It's so sad:( he is begging. But at the same time it looks very edited like they only put what they wanted to be heard on here and he did cut himself off. I don't think he is going crazy I think he is just extremely sad and ready to be freed bu he knows that won't happen unless their demands are met and the afghani prisoners are released:( I feel horrible for his family! To know that your loved one is imprisoned and there is nothing you can do about it!
This is the kid that was "captured" wearing PT gear, without his weapon. Who would EVER leave the wire without their weapon?? I don't feel sorry for him in the least. This guy is a coward
Article V Military Code of Conduct
When questioned, should I become a prisoner of war, I am required to give name, rank, service number, and date of birth. I will evade answering further questions to the utmost of my ability. I will make no oral or written statements disloyal to my country and its allies or harmful to their cause.
This is the kid that was "captured" wearing PT gear, without his weapon. Who would EVER leave the wire without their weapon?? I don't feel sorry for him in the least. This guy is a coward
Unfortunately, my husband said the same thing. The guy put down his weapon and WALKED OFF base/camp/whatever, right??
Its easy to say that when you are not the pow...
Why would you "surrender" to a people that are going to kill you regardless?? I would neer be a POW. Dead maybe, POW never.
I don't care if he deserted... I think its wrong to vilify him. He is an american, and I hope he makes it back to his family.
I agree, completely... but he made a huge mistake and him getting captured was his fault 100%.
Do I think he should die because he made a mistake? No, I don't.
I think they should beat the crap out of him and then let him go.. but that's wishful thinking.. This is a war.
Wow... Beat the crap outta him? How nice of you.. I don't get some people. I agree that if he did go outside of the wire, it was his fault he got captured. But even so, I would never wish harm upon him.
Wow... Beat the crap outta him? How nice of you.. I don't get some people. I agree that if he did go outside of the wire, it was his fault he got captured. But even so, I would never wish harm upon him.
Um, well actually I said "beat the crap out of him and then let him go" meaning that I don't want them TO KILL HIM.. which is what is going to happen.
I was ACTUALLY wishing for the best possible outcome... but if you want to twist it to mean whatever.. that is fine. :D
Wow... Beat the crap outta him? How nice of you.. I don't get some people. I agree that if he did go outside of the wire, it was his fault he got captured. But even so, I would never wish harm upon him.
So do you think it should be YOUR husband/brother/family member/friend that goes to rescue this guy and risk their lives?? Whose is more valuable?
Whether its his fault or not, I hope that he comes back home.
We all do.. but they won't release him until we release their prisoners.. Not happening, unfortunately.
Yes... He is an american, and deserves to live. No one truly knows what happened.. And here are the reasons in my head to why none of it makes sense... If he truly left the wire, in his pts and no gun... Why did no one stop him? They musta seen him if they knew the detail in how he left, and knew it was off. Also who in their right mind just leaves? They are in a foreign country, didn't take any gear, didn't take their gun, just left- that makes absolutly no sense. I've eard of people deserting on leave, but its extremely rare for people to do it while in a combat zone. Which makes it seem that either they were lying about how he left, didn't care that he left, or that he went crazy (ptsd, or perhaps tortured by people in his unit- it happens) and left.
Yes... He is an american, and deserves to live. No one truly knows what happened.. And here are the reasons in my head to why none of it makes sense... If he truly left the wire, in his pts and no gun... Why did no one stop him? They musta seen him if they knew the detail in how he left, and knew it was off. Also who in their right mind just leaves? They are in a foreign country, didn't take any gear, didn't take their gun, just left- that makes absolutly no sense. I've eard of people deserting on leave, but its extremely rare for people to do it while in a combat zone. Which makes it seem that either they were lying about how he left, didn't care that he left, or that he went crazy (ptsd, or perhaps tortured by people in his unit- it happens) and left.
Or his loyalty lies elsewhere. Either way we look at it, we will not negotiate. Too bad, so sad. He should have fought to the death or off'd himself as a last resort. It would have been MUCH easier on his family.
The circumstances of Bergdahls capture werent clear.
On July 2, two U.S. officials told the AP the soldier had just walked off his base with three Afghans after his shift. He had no body armor or weapon and they said they had no explanation for why he left. The officials spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the case.
On July 6, the Taliban claimed on their Web site that five days earlier a drunken American soldier had come out of his garrison and was captured by mujahadeen.
In the video, Pfc. Bergdahl said he was lagging behind a patrol when he was
captured.
Details of such incidents are routinely held very tightly by the military as it works to retrieve a missing or captured soldier without giving away any information to captors.
If he was deserting, and people saw- why didn't they arrest him right then?
I don't THINK anybody SAW, but they are going on evidence. His weapon was found as was his body armor. Sometimes it's not hard to put together the puzzle pieces.
Also, I'm confused.. Bergdahl said that he was lagging behind a patrol when he was captured.. but I find that hard to believe because then someone WOULD HAVE seen it.. Also, if you are lagging behind a patrol... you wouldn't be unarmed..