Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Which Would You Choose?

who's talking here?

KeyboardWarrior 4
Mommeee Drest 1
TrueYooperAtHeart 1
Smile 1
NoSugarAdded 1
Scrappy 1
MasonsMama 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Which Would You Choose?

I've interviewed for two positions this week and, while it's not guaranteed that I'll be offered both jobs, I find myself trying to weigh the pros and cons of each position if I AM offered both jobs. Which would you choose? Position A: Desk job. The work itself isn't too thrilling. Computer work mostly with a bit of administrative stuff thrown in. M-F 8-4:30 kind of job. Guaranteed weekends off, holidays off. Position B: Communications Operator aka 911 operator. Shift work: either 4am-4pm or 4pm-4am. 3 days on, 4 days off, then 3 day 12 hours and 1 day 8 hour. Not guaranteed holidays off or weekends off. Work, itself, is more interesting.

Position A Vote
 
 65.4% (17)
Position B Vote
 
 34.6% (9)
KeyboardWarrior --- 15 years ago -

I've interviewed for two positions this week and, while it's not guaranteed that I'll be offered both jobs, I find myself trying to weigh the pros and cons of each position if I AM offered both jobs.

Which would you choose?

Position A:

Desk job. The work itself isn't too thrilling. Computer work mostly with a bit of administrative stuff thrown in. M-F 8-4:30 kind of job. Guaranteed weekends off, holidays off.

Position B:

Communications Operator aka 911 operator. Shift work: either 4am-4pm or 4pm-4am. 3 days on, 4 days off, then 3 day 12 hours and 1 day 8 hour. Not guaranteed holidays off or weekends off. Work, itself, is more interesting. 

NoSugarAdded --- 15 years ago -

Do yo have children? 

KeyboardWarrior --- 15 years ago -

Yes. I have two kids. My husband is in a non-deployable position right now for the next 4 years. And the pay is pretty even with both positions. :) 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

With small children I would not even be considering 911. The crazy hours, the stress, the emotions...for me, if I am working outside of the home again, it's going to be a nothing, easy, relaxed, going nowhere job because I've been on the other side and we almost got divorced. It's too hard juggling and the added stress doesn't help anybody.

My kids are all much older now so they can take care of themselves most of the time and there wouldn't be as much stress. But this is about you, and whatever you decide I wish you lots of luck =)

**not to mention you will miss most holidays as the "newbie". 

TrueYooperAtHeart --- 15 years ago -

Position a would be my choice. With kids it just make more sense.:) good luck! 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I'd pick A just because I love desk work :) 

KeyboardWarrior --- 15 years ago -

But this is about you, and whatever you decide I wish you lots of luck =)

Thanks. I am leaning more towards Job A because of the weekends and holidays off. I'd like to be able to spend the weekends with my family. I find out today about that job, so here's hoping! 

Smile --- 15 years ago -

Are your children in school? If so I say do the desk job so you can spend time with them. I know I hated my mom working 3-12s and 2-8s a week because I felt like she was so asleep or at work I never got time with her. And that's just how it is. Also how she always missed holidays and hardly had weekends off. 

MasonsMama --- 15 years ago -

With small children I would not even be considering 911. The crazy hours, the stress, the emotions...for me, if I am working outside of the home again, it's going to be a nothing, easy, relaxed, going nowhere job because I've been on the other side and we almost got divorced. It's too hard juggling and the added stress doesn't help anybody.

Exactly. When I started working even a 8-430 job with my son it was too much. I was driving near2 hrs a day to commute and got to see my son for an hour a day, and spent my weekends running errands and all the other things I didn't get to do during the week, like clean my house. I was left little time to spend with my son and my marriage and my sanity was under a lot of stress because of it. It's really up to you though, my son is only one, so it's a big thing to spend time with him now and it was the first time I had returned to work since he was born. I ended up quitting after 5 months and now I'm much happier spending time with him. 

KeyboardWarrior --- 15 years ago -

Masons--my commute would be 25-30 minutes. It's on base :) I looked at jobs in San Diego as well, but for all the reasons you mentioned in your post, I decided against that option.

Everything you ladies have said have really help clear my mind about the choice! Thanks :) 

MasonsMama --- 15 years ago -

Masons--my commute would be 25-30 minutes. It's on base :) I looked at jobs in San Diego as well, but for all the reasons you mentioned in your post, I decided against that option.

I wish I would have thought about adding the commute and everything in when I was looking for work. I didn't realize what a big stress it was going to add to me not seeing my son hardly ever. I hope it works out for you :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground