Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

TLC Surprise Homecoming

who's talking here?

Skittles 1
hailstorm 1
*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* 1
grantsmommy 2
Nyki 2
SadpanDUH 3
Tearsa 1
ChefsDoItBetter3 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

i like some parts of the TLC version better than the Lifetime but its just weird they copied it!

thoughts? 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

all the darn military related commercials have me tearing up! lol im super hormonal prego today! 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

I just hate that both shows. Is they show so many army homecoming 

Nyki --- 15 years ago -

And I guess he was serious when he made that song I want my mullet back 

SadpanDUH --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Nyki. I really don't care for either show. I mean, they're sweet, and I'll watch it if I am int he mood, or if there's nothing else on, but they really mostly do Army. Which is not a big deal, I mean Army fights for our country too, but it's not what branch I affiliate myself with, so I find it a little harder to relate. Also, for whatever reason, it bothers me that they depict it the way they do. With all the fancy surprises... Cause ti doesn't happen that way. You wait in the heat or the cold for hours on end, until they arrive, and they just want to go home and rest. And that's if you have it lucky, and they aren't injured mentally/physically. It's not a big party. I mean, it is, in your head, but most don't want to get drunk, stay up late talking with friends and stuff after a long flight in a cargo plane back to the states. Mostly, they just want a hug, and to fall into their own bed, surrounded by their close family.

Not saying that there aren't exceptions to the rule, but that's been my experience.

I just feel as though they try to make it seem much more fantastical than it is. I mean, it's always wonderful to have them home, and I know, it's a TV show, they have to make t worth watching, yadda yadda, but i just don't watch it, since it kind of fills my head with fanciful ideas of how it will be when I know that's not how it is.

Not sure if that made a lick a sense, but w/e. =) 

SadpanDUH --- 15 years ago -

And certainly not all of them get to go home to be on TV, and be in a surprise country concert. 

Tearsa --- 15 years ago -

I cant watch the show now that I am preggo cause all I do is cry! lol But I agree its normally not some big party when then come home. My first deployment with my husband he was injured and i met him at the Naval Hospital. the 2nd time it was FREEZING and pouring down rain and they were 3 hours later than what we were told! I looked like a drown rat and he was so tired he passed out as soon as we got back to the hotel room lol Its nice that that they are doing that for a few families I guess but sad that they are giving ppl the wrong idea of how a homecoming really is. 

hailstorm --- 15 years ago -

I totally agree BabyBack! I can't watch the Coming Home show after the one episode where the host spoke to some guys command and "asked" for him to come home off ship to surprise his daughter. It actually pissed me off that they put that in the show trying to pretend like that is something that is even possible. I think it makes people happy to see the men and women coming home like that but it is in no way reality. I know a lot of my friends have already asked me to tell me the story of how my husband came home. Uhm, he got off a bus and we hugged but he had to leave for 30 min to find all his crap and we went home where he slept. Not much of a tv show ending. 

SadpanDUH --- 15 years ago -

Yeah. that's what made me a little mad too. The fact that they aired the part where they ask the guys command. I was like, damn, if I asked my husband's command if he could come home early to surprise his family, they'd be like what shit are you smoking, cause I gotta get me some. And then they'd bash my hubby and make fun of him and he may even get some form of reprimand from his command.

And yeah, life is not a TV show. I mean, yes, it's amazing to finally have them home again after so long, and it is a dream come true to those closely involved, but to others it's not that exciting of a story. 

Skittles --- 15 years ago -

The episode that irked me the most was the pilot who took his jet from country back to the states to offer a flag to a family of a fallen soldier. My husband's remark was of course they let him do it...it gave the USMC a ton of P.R. which I think is crap 'cause it's very misleading. I was pretty excited to watch the series until I watched a couple episodes and now I don't give two cents about whether I watch it or not. I agree with all you ladies...portray it how it actually is. There's enough emotion in the real homecomings. I took pictures for a neighbor's homecoming and it was pretty small but the wives were still running up to their husbands crying introducing their babies to their daddy for the first time or the mom's who grabbed their son's face crying 'cause they were so happy. Like I said there is enough emotion in the real homecomings without all the hype. 

ChefsDoItBetter3 --- 15 years ago -

*Bump- anyone going to watch this tomorrow? 

*Stuart Mesa mother of 1* --- 15 years ago -

No. I just said good bye to mine an hour ago. I have too long to wait to be watching homecomings. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground