Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Do you think...

who's talking here?

CourtesyFlush 6
Jillian 5
Mommeee Drest 1
ALS MommaKitty 6
sofaa 11
Kariane 2
DotComMyLife 3
5811wife 1
Pseudonym 6
2Gems4Ever 20
Jane Wayne 15
Taminator 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
BadMomma2 2
emysmama2 1
Turquoise 2
KIT 113 1
panda 1
ValsalvaManeuver 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think...

It's appropriate for a kinder class to be discussing fat and skinny. Remember this is 5 and 6 year olds who may not fully understand what it means.

Yes Vote
 
 23.0% (14)
No Vote
 
 67.2% (41)
Other Vote
 
 9.8% (6)
ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

It's appropriate for a kinder class to be discussing fat and skinny. Remember this is 5 and 6 year olds who may not fully understand what it means. 

5811wife --- 15 years ago -

In what context are they discussing it? 

emysmama2 --- 15 years ago -

I think they should discuss results of eating healthy and not eating healthy 

Taminator --- 15 years ago -

I think that 5-6 is old enough to understand a size difference and maybe the discussion will help with teasing 

KIT 113 --- 15 years ago -

Depends on how they are describing it and why? I guess. Ive had this conversation with my daughter (4) she called my grandmother fat one day, had no clue where the heck she heard it from.. She understands now that Fat is not a nice word. What was the situation? Was it meant to correct a kid from saying those words.. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

So my daughter tells me that in school the sub was discussing fat and skinny. Ok, nutrition is important and I think it should be taught. But then she tells me that she was told that fat people get sick and can die, NOT APPROPRIATE. I ask her what is fat and she tells me that she is *pinching her side* because she has rolls. My child is far from fat. I think the discussion went to far and was not in the vernacular a child that age could understand.

Thank god this sub is now gone, this is the same woman who gave my child 2 ringpops in one day. WTF is this woman thinking. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

i voted no but it depends on why and how they are describing it, i think it is appropriate to discuss good and bad food choices 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

Food choices are one thing, describing fat and skinny to kids who cannot understand is just plain wrong. 

BadMomma2 --- 15 years ago -

I ask her what is fat and she tells me that she is *pinching her side* because she has rolls. My child is far from fat.

this is scary - you can teach children about being healthy without altering their their self image 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Fat and skinny are very general, loose terms so no, I don't think that's something to teach a kid that young in school. Fat and skinny are not even proper medical terms.

I agree they should be taught healthy vs unhealthy or what it means to be underweight, healthy weight, obese etc. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

this is scary - you can teach children about being healthy without altering their their self image

Exactly, I was so sad. I had to sit down with her and explain that she is in no way fat. I showed her pictures of healthy women and explained she was just like them. She eats a good amount and is very active, health is the most important. She told me "I told P I wasnt fat, I knew I was right" LOL, I am glad she now believes she is healthy again. 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

Depends on how they are describing it and why? I guess. Ive had this conversation with my daughter (4) she called my grandmother fat one day, had no clue where the heck she heard it from.. She understands now that Fat is not a nice word. What was the situation? Was it meant to correct a kid from saying those words..

Took the words right out of my mouth! Many things come up in a classroom/on the playground. Some teachers go the extra step and have a discussion about it. A child is never too young to learn right from wrong.

ETA: Right and wrong when it pertains to eating right, staying active, not calling names. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

Exactly, I was so sad. I had to sit down with her and explain that she is in no way fat. I showed her pictures of healthy women and explained she was just like them. She eats a good amount and is very active, health is the most important. She told me "I told P I wasnt fat, I knew I was right" LOL, I am glad she now believes she is healthy again.

I'm glad you were able to explain it to her in a way she understood. I think fat is a nasty word period, and no one should ever be called it whether they are large or not. 

panda --- 15 years ago -

Yea it depends on how, that teacher obviously stepped out of line. I think I'd complain. 

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

It's too early for them to teach the kids the diffrences in looks already. Thats like them teaching them abt race, it's not the right time yet. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Well, maybe we should stop sugar coating it and making people think that being fat is okay...it's not. It's unhealthy. Maybe she didn't explain it appropriately but I think it's a great topic to touch on. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Thats like them teaching them abt race, it's not the right time yet. 

Why not? My son has already asked me questions about race and he's only 3.... 

2Gems4Ever --- 15 years ago -

Well, maybe we should stop sugar coating it and making people think that being fat is okay...it's not. It's unhealthy. Maybe she didn't explain it appropriately but I think it's a great topic to touch on.

Ummm fat isn't the only thing unhealthy. Skinny can be unhealthy as well. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -


Ummm fat isn't the only thing unhealthy. Skinny can be unhealthy as well. 



True, but skinny isn't a huge problem in America...... 

2Gems4Ever --- 15 years ago -


True, but skinny isn't a huge problem in America......



Its not a problem that is talked about in America. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

Its not a problem that is talked about in America. 



What population of America is overweight? How many are underweight? Not even in the same category. Everywhere you look people are overweight. It's a HUGE problem and becoming bigger especially in children which is SAD. Childhood obesity is 100% preventable! 

Jillian --- 15 years ago -

What population of America is overweight? How many are underweight? Not even in the same category. Everywhere you look people are overweight. It's a HUGE problem and becoming bigger especially in children which is SAD. Childhood obesity is 100% preventable!

I have to agree. And as far as america not talking about being too skinny, I totally disagree. I think people talk about being too skinny all the time. People aren't afraid to tell someone that they look too skinny. On the other hand, if you tell someone who is obese that you're worried about their health, it's horrible and mean. I don't think they should be discussing "skinny and fat" in schools, per say, but I do think they need to start discussing healthy choices, healthy size, etc as early as they can. It makes me so sad to see today's kids doing nothing but eating junk food and playing video games. (not all kids obviously) 

2Gems4Ever --- 15 years ago -


What population of America is overweight? How many are underweight? Not even in the same category. Everywhere you look people are overweight. It's a HUGE problem and becoming bigger especially in children which is SAD. Childhood obesity is 100% preventable!



I don't need statistics I work in the healthcare field. People who are underweight can have the same problems that an overweight person can have. Neither is good. 

Pseudonym --- 15 years ago -

yes it's appropriate, stop getting all bent out of shape because you're afraid that one day your kid is going to come home and tell you that you are fat, if you can't run an army pft you might want to get in shape, i mean really 1.5mi is not that far! 

ValsalvaManeuver --- 15 years ago -

a great topic to touch on. 

a fantastic topic! education about health and nutrition in America needs reform! So many people are ill because of being overweight, and if you have [insert disease here] as a complication of being overweight... it's preventable!!!

I understand not everyone cares about their health, and it's not even an issue of vanity anymore... it's an issue of HEALTH. Preventable diseases cost americans TONS of money in tax dollars. It would be more cost efficient to put the money into education programs about preventative measures and keeping our population HEALTHY! Not skinny, but HEALTHY!

Just my humble opinion. 

Turquoise --- 15 years ago -

Why not? My son has already asked me questions about race and he's only 3....

Let me rephrase that, teaching them abt the issues that come along with race. There is no problem with saying some people are this size, others are this size. Orrrrr saying some ppl are this color others r this color. I do think its innappropriate to say "Some ppl think white ppl are superior and theres a such thing as the KKK... Um no waaaaay too much info for their young brains. They need to become more mature. 

2Gems4Ever --- 15 years ago -

yes it's appropriate, stop getting all bent out of shape because you're afraid that one day your kid is going to come home and tell you that you are fat, if you can't run an army pft you might want to get in shape, i mean really 1.5mi is not that far!


Really?? It may not be that far but it can surely help prevent diabetes and heart disease. 

ValsalvaManeuver --- 15 years ago -

it can surely help prevent diabetes and heart disease. 

AGREE. AGREE. AGREE.

& Diabetes is a NASTY disease. I've seen some nasty complications of that disease, it's not something you want... at all costs PREVENT it if you can. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

but to say one takes precedence is blind ignorance. 

I don't think so.....

Look at numbers. Look at the amount of people and children with health problems related to obesity vs. those with health problems related to eating disorders. There is an ALARMING number of overweight children and a large amount of them already have, or will, develop diabetes, sleep apnea, heart failure, asthma, digestive problems... the list could go on and on...

How many elementary schoolers do you know that are anorexic? Only a few out of a whole high school probably suffer from an eating disorder... I'm willing to bet over half are overweight. That is way more concerning.... 

Pseudonym --- 15 years ago -

look, i smoke a pack within 3 days, drink until there's no more beer, and just about on the drop of a hat can run a 1st class pft and make weight. i personally think im a lazy Marine but i do well enough, so why cant the rest of America do the same? 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground