Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Equal pay for women... nope!

who's talking here?

sofaa 3
BitBit 6
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1
Tits McGee 1
Jay Elle 6
BadMomma 4
Green Chick 1
Just Sayin 1
Samm 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

I'm kind of stunned by this.
Republicans vote unanimously against equal pay for women bill

"Senate Republicans voted unanimously Wednesday against a bill that would work to ensure fair pay for women, the Paycheck Fairness Act. The vote was 58-41.

Despite the Senate having majority support, Democrats couldn't muster the 60 votes they needed to overcome a Republican filibuster.

Several Republicans who voted for another women's rights bill last year, The Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, opposed this iteration.

Those senators included Sens. Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins, both Republicans from Maine. The bill would have expanded enforcement of equal pay laws.

Collins argued that the bill would place undue burden on small business, and "impose increased costs and restrictions on small businesses in an already difficult economic climate."

Her statement echoes rhetoric from the US Chamber of Commerce, which has routinely used small business as a defense for opposing all manner of progressive legislation. In fact, Collins even cited the Chamber's opposition to the bill in her statement.

"Many business groups oppose this legislation, including the National Federation of Independent Businesses, our nation's largest small business advocacy group, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce," Collins said.

Sen. Olympia Snowe of Maine also declined to back the expansion of enforcing equal pay for women, even though she'd been supportive of a similar bill in the past. Noted the liberal blog ThinkProgress:

Not a single Republican supported the bill, including Sens. Olympia Snowe (R-ME) and Susan Collins (R-ME), who had previously voted in favor of the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, which removed barriers blocking workers from seeking compensation from discriminatory pay practices. At the time, Snowe said, “This new law[] sends a clear message to the American people that this Congress is committed to these core principles and will continue to work in bipartisan fashion to break down the barriers of wage discrimination in our nation.”
Sen. Ben Nelson (D-NE), who also voted for the Lilly Ledbetter Act, was the lone Democrat voting against the bill today. Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) was not present for the vote.
The bill would have worked to ensure equal pay for women, giving them more remedies in the court system for wage discrimination.

The summary of the bill states that it "amends the portion of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) known as the Equal Pay Act to revise remedies for, enforcement of, and exceptions to prohibitions against sex discrimination in the payment of wages."

In a statement, President Barack Obama said he was "disappointed."

"I am deeply disappointed that a minority of Senators have prevented the Paycheck Fairness Act from finally being brought up for a debate and receiving a vote," he said. "This bill passed in the House almost two years ago; today, it had 58 votes to move forward, the support of the majority of Senate, and the support of the majority of Americans. As we emerge from one of the worst recessions in history, this bill would ensure that American women and their families aren't bringing home smaller paychecks because of discrimination."

Correction: Sens. Snowe and Collins are from Maine, not Vermont." 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

i have always earned equal or higher salary than my male counterparts - ive never had an issue

the bill would place undue burden on small business, and "impose increased costs and restrictions on small businesses in an already difficult economic climate."

shame shame shame to those that dont support same job=equal pay, what they are effectively saying is its ok to have a sub class of employees and this usually pertains to women

some days i have to check the calendar to see what year it is 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

Collins argued that the bill would place undue burden on small business, and "impose increased costs and restrictions on small businesses in an already difficult economic climate."

As a woman herself, she should be standing up for American women. Not against them. That pisses me off. Of course it would impose increased costs! To pay your workers fairly! But that is undue burden, right? I don't know what else to say. I am hoping it is corporate america whispering in her ear, and these are not her own thoughts. Scary. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

shame shame shame to those that dont support same job=equal pay, what they are effectively saying is its ok to have a sub class of employees and this usually pertains to women

some days i have to check the calendar to see what year it is 


x100! 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

some days i have to check the calendar to see what year it is 


No kidding eh? It's ridiculous. 

Samm --- 16 years ago -

I'm disappointed...but not even a little bit stunned. 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

I disagree with the article you posted and I disagree with the bill. For a variety of reasons, but mainly because the bill assumes that the pay disparity between male and female employees is a result of direct and intentional discrimination. This assumption may be true some % of the time, but the disparity in pay can also be attributed to other factors, including:

1) Women are less likely to negotiate a higher salary in accepting a position

2) Women are more likely to leave the workforce to care for children or elderly parents

3) Women are more likely to work only part time, or accept a lower paying position at a job they deem family friendly.

It is asinine and the sign of a poorly written piece of legislation to assume that a problem is caused by a single variable and only address that variable.

This also doesn't account for pay discrepancies that are based on higher negotiated offers, different educational/experience background, or other such factors. The same job title does not necessarily mean the same job or quality of work.

There is already procedural mechanisms for women to address gender discrimination in the work force. So, if politicians would like to address the social stigma women carry as being the primary caregiver or perceived as a witch for demanding a higher salary in negotiations, I am all for it. I am not for assuming that Jane and John are paid differently purely based on the fact that Jane is a Jane and penalizing employers for that assumption. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

BitBit, my assumption is that same job/tasks/performance should = same pay

doesnt matter if she chooses to leave the work force later on to care for children or chooses to work part time (where pro rate rate would apply). if 2 people are performing the same tasks equally then equal basic pay should apply

of course is one person then chooses to negotiate a higher rate then thats a different issue but equal minimum pay rate for all sexes/same job should apply is my thoughts 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

The leaving the work force is more of a counter to the national factoid of women earning 77 cents for every male dollar, which is one of the bases for the bill (general assumption that the figure is derived from discrimination instead of shorter periods in the workforce).

As to the same job/tasks/performance, yes it should equal the same pay assuming that the candidates entered with the same level of experience or education.

If candidate 1 and candidate 2 apply for the same position, but the second candidate has more experience they will likely be offered a higher starting salary. If a blanket federal law mandates the same pay for the same position based on gender, then the company that hired them is guilty of gender discrimination, when they paid based on value of the employee in front of them.
I just think it is too attenuated to have such a broad clause or such an obtuse remedy for what is a multifaceted problem. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

If candidate 1 and candidate 2 ....

i also think we are thinking about two different work forces. for me this bill will protect those in retail/service/sales/labour-factory/min wage as my experience with women in middle+ management/executive positions are that they are usually in a position to ensure/negotiate they receive market renumeration for their services


it is too attenuated to have such a broad clause or such an obtuse remedy for what is a multifaceted problem

you have been dying to use these words in a sentence for ages havent you lol :) 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

It is a multifaceted problem. Currently, don't companies just pay a fine if they are "sued" or whatever for gender discrimination? A one time fee, I believe.

Women are more willing to accept a lower paying job than men are... so businesses take advantage of this.

"Why do you think [male-dominated industries] are sex-segregated?" says Terry O'Neill, president of the National Organization for Women. "Very often women aren't welcome there." Real or perceived, discrimination in certain sectors could discourage women from seeking employment there. A dearth of role models might, in turn, influence the next generation of girls to gravitate toward lower-paying fields, creating an unfortunate cycle.

Read more: http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1983185,00.html#ixzz15rcwwTFH

- Time Magazine

Time magazine also goes on to say that men who transitioned to women earned, on average, 32% less after the surgery. Women who became men, on the other hand, earned 1.5% more.

Read more: http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1983185,00.html#ixzz15rdAOVTL

So that definitely shows discrimination. 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

Women are more willing to accept a lower paying job than men are... so businesses take advantage of this
Well that would be more the individuals problem then the companies. If a woman is not willing to negotiate a bigger salary then she obviously is happy with what she is making. If you dont like what your making then change it. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

If candidate 1 and candidate 2 apply for the same position, but the second candidate has more experience they will likely be offered a higher starting salary. If a blanket federal law mandates the same pay for the same position based on gender, then the company that hired them is guilty of gender discrimination, when they paid based on value of the employee in front of them.

You are taking a great leap of faith in giving businesses credit to pay equally. It is so easy to say, "while they hired a male and a female for the same job, the female is not making as much in salary as the male because the male had more experience. It has nothing to do with her gender." And who would be able to question them? They could sue the company. But without a law to protect them and their worth, they wouldn't get much. This bill protects women, in the same way people are protected from race discrimination. It is necessary, unfortunately. 

Green Chick --- 16 years ago -

Collins argued that the bill would place undue burden on small business, and "impose increased costs and restrictions on small businesses in an already difficult economic climate."

I think this shows responsibility on their part to not further burden businesses that are on the brink of bankruptcy in a slow economy. It does not automatically mean they think women should make less than men. It seems to me like it was not supported because it was a bad idea at the time. Not necessarily a bad idea, period. 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

This is new to me because I have never had an issue with getting paid differently than a male coworker.
I didnt even realize there WASNT a bill out there that protected equal pay rights for women.
Huh. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

Collins argued that the bill would place undue burden on small business, and "impose increased costs and restrictions on small businesses in an already difficult economic climate."


I think this shows irresponsibility on their part to burden female employees with lower wages then their male counterparts, especially when nearly everyone is on the brink of bankruptcy in a slow economy.

Fixed it for ya ;) 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

i also think we are thinking about two different work forces. for me this bill will protect those in retail/service/sales/labour-factory/min wage as my experience with women in middle+ management/executive positions are that they are usually in a position to ensure/negotiate they receive market renumeration for their services



We are talking about two different workforces, but this bill will treat those two workforces the same, which is why I have an issue with it. If you are talking about minimum wage positions, then that should be across the board and pay discrepancies blatant. However, after looking at the provisions of the bill, that isn't the specific targeted cross-section. It is over-inclusive in application.


Sofaa, I think you are muddling societal convention with discrimination. Here is one study that seems to indicate that, barring other variables such as time out for child cares and assuming an similar education levels, women earned the same or more than male counterparts.
http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1983185,00.html#ixzz15rdAOVTL


I think my issue is that a business should be penalized for an individual's choices. I think is sucks that women gravitate away from male dominated industries because fewer role models. I think it REALLY sucks that a man demanding a high salary is a go getter whereas a woman is a ball-buster for demanding the same thing.

I don't think that over-inclusive, poorly written legislation is the answer to those problems though. I would rather see more grants/scholarships encouraging women to enter those fields or programs for girls to learn that they can ask for more money. I think the legislation as it stands is stagnantly retroactive rather than proactive so it doesn't address the underlying issues.

I also think the some of the numbers used to support wage discrimination are not accurate.

This report is really interesting to me:

http://www.consad.com/content/reports/Gender%20Wage%20Gap%20Final%20Report.pdf 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

This is new to me because I have never had an issue with getting paid differently than a male coworker.

Well that is good. Did you discuss your wages with fellow male employees? We always had to sign contracts saying we wouldn't discuss our wages with other employees. We of course did, on occasion. What I found was 9 times out of ten, in all the restaurant/retail service jobs I have worked in, males were started off at a higher wage then I was. It is a REAL problem. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

didnt walmart have a pay discrimination class action against them a year or so ago???

off to lookie:

found it
Wal-Mart had for the most part failed to dispute the plaintiffs evidence that women were paid less than men in every region and in most job categories; that the salary gap widens over time even for employees hired into the same jobs

the class action also included the discrepancy between male & female management postions but im ignoring that for now to keep it in the equal job should = equal pay argument 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

You are taking a great leap of faith in giving businesses credit to pay equally. It is so easy to say, "while they hired a male and a female for the same job, the female is not making as much in salary as the male because the male had more experience. It has nothing to do with her gender." And who would be able to question them? They could sue the company. But without a law to protect them and their worth, they wouldn't get much. This bill protects women, in the same way people are protected from race discrimination. It is necessary, unfortunately.

I am not taking a great leap of faith, I think you are over-simplfying by a very large margin. There already are procedural mechanisms to address perceived or actual discrimination in the workforce. A company would have to show the experience based decision to hire.

If one employee is less qualified than another, that person's salary should reflect that...regardless of age, gender, race, nationality or other factors. If you want to address the underlying social issues, terrific, but do that in a proactive manner and not one that holds individual businesses liable for long-ingrained societal perceptions. 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

didnt walmart have a pay discrimination class action against them a year or so ago???

off to lookie:

found it
Wal-Mart had for the most part failed to dispute the plaintiffs evidence that women were paid less than men in every region and in most job categories; that the salary gap widens over time even for employees hired into the same jobs

the class action also included the discrepancy between male & female management postions but im ignoring that for now to keep it in the equal job should = equal pay arguement



I am not saying that discrimination doesn't exist, please understand that isn't it at all. I am saying that the bill in question is over-inclusive in its reach and frankly redundant as shown by the Walmart example. The afflicted employees were able to bring suit and remedy the discrimination (or at least receive monetary compensation from prior infliction).

But I should add, that even the Walmart example may go towards some of the variables I was referencing. I personally think that Walmart is evil incarnate and treat ALL of their employees like crap. However, the discrepancy widening over time may not be solely attributable to gender discrimination as it might be to the male manager demanding a raise, where the female is afraid to do the same. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

I am not taking a great leap of faith, I think you are over-simplfying by a very large margin. There already are procedural mechanisms to address perceived or actual discrimination in the workforce. A company would have to show the experience based decision to hire.

If one employee is less qualified than another, that person's salary should reflect that...regardless of age, gender, race, nationality or other factors. If you want to address the underlying social issues, terrific, but do that in a proactive manner and not one that holds individual businesses liable for long-ingrained societal perceptions. 


All I am hearing, is you feel it should be at the businesses discretion whether or not to pay equally. There is hardly anything at all protecting female workers from a discriminative wage. In a minimum wage position, as in others I am sure, you are not allowed to discuss your wages with other employees. Ignorance is bliss, right?

in a perfect world, If one employee is less qualified than another, that person's salary should reflect that...regardless of age, gender, race, nationality or other factors. But unfortunately all those prejudices still exist, and they need to be addressed with legislation. Passing this bill would have been a huge step in the right direction. 

BitBit --- 16 years ago -

If that is all you are hearing, then you are not reading what I wrote properly. Are you completely ignoring the Equal Pay Act, or any of the other tort reforms that address these issues? I am not disregarding anything of what you are saying other than to note that it isn't 100% correct or correlative.

I would be in favor of a bill that required employers to disclose pay if requested to do so by an employee. Most employers do not do so because when an individual learns a co-worker is making more they usually are upset and want equal pay, which is understandable. However, that employee may be demanding equal pay when they are not an equal employee (read experience, education, or even performance).

I think discrimination is wretched and shouldn't be tolerated. However, I do not think this bill is remotely close to hitting the mark for remedying any actual discrimination or the underlying issues. 

Just Sayin --- 16 years ago -

Sidetracking for a moment, but ...
@Sofaa,

In an attempt to belittle Republicans you obviously don't have the full picture, i.e. if other initiatives were attached to it that they decided to vote the whole thing down. Where were you when the Republicans voted against the new bill for the military; it was voted down completely because the Dems attached the repeal of the DADT to it. Unless you're actually in the work force and is personally affecting your way of life this is just a sad attempt to talk down the Republican party.

As a Liberal you should take a page from your Liberal manifesto before talking down the vote against one bill. Last I checked Dems are in charge and this country is spiraling downwards financially, morally, and otherwise. You can't "blame" Bush because if obama was a great as you talked him up to be then this country's problems would be *solved*.

Furthermore, as you legally don't have the right to vote your opinion really is just hot air. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground