but we find ways to make it work. My son respects my husband more than his dad.
I think it would be interesting to ask our grandparents what happened when they went to school when it came to discipline.
My grandpa once said they got hit on the hands with a ruler. He said it stung like a bit(h. haha his words. not mine.
Yeah, He IS allowed to punish him, just not spank him. If it gets to that point then I have to step in and take care of it. Its not the ideal situation but we find ways to make it work. My son respects my husband more than his dad.
wow