Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Question!?!

who's talking here?

CourtesyFlush 5
Mommeee Drest 2
ALS MommaKitty 2
MRMBR 1
YeaOk 2
Colonel LizZoo 2
Karma32 2
Taminator 2
Melissa 5
JAZZ 2
Lula Belle 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

My sister just told me that My 4 year old nephew's teachers are telling her that he is to young for school. And that he will just have to return next year. They are saying he has a hard time listening. MY sister and her MIL works with him on listening. School just started last week.. doesn't he need time to adjust. I thought school was supposed to teach listening skills as well as academics. Am I right or can they just tell her he can't go to school?? Any advice?? 

Lula Belle --- 16 years ago -

I started school when I was five, but there were still a lot of four year olds in my class. I'm also pretty sure no kid listens on they're very first week of school. He may not be use to other adults giving him instructions yet. It takes time! 

Karma32 --- 16 years ago -

Is the 4 year old in Kindergarten? I would say that the best bet is to go try and talk with the teacher and ask for a few more weeks to see if he can adjust. And, after trying longer then a week he is still having a hard time in the class room that maybe going next year would be the best thing for him, 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

See that is what I told her. The teachers are telling her he doesn't listen. But That is what teachers are for... to teach!!! I think they are being lazy and just don't want to mess with him. MY sister doesn't like confrontation so she won't say anything. NOt sure what to tell her. 

Karma32 --- 16 years ago -

There are only 2 things to do then. Tell her these are the choices.. 1. go to the school and talk, no it isn't easy to go and confront someone, but if she feels he is ready for school some things are worth the fight. 2. He stays home for another year and she works on his listening skills.. maybe there is a group she can put him in, a sport or something where he has to listen to other adults that will help him for next year. 

MRMBR --- 16 years ago -

When does he turn 5? Many of the "younger" kids in states like CA are not mature enough to start K when they are 4, despite making the official cut off. I watched one little girl do it when my daughter did, and they passed her (even though she should have repeated) and she struggled a ton in 1st grade (her bday was in the fall). I have another friend that kept her son back a year and he did K when he was 6, and it was for sure the best decision for that particular child. It is not uncommon for the younger ones to need to repeat K. There are definitely kids that are ready and are on the young end, but especially with boys, the maturity often isn't there. If it's an issue of the teacher not doing her job/ trying to take the easy way out, that's one thing, but if the child truly isn't ready, it can be very beneficial for some kids, to wait the extra year. Doing another year of preschool is an option, which allows time for the child to mature, as well as an environment where he could be working on the social skills required in school, such as listening, waiting their turn, etc. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

4 is young to start kinder, most students are smart enough but just not mature enough for the challenge and will end up repeating kinder the next year. My daughter was 4 1/2 when she started school last year (since this state goes to December for the cut-off, most states cut-off is September) but was put into a 2 year kinder program by the school because they wanted what was best for her academically. She did well last year and starts normal kinder this year.

She will still graduate at 18 and instead of being held back, having issues in class or being stressed out to young because she isn't emotionally ready (something that cant be rushed) she will be able to move at a normal rate. Not to mention she will be set to what more the 90% of the country is set at (only a handful of states make their cut-off past September).

Instead of assuming they are being lazy or wrong you might to try listening to teachers with experience who are only trying to make sure the child is not set up for failure. 

Taminator --- 16 years ago -

Sorry dont mean to thread steal but it seems like some of you really know about the age thing so I just wanted to ask
My daughter was born in Nov and is 6 months older then my niece that was born in May, are they going to be able to be in the same class? My sister and I were always in the same class (twins lol)so we want our girls to always have each other in school. 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

Yes Tammy they can. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

I was in the same class as kids born in May and I was born in November. You'll just have to wait until your kid is 5 almost 6 before starting Kindergarten (which isn't a bad thing). 

Taminator --- 16 years ago -

Thanks! 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

Melissa... here is another thing to consider: The teacher sees about 20-30 kids in her class every single year. She knows what she is looking for, and the signs she needs to watch out for to tell her that one of them might not be ready. Why in the world would you or your sister get mad that the teacher is thinking what is best for the little boy? What is the rush? Myabe put him in pre-school for a year and then see if he is ready for K. Just my thought. Remember, my opinion as the parent may not always be the same opinion as the teacher. I think they have more knowledge about certain things and are just going off of those things they know. She isn't trying to target the boy. 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

I would sit down with the teacher and have a meeting and maybe ask her for 2 weeks. My son had a hard time adjusting at first too, but he finally got used to the schedule and everything worked out. However there were multiple kids that the teachers thought should have been taken out of kindergarten and they were not. They struggled the entire year and will struggle even more in 1st grade. California kindergarten is pretty academic from what I have seen and I have read many studies that say academic kindergarten for boys is counterproductive if they arent ready because of their maturity level. She needs to do what's best for her son and in the end if that is waiting that is what she needs to do. The teachers know what's best for the child in most cases. 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

Melissa... here is another thing to consider: The teacher sees about 20-30 kids in her class every single year. She knows what she is looking for, and the signs she needs to watch out for to tell her that one of them might not be ready. Why in the world would you or your sister get mad that the teacher is thinking what is best for the little boy? What is the rush? Myabe put him in pre-school for a year and then see if he is ready for K. Just my thought. Remember, my opinion as the parent may not always be the same opinion as the teacher. I think they have more knowledge about certain things and are just going off of those things they know. She isn't trying to target the boy.

They only gave him 4 days to adjust and the teacher only has him from 7:00am to 10:30am. I am sorry that isn't enough time to know if he will excel in Pre-k. I am not mad at anyone... neither is my sister. I just think he wasn't given enough time. That was my point 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

They only gave him 4 days to adjust and the teacher only has him from 7:00am to 10:30am. I am sorry that isn't enough time to know if he will excel in Pre-k. I am not mad at anyone... neither is my sister. I just think he wasn't given enough time. That was my point

So this is Pre-k? 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

So this is Pre-k?

Yeah, and it isn't cali schools. They live in Oklahoma. I just think That Pre-school is used to get kids ready for school. Am I right??? 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

So this is Pre-k?

I just re-read the original comment and nowhere does it say kindergarten. Not sure where I got that. Melissa, if this is Pre-K... then NO, you guys are right. I would not take him out. You are correct, that this is the time/grade where he will learn how to be a proper student and listen. If it is Pre-k, then the teacher might not want to deal with him. If it is K, then I think he should be removed. 

JAZZ --- 16 years ago -

They only gave him 4 days to adjust and the teacher only has him from 7:00am to 10:30am. I am sorry that isn't enough time to know if he will excel in Pre-k. I am not mad at anyone... neither is my sister. I just think he wasn't given enough time. That was my point

OH i also assumed you were talking about kindergarten. This is Preschool. I know with preschool since it is an option and not really necessary to the school then a lot of times when they feel a child is going to be a distraction they can chooses not have him/her in their class. I do understand how you say it is just the first week. Seems to me like they would give him more time. 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

No, it is not kindergarten. That is what I thought that Pre-K is where kids learn the basics. That is all I wanted to know and if it was wrong for the teachers to tell her he is too young. 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

Ok scratch the whole entire thread. Everybody thought since you said school this was kindergarten. 

YeaOk --- 16 years ago -

I would listen to the teacher.
Keep him back a year and work on the listening.


Melissa... here is another thing to consider: The teacher sees about 20-30 kids in her class every single year. She knows what she is looking for, and the signs she needs to watch out for to tell her that one of them might not be ready.

I agree

Also if the teacher is having to repeatedly ask your sister's child to listen or do some thing, that can be very disruptive to the rest of the class. My daughter went to kinder when she was 4. She did very well. BUT if her teacher would have ever mentioned she was not ready i would have pulled her out, worked on the issues the teacher mentioned and sent her the next year. IMO teachers know best most times. the parents are not their in the class room to supervise 100 percent of the time. some kids also act differently when away from home, and with a different authority figure. good luck to your sister though! 

JAZZ --- 16 years ago -

Ok scratch the whole entire thread. Everybody thought since you said school this was kindergarten.

I know right?! lol..i thought so too from reading the comments but now going back and reading her post she says nothing about kindergarten. 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

I know right?! lol..i thought so too from reading the comments but now going back and reading her post she says nothing about kindergarten.

Yeah I know. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

Wow...that changes everything!

Pre-K is where they learn to listen. Y'all need to sit with the teacher in a conference and work out a plan of action for the little guy. Listen to the teacher, because she'll have some insights you guys won't have, but use your own judgement as well. If it becomes a problem, ask to have him switched to a different class. Some kids just don't jive with certain teachers. 

YeaOk --- 16 years ago -

O!, ooops i thought you were tlking about kinder too! IMO, I would try keep him in pre k! i would ask the teacher to keep him in a few more weeks and see how it goes. And maybe even try sending him to a different pre k. if that doesnt work then he probably just isnt ready for it yet. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

If its pre-k then I would sit down with the teacher and make a plan for the child rather then just removing him. If the teacher is unwilling either ask for another class or find another pre-k because that's what it is for. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help
rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground