Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Doctor or midwife??

who's talking here?

KeyboardWarrior 1
Mommeee Drest 1
ALS MommaKitty 3
LakerGirl 2
Jane Wayne 1
grantsmommy 1
~Lauren~ 1
JAZZ 1
Crystal9604 2
Vod Kaknockers 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Doctor or midwife??

Just wondering what most people prefer for pregnancy and delivery?? I had a midwife with my daughter,and I absolutely loved her, but that was back home. Which would you recommend?? I'm not really sure of the exact differences, so any info will help :)

Doctor (OB) Vote
 
 67.9% (19)
Midwife Vote
 
 32.1% (9)
Crystal9604 --- 15 years ago -

Just wondering what most people prefer for pregnancy and delivery?? I had a midwife with my daughter,and I absolutely loved her, but that was back home. Which would you recommend?? I'm not really sure of the exact differences, so any info will help :) 

JAZZ --- 15 years ago -

My first pregnancy I had a doctor and with this pregnancy I have been seeing a midwife (given to me by the clinic, not my choice) I felt more comfortable with the doctor. 

Crystal9604 --- 15 years ago -

But if you have a doctor, doesnt that mean that you see a few different soca for your checkups, and whoever is on call delivers for you? 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

Ive had both and loved both. Midwives spend like 6 years of training on just birth and everything around it. Docs have to know basics and choose specialty after they have become a doc. It depends on your specific needs and comfort. My first was a midwife and im thankful for that, she was awesome. My miscarriage, 2nd and 3rd child was all Dr Takahashi and I cannot express words for how much I love her. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

But if you have a doctor, doesnt that mean that you see a few different soca for your checkups, and whoever is on call delivers for you?

Not necessarily. My first was delivered by the midwife I had had all along. Second was done by my doc and third would have been except her car broke down on the way to the hospital so she was consulting via phone while stoker and an intern actually delivered. 

Vod Kaknockers --- 15 years ago -

I had an OB the entire time I was pregnant and only saw her. I had a midwife that was checking on me after my water broke, because my OB was on a flight coming off of leave, and there were 8 other women giving birth at the same time as I was. She got to the hospital 5 mins after my daughter was born. The midwife was pretty cool other than she tried to talk me out of getting meds. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

The midwife was pretty cool other than she tried to talk me out of getting meds.

This reminded me of the doc and nurse trying to convince me to go talk to the girl down the hall after I gave birth. I did it all natural and they ere for sure she could do it to, she was just told by so many people that she couldn't do it. I ran into her on my way out, she was walking around. I told her to listen to her body and to the pro's, if she felt good then why mess with it, dont let others tell you cant do something. She ended up giving birth 10 mins later, all natural (proving a few in-laws wrong hahaha). 

Mommeee Drest --- 15 years ago -

I was way too paranoid with my three to have anybody but a Doctor in a hospital. My best friend used to tease me all the time, because for her...... I think it was the 4th one she gave birth at home in the bathtub. Uhhh no thanks. 

KeyboardWarrior --- 15 years ago -

First time was in a birth center with traditional midwives.

Second time was in a hospital with a CNM.

I preferred the birth center setting,but they didn't have that option in NC. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

a birth center with traditional midwives.

This would be my preference if I was going to have another baby, which I'm not. I would have loved to do a water birth. I would want the birth center to be near a hospital though, just in case anything went wrong. 

grantsmommy --- 15 years ago -

tricare standard does cover a birth center in san Diego but it is a drive. i would want to sit in the car for over an hour in labor. no way i really want a water birth at home but hubby would not allow it. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

really want a water birth at home but hubby would not allow it.

What do you mean he won't "allow it"? lol
It's your body, and you're the one giving birth. Make your birth experience what YOU want it to be. When your hubby gets pregnant, grows a baby for 9 months and then gives birth, he can choose where he wants to do it! 

~Lauren~ --- 15 years ago -

My first pregnancy I had a doctor and with this pregnancy I have been seeing a midwife (given to me by the clinic, not my choice) I felt more comfortable with the doctor.

I was assigned a midwife by Tricare since NHCP was full when I went in. I tried getting in touch with her with the information Tricare had on their site - it was incorrect/out-of-date. I called them, let them know, and also let them know I wanted a doctor and NOT a midwife. They let me choose who I wanted. 

Jane Wayne --- 15 years ago -

MIDWIFE. I want to be able to do what I want to do without too many medical interventions. I have been entertaining the idea of having her at home unassisted. I trust my body to do what it's sposed to :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground