Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Help...Should Camp Pendleton Patch stop posting links?

who's talking here?

Lavender is Good 4
UnicornsR4Gangstas 7
LakerGirl 3
Taminator 1
Green Chick 8
Barbie 1
LilyB 1
Jack Hass 1
southernheart88 1
xVivaLaDollx 4
whatevergirl2 3
MissTexas 1
Texas9 1
Momma2Fur 2
Doo Schnugget 1
Obey the golden rule 3
Camp Pendleton Patch 22

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Help...Should Camp Pendleton Patch stop posting links?

I really don't think I'm out of line here. One of the moderators threatened to ice me if I didn't stop posting links to Camp Pendleton Patch. First she said it was because I was spamming. I told her I wasn't. Then she said it was because I wasn't allowed to link to for-profit websites. I'm [url=http://pendletonunderground.com/topic.jsp?w=&s=30&n=30&topicId=11653547]posing questions that the PU community cares about[/url]. Look at the conversation I've started. PU has advertising on it, so that doesn't make sense. Furthermore, I've even offered to pay for event expenses for military wives on this site. Call it sponsorship or call it charity. I also employ military wives, some of whom you know on PU. I'm also giving bloggers the opportunity to have their voices heard on a site that has a substantial viewership. Patch connects volunteers to volunteer organizations, users can post events to our calendar, make announcements, create a classifieds ad...all for free. So tell me how I'm breaking PU's terms of service. Granted, other Patch sites have advertising, and that's a typical business model for a news organization, but Camp Pendleton Patch doesn't at this point in time. Here are examples of people posting links to for-profit websites. They weren't threatened by a moderator because of it: [url=http://pendletonunderground.com/topic.jsp?topicId=11654206]CNN[/url] [url=http://pendletonunderground.com/topic.jsp?topicId=11654203]Gannett Government Media Corporation[/url] [url=http://pendletonunderground.com/topic.jsp?topicId=11654189]Babies R Us[/url] I'm just asking to be treated fairly. Why would you censor me for trying to get people talking?

Yes Vote
 
 32.9% (23)
No Vote
 
 67.1% (47)
Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

I really don't think I'm out of line here.

One of the moderators threatened to ice me if I didn't stop posting links to Camp Pendleton Patch. First she said it was because I was spamming. I told her I wasn't. Then she said it was because I wasn't allowed to link to for-profit websites.

I'm posing questions that the PU community cares about. Look at the conversation I've started.

PU has advertising on it, so that doesn't make sense. Furthermore, I've even offered to pay for event expenses for military wives on this site. Call it sponsorship or call it charity. I also employ military wives, some of whom you know on PU. I'm also giving bloggers the opportunity to have their voices heard on a site that has a substantial viewership.

Patch connects volunteers to volunteer organizations, users can post events to our calendar, make announcements, create a classifieds ad...all for free.

So tell me how I'm breaking PU's terms of service. Granted, other Patch sites have advertising, and that's a typical business model for a news organization, but Camp Pendleton Patch doesn't at this point in time.

Here are examples of people posting links to for-profit websites. They weren't threatened by a moderator because of it:

CNN

Gannett Government Media Corporation

Babies R Us

I'm just asking to be treated fairly. Why would you censor me for trying to get people talking? 

MissTexas --- 15 years ago -

Where's the "dont care?" option?
x2 

Texas9 --- 15 years ago -

Where's the "dont care?" option? 

x3.

If I open a thread and dont like it, I just move on to the next. People advertise all the time. It doesnt bother me. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

I could understand being edited or iced if I was linking to sites that had nothing to do with the lives of people on this site, but I'm doing the opposite. I'm not trying to sell anyone anything. I'm just trying to provide information. What's wrong with that?

Why do you think the moderator is doing this? 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -


Why do you think the moderator is doing this?


Power trip? Hopefully it's not the moderator that I'm friends with. LOL

Your posts don't bother me at all. At least you're not like some of the other guys on here who post pervy sex topics all the time. 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

Just a thought but try not posting more than "X" amounts a time a day and if you continue to be bothered about being iced contact the site owners...just a thought ;) 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

Your posts don't bother me at all. At least you're not like some of the other guys on here who post pervy sex topics all the time.

I'm the new breed of feminist. I'm not afraid to say that. I'm the kind of guy that will whoop your a$$ if you talk shiz about me being for women's equality. :)

Patch has hired more female editors in a field where so many women drop out after college. There's a huge percentage of women who don't go into journalism after getting a B.A. in the subject. The reason is that it's a male-dominated field.

So, ya, that's one of the reasons as a man I wouldn't post crap like that. The other reason is that I'd probably get fired. :D 

Obey the golden rule --- 15 years ago -

I think you should be allowed to continue posting. I don't think you're spamming at all. Sounds like the moderator is playing favorites. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

If they tell you to stop, then stop. Just post a thread saying if you have questions, email me. Pretty simple. No need to get your panties in a wad.

My panties are sitting comfortably, I'm just standing up for myself. I don't like being pushed around is all. This is America!!! :D Why should I stop and everyone else shouldn't have to? Ok, sure, I'm the new guy and I don't have any weight around here, but fair is fair. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

Just a thought but try not posting more than "X" amounts a time a day and if you continue to be bothered about being iced contact the site owners...just a thought ;)

I have only posted like two or three and haven't been annoying about it. Thanks for the advice, I'll consider it. :) 

Doo Schnugget --- 15 years ago -

Hey, one of those links is my thread! I don't consider any of it spamming, you're not posting like Miche Mom was, advertising her business several times per day. Your posts are more like news stories and opinions. Mine was not my own service, but a deal that PU'ers may want to know, so I don't consider that spam either. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

I think you should be allowed to continue posting. I don't think you're spamming at all.

Thank you. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

Hey, one of those links is my thread!

I wasn't trying to call you out, I'm sorry. I was just trying to prove a point. The moderator won't tell you to stop as a result of my comment because I'm sure she knows you didn't do anything wrong. And that's my point. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

Pendleton Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Pendleton community


The moderator who threatened to ice you needs to look up at the top of the page where it describes what this site is about. I think Camp Pendleton Patch fits right in with that description. I would rather see posts about relevant news and local interest topics than see one more post about the latest Scentsy specials! If you're going to ice anyone, please ice all the "home business" people. lol
Nothing against running a home business, but I personally think those topics should be kept on PYS. On some undergrounds you are not allowed to post that stuff at all. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I run a home based business and I know I have posted my link here before. I have never been asked not to. I don't think it is fair to ask you not to post your links unless you are purposely commenting on things just to give yourself PR. If it is relevant then it shouldn't be an issue.

I would consider myself an older spouse so some of the topics seriously make me roll my eyes and some of the posters who are writing from the experienced point of view come off as sounding more know-it-all than helpful, but that is just my opinion. I didn't care for a few of the posts on the patch, but I certainly don't think you should stop posting your link. I am sure many people find things on there to be helpful. 

Jack Hass --- 15 years ago -

I consider it spamming to an extent but you're not annoying like that one purse/blog chic. You bring something to the table in your threads other then "look at me" so it doesn't bother me. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

This is the pendleton underground where sh*t ain't fair and the crotch rot mods make the rules. Live with it like we all do.

But technically you all aren't "living with it" if you can post links and I can't. See what I'm saying? :/ And the mods make the rules, but do they also make rules that break the previous rules? And do some rules apply to certain people? That doesn't make sense. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

the mods make the rules

No. They're only supposed to enforce the rules that the site owners have established. 

Obey the golden rule --- 15 years ago -

No. They're only supposed to enforce the rules that the site owners have established.


This.

So if a mod is selectively applying the rules and not being fair then that needs to be looked into. That person then does not make a good moderator. 

UnicornsR4Gangstas --- 15 years ago -

I don't think what your doing is spam.. If you comment every thread or made numerous amounts of threads that had the same message, then you would be spamming. 3 or 4 links in a couple of days NOT spamming. 

xVivaLaDollx --- 15 years ago -

But technically you all aren't "living with it" if you can post links and I can't. See what I'm saying? :/

0 

UnicornsR4Gangstas --- 15 years ago -

I think your being targeted cause your the new Guy. The PU is watchful of new accounts. 

Lavender is Good --- 15 years ago -

I simply asked you to stop posting the link to the site that you personally benefit from on every single post. I have been out of town and when I got on I saw a bunch of your links all on the first page and sent you a message asking you to not do that since we just dealt with this issue with someone else.

As I have said before if people don't won't me to be a moderator here I have no issue with that. I have no desire to put in the time and effort moderation takes if my efforts are not wanted. 

Obey the golden rule --- 15 years ago -

I simply asked you to stop posting the link to the site that you personally benefit from on every single post.


I agree that if someone posts several times a day that is spamming but what is the difference between the OP in this post and anyone that posts about their own homebased business ie. scentsy, pampered chef, body wraps, hair services, pet training, ect.? Where is the line drawn? What counts as spamming, 1 post, 2 posts? 5 posts? 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

I'm going to believe Lav-Lav on this one

x2 I stand by what I said as far as not posting on every thread just for PR, but if Lavender noticed you doing something that is considered spam then I believe her.

She is one of the most fair people I have ever met. 

Lavender is Good --- 15 years ago -

I agree that if someone posts several times a day that is spamming but what is the difference between the OP in this post and anyone that posts about their own homebased business ie. scentsy, pampered chef, body wraps, hair services, pet training, ect.? Where is the line drawn? What counts as spamming, 1 post, 2 posts? 5 posts?

I just asked him to not post the link to the site anymore. Increasing the traffic to it is part of his job. He had already gotten it out there in a positive way on many occasions, he had the link in his profile (which I pointed out was fine) plus it is his user name and I did not ask him to not talk about it. After what we just dealt with over the miche mom thing I just didn't want the same thing to happen again. I did it privately via PM. I did so only because in general the people of PU have not seemed to appreciate spamming.

Again, I will happily put my own account up for moderator removal if it is felt that I was on a "power trip" and my help is no longer wanted. 

southernheart88 --- 15 years ago -

Oh gosh really ? 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

Put on your big boy pants.

That's what I was doing. Big boys stand up for themselves. I didn't call Lavender out by name because I didn't want it to come to this...I'm not calling for her resignation, just for what's fair.

My feelings aren't hurt, I just want to be able to post relevant links. Who cares if the links come from the same site, there of different topics. Topics that people are talking about.


I'm going to believe Lav-Lav on this one.


What's there to believe? No one is lying here. We just happen to feel differently about what the rules are and how they should be applied.

Clearly there is a majority and a minority opinion on the matter, just sayin'.

You can say I'm crying and that my feelings have been hurt all you want, but the fact remains the same. 

Camp Pendleton Patch --- 15 years ago -

Umm, all you have to do is look at my comment history. There are some shoddy lines of reasoning being slapped together on this thread. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Again, I will happily put my own account up for moderator removal if it is felt that I was on a "power trip" and my help is no longer wanted.

I don't think anyone would ask you to remove your mod privileges over this situation. I am glad you said something because it is nice to have both sides of the story. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

charity
help
pendleton
pu

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground