Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Breaking the binky!

who's talking here?

MomOf2inCali 3
hailstorm 3
KellyBean 1
Barbie 7
Rocketmama 1
YouReallyThinkSo 1
Scrappy 4
Samantha07 2
Karen25 1
Doo Schnugget 1
BosssLady 1
crystalblue 2
Kaisully 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

I need some tips/prayers....it's been a LONG day.

I've done everything in my power to keep her busy but the kid isn't having it. All day she walks to the kitchen and sits screaming by the cabinet I keep them in. I know I have to stand my ground but this is hard. She wont even let me come near her just cries and runs away saying "mean" How long does it take to break them? 

hailstorm --- 15 years ago -

did you just take it away cold turkey? id say probably a week at the most. maybe put them somewhere else and open the cabinet for her to see that they are not there anymore. 

Rocketmama --- 15 years ago -

She wont even let me come near her just cries and runs away saying "mean"
I'm sorry but that made me LOL. I don't have any advice, just well wishes. Both my boys, at three months, threw theirs at me and didn't want it back. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

did you just take it away cold turkey? id say probably a week at the most. maybe put them somewhere else and open the cabinet for her to see that they are not there anymore.

I threw them away I knew if I had them in the house I would give her one. 

KellyBean --- 15 years ago -

Does your daughter like Dora? My girls were terrible when I first tried to take their binkies away cold turkey. After day 3 of madness, I told them that Swiper the sneaky fox from Dora swiped the binkies and I couldn't find them! They couldn't believe that Swiper was in our house and loved shouting "Swiper no swiping!" again and again. It was never an issue after that. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

I'm sorry but that made me LOL. I don't have any advice, just well wishes. Both my boys, at three months, threw theirs at me and didn't want it back.

lol I would laugh if someone put that too. My son has never got the hang of them I've tried a few times and he acts like he's chocking on it 

hailstorm --- 15 years ago -

oh well just stick it out. tell her they are gone, show her inside the cabinet and let her cry. she will get over it. im a mean mommy though lol. i threw my sons away too samn with his bottles and switching to whole milk. all in one day. no transitions or anything. 

BosssLady --- 15 years ago -

Throwing them away was probably the best thing you could do. How old is she? I never had an issue with my kids, but my mom.told me that when I was old enough to understand the "big girl" concept she told me that only babies drink bottles and have binkies so if I was a big girl I had to throw it away. And I did. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

She will get over it pretty quick as long as you dont give in. We took our sons away at two and he hasnt even noticed which shocked us because he loved that thing. My other son cried off and on for a couple days but he soon forgot about it too. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

She's throwing up from all the screaming, I'm having a hard time sticking to my guns. My neighbor said I should start off giving it to her only at naps and bed time she said it can cause some physiological problems. My husband thinks we should just stick to the plan but I'm having second thoughts 

hailstorm --- 15 years ago -

she will be fine, just have to stick to your guns. youve already taken it away and she will forget about it. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

she will be fine, just have to stick to your guns. youve already taken it away and she will forget about it. 

x2 she isnt going to develop psychological problems because you took her passy away. That is a bit ridiculous. 

Samantha07 --- 15 years ago -

I slowly took my sons away. I only gave it to him at naps and bedtime. Then I took it away from both. He fell asleep in the car and didn't "need" the pacifer to fall asleep. Then at bed he cried for about 20 mins and was so tired from crying he fell asleep. Next night it was 10-15 mins and third night a few cries and he was out.

I read though that if you cut the pacifer end, kids don't like it and take themselves off of it.

Or if she would understand- a going away "party" for the pacifers that there going to go to a new baby.

(I just realized you said you threw them away)

Just stick to what your doing though, its tough listening to the crying and whinning. Give it a few days 

YouReallyThinkSo --- 15 years ago -

Stick to it, we just took my sons away bout 2 weeks ago. Cutting the tip was horrible. He was so mad at me and kept throwing it at me saying binky. It was horrible. What I ended up doing was have him throw it away and it worked great. He stopped asking for it and stopped looking for it. I told him it he was a big boy and it was time to throw his binky in the trash cause it was breaking and he stopped crying looked and me and said ok. He then grabbed from where it landed after he had thrown it at me and put it in the trash and said bye bye... It worked so while. This was after most of the day from h3ll because I clipped the end. 

crystalblue --- 15 years ago -

how old is she? 

Samantha07 --- 15 years ago -

Cutting the tip was horrible. He was so mad at me and kept throwing it at me saying binky

I didn't try it with my son, I just read about it.

Glad your son did it on his own. :)

I also keep telling him pacifiers are for babies...and my 3 week old is a baby so she gets one.I just keep telling him thats for babies and your a big boy. So far he wants nothing to do with a pacifer except to take it out of a babies or another child's mouth and try to give it back to them and he has very bad aim lol 

MomOf2inCali --- 15 years ago -

We burried them, my duahgter dug them up. I threw them away she would find a hidden one. We sewed it up in a build a bear she pulled the seam and got it. We cut the tip she put the whole thing in her mouth. We took it away and she didnt sleep for seriously 2 days until she was so tired she would fall asleep standing lol. I talked to the doc and she said let her have it, it wasnt hurting anything.
Two weeks ago at bed time I told her if we cut the whole suck part off and put it under her pillow the binky fairy would come leave her a suprise. She was all about it. I also told her if she went a week without asking or crying we could go do something fun. Today we went to the movie. She hasnt asked once. I even found a binky in my purse and she grabbed it and said it was nasty and threw it away. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

We sewed it up in a build a bear

Why? Lol 

MomOf2inCali --- 15 years ago -

It was some binky party thing one of my friends had done. They went to build a bear and put the binky inside so they still had it with them. Her daughter dug it. Mine killed it, literally... 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

how old is she?

She's 2

This is rough not only on me but my whole street...she has a scream that can wake the dead and it's all she's done all day 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

MomOf2inCali --- 4 min ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
It was some binky party thing one of my friends had done. They went to build a bear and put the binky inside so they still had it with them. Her daughter dug it. Mine killed it, literally... 


That's actually cute lol. I'm glad you explained it cause I was like whaaa....there are much easier ways to dispose of a binky hahaha. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

I did it! She's finally asleep I almost gave in so my husband decided to take her on a car ride and it worked. I just hope it goes better tomorrow 

crystalblue --- 15 years ago -

yikes 2 ! i bet that is a hard age .... the ped told us 6 months so it went in the trash at six months t was a hard week but after the week he did not miss it . out of sight out of mind . i say just trash it . good luck! 

Kaisully --- 15 years ago -

At 2.5 my son was still in love with binks. I dreaded the day we would take them away. And also got overwhelmed with different advice. One day tho, we drove to San Diego and forgot them. He had to go all day without and it was rough at times but I'd distract him. When we got home, I thought hey..I won't give him one since he's gone all day. Let's see if he sleeps thru night. He did!!!! The next day he only asked a few times but I just said no more binks your a big boy! Then distracted him, within 2 days he never asked again, and I thought it'd be war before trying!!! So, it's to each their own. Let her tell you when she's ready, and don't do it too early, I'd say 2.5at the oldest. And make it fun for her. Have her throw them all away as a sign of growing up. Give her treats as encouragement. Most of all though, do not cave!! 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

I just took my son's away, but we are doing it slow. I tried cold turkey and he would stay up till midnight screaming after going down to sleep at 8 and he wouldn't take naps, would just sit and scream for hours. So i cut the tip of and gave it to him. I let him keep it and he wouldn't use it. he would hold it in his mouth but couldn't suck on it, so he would most of the time just throw it and go without it. But he still wanted to know it was there to comfort him. After 2 days he started just sleeping with it, not having it in his mouth but sleeping with it in his bed, and I have slowly been taking that away. He never cries to go to sleep anymore, but he some nights will stay up late playing in his room. 

Karen25 --- 15 years ago -

Yeah im dreading this..my son only takes his at naps ..its the hospital soothie to ive tried giving.him.different pacifiers I tried an advent one it was like 6.bucks for 2 they looked nice.and.didnt take up his whole face oo no wasnt having it hes 16 months now ...im taking it soon . Maybe ill do that build a bear thing cute idea. 

Barbie --- 15 years ago -

its the hospital soothie to ive tried giving.him.different pacifiers I tried an advent one it was like 6.bucks for 2 they looked nice.and.didnt take up his whole face oo no wasnt having it

Those are the only ones my daugther will take too. I'm taking her today to get a stuffed animal I read it helps when they have a soft toy to cuddle with. I hope it works! 

MomOf2inCali --- 15 years ago -

The aquarium in La Jolla (I think) did a binky day. Look online for activities. It sounds so weird but is neat for the little ones. The aquarium was neat. If your kiddo brought their binky that was their admission (it also got 3 other people in for FREE!) It was a very cool thing. They all got a little stuffed animal and made to feel real special like big kids.
The binky fairy was neat. When she woke up it was just gone. She asked for it once but I told her we would need to write a note to put under her pillow to see if the fairy still had it, but that her cool new toy would have to go back with the fairy. She was like umm NO!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground