Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Do You Agree With This Law? I see nothing wrong with it.

who's talking here?

Mon Cheri 1
Heather 1
CaliMommie 1
Mommeee Drest 7
B*Bright 2
San Antonio Bound 1
valerie - palomina.etsy.com 1
ALS MommaKitty 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 10
♥LovingJ 3
Lebowski 3
El Doosho 2
MandaBabyy 2
BitBit 1
βo§§ L@dγ 7
merryinmemphis 1
Spork Fight 18
HisWifey13 1
Samantha 1
Mama22Angels 17

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

merryinmemphis --- 16 years ago -

Arizona police will have the right to stop anyone on "reasonable suspicion" that they may be an illegal immigrant and can arrest them if they are not carrying a valid driver's license or identity papers.  

valerie - palomina.etsy.com --- 16 years ago -

So basically this law gives them permission to pull over anyone that looks Mexican. Yeah....I don't think that's going to go over well. 

Lebowski --- 16 years ago -

"reasonable suspicion" that they may be an illegal immigrant and can arrest them So basically this law gives them permission to pull over anyone that looks Mexican. Not what was said, you twisted it.... 

Samantha --- 16 years ago -

I think if someone looks illegal they should have the right to pull them over. It doesn't matter if they're Mexican, European, Canadian, Chinese, or whatever, if they're illegal, then they're illegal. 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

I don't think it's a bad idea.... If they are doing something that draws the attention of a police officer and they get stopped and don't have proper paperwork then yea they should be detained. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

apparently in texas at the walmart the cops go around in civilian clothes and can ask people for their license or papers, etc...they dont show their badge til they ask you...not sure if its legal or not but it does happen...my uncle had it happen to him...but hes legal...anywho so i dont see why this law would be any different....and they do it at airports too for potential terrorists...if thry can do it one place why not another?? but what does an illegal immigrant (or terrorist) look like anyways?? lol... 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

Honestly I don't give a rat's ass what they do as far as this law is concerned. I don't live there and if you get pulled over just because you look illegal, but have authentic documention to prove that you are a legal citizen then so what. If you get pulled over and fail to show papers or whatever they want then adios! You didn't belong here anyway. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

dp... 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

I think it sucks bc ppl will never know if they are going to get pulled over for doing nothing. Also...it seems like it is just another thing that constantly keeps people looking over their shoulder from "tha man." BUT....if someone isnt a criminal, isnt doing anything wrong, and has nothing to hide....then it shouldnt be a problem lol. So....if I have to be annoyed bc of potentially being "harassed" by "tha man" when it is not warranted.....I can deal with that if it means that someone who isnt following the rules can get caught an off the streets...then so be it. I would rather them pull over 50 non offenders in order to catch that one who is illegal, or worse, a violent criminal etc. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

how many people who are ok with this law actually hispanic? I totally disagree with this law. i cant tell you how many times we were pulled over for bs driving from tx to ca... they always look at my husband all suspiciously and demand his license, and then back track when the see the mil id peeking out of his wallet. its disgusting, and i feel this is a huge back step from all the work that people have done to prevent racial profiling. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

how many people who are ok with this law actually hispanic? I am and have family in AZ. I don't really look hispanic, but I am. Also, as Priv8 said if you have nothing to hide and the only thing you have to really worry about is maybe getting "harrassed" by "da man" then so be it. I can handle that. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

how many people who are ok with this law actually hispanic? I totally disagree with this law. i cant tell you how many times we were pulled over for bs driving from tx to ca... they always look at my husband all suspiciously and demand his license, and then back track when the see the mil id peeking out of his wallet. its disgusting, and i feel this is a huge back step from all the work that people have done to prevent racial profiling. But....as annoying and "rude" or "racially upsetting" that is. Wouldnt it be great to know that if they happened to pull someone over who had warrants or was a violent offender was off the streets? I know there are plenty of cases where they cant do anything to people who are known to be suspicious bc they have no probable cause to pull them over or bother them etc. This pretty much takes that out of the picture. They can investigate "suspicious" people without having to get cause first. Intrusive of peoples privacy???YES. Pretty much necessary in this day in age??? I am leaning towards yes. And again....once they see you have nothing to hide or are doing nothing wrong.... they let you go right? So momentary embarassment or a twinge of feeling racially profiled and violated then let go....is it really that bad? 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

I like having these types of adult conversations lol....without all the "you are fat lazy and an idiot" comments....but I have to leave :( I wish I could stay to hear more points of view. Maybe later ladies. :) 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

if you dont look hispanic, then obviously they wont profile you.. my husband looks hispanic, even though he is half mexican, and half jewish. he doesnt even speak spanish. people have a right to travel without being harassed by the police. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

is it really that bad? I don't think it is. Now if there's something you've got to hide and don't want to be pulled oer becuase you look suspicious, then don't drive in AZ. Pretty simple fix, yes? 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

if thats the case priv, then why dont they just pull over everyone? heck lets have stop points at all major intersections to make sure everyone doesnt have warrants. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

if you dont look hispanic, then obviously they wont profile you.. my husband looks hispanic, even though he is half mexican, and half jewish. he doesnt even speak spanish. people have a right to travel without being harassed by the police. Actually it is if you dont look like your illegal they wont profile you.....which begs the question....why are you assuming that everyone who is illegal is mexican? That right there is you racially profiling yourself. It is easy to do huh. I think this law is less of a "lets pull over people who look hispanic" than a loophole to get around probable cause. They can now just wait for someone to hop in their car to pull them over. I think it is more of a loophole for the government to have more power to just detain you or question you whenever they want without cause, than it is a racial profiling thing. I mean really....they could pull anyone over and say they think they are illegal. No matter what their race. Someone looking "illegal" is all in the eye of the beyholder. So whomever the officer feels like targeting that day is the one that will get pulled over....not just mexicans. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

if you dont look hispanic, then obviously they wont profile you. Okay, so what you REALLY want to know is who LOOKS hispanic. Also, you know that it doesn't just mean that you have to look hispanic to be pulled over, right? 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

if you dont look hispanic, then obviously they wont profile you.. my husband looks hispanic, even though he is half mexican, and half jewish. he doesnt even speak spanish. people have a right to travel without being harassed by the police. My husband is not hispanic AT ALL but he looks like he is. We have hispanic friends who swore up and downt hey thought he was. I can see your point of view as well but like Priv-8 and walter said.... If you ahev nothing to hide then there shouldn't be a problem. No matter what you do there will always be racial profiling. There will always be stereo-types.... 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

i wont anymore, because i no longer live in tx.. but in order to visit home we used to have to... we dontt have anything to hide (k maybe there was one time when we bought fireworks in nm) but how do you think it made my husband feel being pulled over for nothing? (they said they pulled him over for not using his blinker or some dumb crap like that, but he always uses his blinkers). he has deployed 2 times to iraq, a year each. he was born here, but because now it is basically a crime to look mexican, he gets pulled over. 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

Actually it is if you dont look like your illegal they wont profile you.....which begs the question....why are you assuming that everyone who is illegal is mexican? That right there is you racially profiling yourself. It is easy to do huh Good point.... and I agree 100%.... Someone can be from Ireland or Russia and be illegal... or hell even Canada!LOL.... I think they are just making this law as well to get around the whole probable cause thing. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

And I fully agree that people should have the right to travel without being harassed. But...this day in age with crime running rampant it seems that the government has to intervene more and more into peoples privacy in order to maintain peace. It is sad bc so many law abiding citizens are now put out there for un warranted scrutiny...but....if they are not doing anything wrong...then it should be a problem. A little wrong and annoying...yes....but really not that huge of a problem if it is better for the greater good of the community that people are living in. 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

but because now it is basically a crime to look mexican, he gets pulled over. Did the officer say this? Or was it just your impression that you got? Maybe he did actually forget to use his blinker.... I have been stopped for that. I was discriminated against in Hawaii. I am white.... and because I am white I was treated differently there. It happens everywhere to all races. Like I said it is an ongoing battle that no one will EVER win. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

no sh*t walter, but this law is targeting hispanics, who may be here illegally, or in some cases, innocent people. if you dont look hispanic (as you said you dont)the chances of you getting profiled as an illegal go drastically down. 

Mama22Angels --- 16 years ago -

Ditto Priv8! I would rather be safe than sorry.... this unwarranted stops could uncover SERIOUS criminals.... could uncover drug and sex trafficers. It could really help out with the raising crime rates in urban areas. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

you have got to be a complete numb skull to believe that Canadians will be pulled over as result of this law... lets just throw out that argument in this case. last i checked, its kind of hard to profile canadians, put them in a room with a bunch of other white people and you cant tell them apart.. 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

so then lets do what i said, traffic stops at all major intersections... everyone must stop,.. whoop whoop no privacy! everyone must have an id on them at all times, give dna samples, and finger prints.. hey it helps find drug smugglers, and sex traffickers 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

but how do you think it made my husband feel being pulled over for nothing? (they said they pulled him over for not using his blinker or some dumb crap like that, but he always uses his blinkers). he has deployed 2 times to Iraq, a year each. he was born here, but because now it is basically a crime to look Mexican, he gets pulled over. It might make him feel bad...or it might make him feel safe? Knowing that people are out patrolling and protecting his rights. He doesn't want people to be here illegally when he is here legally right? So I would think he would be able to swallow his pride for a moment and respect the fact that they are doing their job protecting the law abiding citizens. I am sure that in Iraq he has had to pull over or detain some people who "looked" as if they were involved in terrorist activities etc. Not everyone was guilty...but they had to make sure right? And...it kept them safer. if anyhthing....you would think with your husbands experience fighting for America and for peoples freedoms...that he can understand and respect what laws we have to impose here. And again....YOU are the one who is saying that everyone who looks illegal is Mexican. YOU are racially profiling by reading into the statement of "illegal" to mean "Mexican" Don't you find that to be wrong? If everyone screamed racism or discrimination for every little thing....we would be fighting about things constantly. It is ridiculous. If you, someone who feels persecution for being Hispanic, cannot even open your mind to the fact that illegal can mean anyone and not just Mexicans...then I can understand why you would think that every officer or even the government as a whole cant either. You are mistaking though. Not everyone sees illegal as Mexican. You are making an issue about something that really doesn't need to be made an issue. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

so then lets do what i said, traffic stops at all major intersections... everyone must stop,.. whoop whoop no privacy! everyone must have an id on them at all times, give dna samples, and finger prints.. hey it helps find drug smugglers, and sex traffickers Ok. And how do u suppose they pay for this? EXACTLY they wont be able to. However...by makeing a loophole in the law and calling it "anyone who looks illegal" they can still pretty much pull over anyone at anytime. And...it doesnt really cost anything more. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

ok now i really have to go. we will continue later. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground