Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: deleting controversial topics.

who's talking here?

Mrs Patch 7
*All Smiles* 1
B*Bright 5
ALS MommaKitty 1
❤ me 2
Minnie 1
BadMomma 2
whatevergirlツ 1
Blondie1985 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: deleting controversial topics.

do you think they should be put to vote before mods delete/lock them?

yes Vote
 
 30.0% (15)
no Vote
 
 64.0% (32)
other Vote
 
 6.0% (3)
BadMomma --- 15 years ago -

i voted no because mods have lives as well and i dont think they can do their non paid volunteer job effectively by committee 

whatevergirlツ --- 15 years ago -

This is getting a little too far. If I deem something delete worthy it must be pretty bad. I am seriously not going to take the time to start a poll, then wait for the results. Kinda defeats the purpose of having a mod. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 15 years ago -

This is getting a little too far. If I deem something delete worthy it must be pretty bad. I am seriously not going to take the time to start a poll, then wait for the results. Kinda defeats the purpose of having a mod.

I think WEG is right 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

This is getting a little too far. If I deem something delete worthy it must be pretty bad. I am seriously not going to take the time to start a poll, then wait for the results. Kinda defeats the purpose of having a mod.

Ditto. 

Minnie --- 15 years ago -

What is your idea of controversial though Sarcasm? Abortions and pitbulls can be controversial but they don't get deleted. Topics like the recent PV "scandal" haven't been deleted just locked. 

B*Bright --- 15 years ago -

What is your idea of controversial though Sarcasm? Abortions and pitbulls can be controversial but they don't get deleted. Topics like the recent PV "scandal" haven't been deleted just locked.


Actually, some abortion topics that had links did get deleted....It was a link to a facebook page that was stealing pictures (from other peoples facebook page) of aborted babies and pictures of kids with downs syndrome and making fun of them....calling them mongrels and that they should have been aborted and all kinds of nastiness. Someone posted the link here for people to flag that page on facebook....because it was a horrible use of a facebook page..and her link got deleted because it contained an image of an aborted baby. I don't think it should have been deleted. Seeing an aborted baby isn't that gross to me, seeing one being made fun of is horrible so I thought the link should have remained so people could report the facebook page. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

abortion topics that had links did get deleted

I deleted it. The link took you directly to a picture of a dead baby. I don't think anyone wanted to see that. It wasn't until after I deleted it that the girl reposted it w/ a warning. 

BadMomma --- 15 years ago -

i remember that thread - people were upset about not being warned about the pics when they clicked the link 

*All Smiles* --- 15 years ago -

Seriously? Have a poll before deletion? That is just plain stupid. 

B*Bright --- 15 years ago -

so links that are not labels properly, are subject to deletion- i think thats good..
I deleted it. The link took you directly to a picture of a dead baby. I don't think anyone wanted to see that. It wasn't until after I deleted it that the girl reposted it w/ a warning.

people were upset about not being warned about the pics when they clicked the link


All of those about it should be deleted because it wasn't properly labeled.....

Mrs. Patch IS a moderator...why couldn't she just have edited the post with something like..

"Edited by Mrs. Patch: This link will take you to a picture of a dead baby" or something..

Why should the link be deleted and then have someone make a brand new thread with the same topic and link but with a warning....instead of deleting it, maybe mods should just edit to add the disclaimer and then tell the OP that next time they need to add the disclaimer themselves. If a mod is going to be "modding" it anyways, why not just add the disclaimer? ya know? 

❤ me --- 15 years ago -

B you are on top of it! All kinds of good suggestions! :) 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

why couldn't she just have edited the post with something like..

The only time I ever delete a link or pic is when someone doesn't know how to use the link or pic button. Adding a "disclaimer" would be in effect posting it myself. No pictures of the dead are to be posted on PU. That's what we have been removing since the deletion of all the other dead pictures while we were being spammned. 

B*Bright --- 15 years ago -

Adding a "disclaimer" would be in effect posting it myself. No pictures of the dead are to be posted on PU. That's what we have been removing since the deletion of all the other dead pictures while we were being spammned.

Well, you also knowingly let her make a new thread with the exact same subject and said that the only reason you deleted the other one was because it wasn't properly labeled. So you let the girl repost it with a warning. So, by allowing her to repost it, you "in effect" posted it yourself....so why not just add the disclaimer instead??? 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

So you let the girl repost it with a warning. So, by allowing her to repost it, you "in effect" posted it yourself....so why not just add the disclaimer instead???

Yes, and by the time she reposted it clearly stated what they were linking themselves to. That's why it wasn't deleted again. Then the fb page was made private. After that I don't know what happened. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

I do see your point. Don't think I don't. I am tired now though lol can we pick this up in the AM? I want to go watching Law & Order SVU. lol Sorry just being honest. 

B*Bright --- 15 years ago -

Yes, and by the time she reposted it clearly stated what they were linking themselves to. That's why it wasn't deleted again. Then the fb page was made private. After that I don't know what happened.

But what I'm saying is, if you are going to allow it to be reposted with a warning, then why not just write the warning yourself? Because either way you look at it, you are a mod who has the powers to delete it. If you are not deleting something then it means that you are okay with what is being posted. So either way, it would just be easier and quicker to add the warning than to have the huge arugment that ensued afterward about why it should or shouldn't have been deleted or just letting her have a warning....ya know? 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

See above lol 

B*Bright --- 15 years ago -

LOL...yeah, its cool. I"m just up bored. I took a 5hr nap today so I'm up and ready to go. LOL. But have fun watching SVU! 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

I only watch for Christopher Meloni. However, I am kind of concerned his spouses name is Sherman Williams. Does anyone know if that's really a woman under a man's name or am I just wishful thinking that he's straight? I'll check back on this later. 

Blondie1985 --- 15 years ago -

I voted other because I could really care less. 

Blondie1985 --- 15 years ago -

Said topics don't affect me/I don't get involved in them 99% of the time. 

❤ me --- 15 years ago -

I only watch for Christopher Meloni. However, I am kind of concerned his spouses name is Sherman Williams. Does anyone know if that's really a woman under a man's name or am I just wishful thinking that he's straight? I'll check back on this later.

He is straight. That is a woman. They have two children together.


link title 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground