Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Spanish judge issues arrest warrants for 3 U.S. soldiers

who's talking here?

EastCoast 1
MandaBabyy 2
Tits McGee 1
Mama22Angels 1
csusbchick 1
BadMomma 1
SierraFoxtrot 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

i hope to god that the US looks after these guys


http://edition.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/07/29/spain.us.troops/index.html

Spanish judge issued arrest warrants for three U.S. soldiers on Thursday in connection with the death of a Spanish TV cameraman in Iraq in 2003, reopening a long-running legal battle, according to a copy of the court order viewed by CNN.

The judge, National Court Investigating Magistrate Santiago Pedraz, indicted the three U.S. soldiers in April 2007, alleging they were linked to U.S. tank fire directed against the Palestine Hotel in 2003, where Spanish cameraman Jose Couso was videotaping the U.S. assault on Baghdad. Couso died from his wounds shortly afterward.

But in 2008, other National Court judges closed the case, citing lack of evidence. The cameraman's family appealed to Spain's Supreme Court, which recently ruled the case could proceed after all.

That led to Pedraz issuing the arrest warrants for the three soldiers Thursday. The three, identified as Philip de Camp, Phillip Wolford and Thomas Gibson, were assigned to the U.S. 3rd Infantry, based in Fort Stewart, Georgia.

In addition to Couso, the tank fire on April 8, 2003, in Baghdad also killed a Reuters cameraman, Ukrainian-born Taras Protsyuk.

Couso's family and some journalists have blamed the U.S. military, saying they should have known the Palestine Hotel, a tall structure in Baghdad, was a base for journalists, not combatants.

The then U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell said American troops fired only after receiving hostile fire from the hotel and the matter received the highest attention, from former President George W. Bush and the Spanish Prime Minister at the time Jose Maria Aznar.

Couso's lawyer has previously said it would be difficult to put the soldiers -- the tank commander, a sergeant, and a superior officer -- on trial in Spain. The Pentagon, faced with similar charges from other national courts in the past, has not turned over American soldiers.

Earlier in the long legal battle, a three-judge panel at the National Court in 2006 ruled that Spain had no jurisdiction in the case. The judges ruled that U.S. troops thought they were firing on Iraqis at the hotel serving as spotters for Iraqi artillery fire aimed at American troops, and that the civilian deaths were not intentional.
 

EastCoast --- 16 years ago -

:-( I hope so too. I guess the only comfort is that the Pentagon has not ever turned over soldiers to foreign nations.

I dont understand their case. He was in a war zone, caught in a bad spot and its the three soldiers' faults...?? I think not. He knew there was a war going on. He chose to go. Sh*t happens. 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

IMO?
This judge wants to set a precence for the War on Terror.
This judge doesn't agree with this war, so he wants the world to believe the same.
In his eyes, if he gets these guys, it will make people see that the U.S. is nothing but a power hungry, nosy older brother. 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

Someone above these guys had to make the order to fire. Soooo why isn't that guys asss in the frying pan as well?

IMO.... I don't think the US will be turning these guys over. I don't think Spain has any right to press charges or issue warrants for the arrest of these three soldiers. I think this guy just has a lot of heat on him by the family of this camera man and possibly others and he's doing what he "thinks" he can do to save his asss! 

csusbchick --- 16 years ago -

This judge wants to set a precence for the War on Terror.
This judge doesn't agree with this war, so he wants the world to believe the same.
In his eyes, if he gets these guys, it will make people see that the U.S. is nothing but a power hungry, nosy older brother. 


I agree with you on this. Maybe the Spaniards are getting a little ballsy now that they finally won a World Cup LMAO!

But seriously, the judge is making seeking fame by making a name for himself doing cases like these. 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

Of COURSE they aren't intentional. Civilians die in every war (unfortunately) and the troops can NOT be charged.. That's ridiculous. 

SierraFoxtrot --- 16 years ago -

Civilians die in every war (unfortunately) and the troops can NOT be charged

I am ONLY playing devils advocate here, not trying to start drama. But I want to ask... What if we had a war on our soil. Would you say the same thing? If there was war in your hometown and someone you knew died as a civilian casualty, would you say "don't blame the invading troops, they're just doing their job"? 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

I am ONLY playing devils advocate here, not trying to start drama. But I want to ask... What if we had a war on our soil. Would you say the same thing? If there was war in your hometown and someone you knew died as a civilian casualty, would you say "don't blame the invading troops, they're just doing their job"?

Well the real situation wouldn't be what you said.. It would be what if an American journalist/reporter was in Country A while Country B was invading Country A. So yes, I would feel like if that journalist specifically went to the country being invaded to cover the news there.. then they are putting themselves in danger. If that's a risk that the journalist wants to take, so be it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground