Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

His or Her vs Their

who's talking here?

PeachyKeene 3
Kristy 1
miasmama12 1
Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey 2
*nEw yOrK* 1
MrsAdventures 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

MrsAdventures --- 16 years ago -

My sister is a senior in HS and sent me her paper to proofread. Now it's been umm 5 years since I took an English class so I'm a bit rusty. Anywho, she keeps writing "his or her" or "he or she" in her sentences. Shouldn't this be their, they etc? Example: "To begin his or her business, a massage therapist has to first find a building to rent or own to work out of." "Although the freedom of choosing whom and when a license massage therapist gives a massage is the appealing factor that really keeps him or her self employed' 

MrsAdventures --- 16 years ago -

bump for the grammar team! 

*nEw yOrK* --- 16 years ago -

im taking english now and in certain situations you have to be more specific..which would be using the his and her... saying their is to general.. but you have to specify the man and woman ... 

MrsAdventures --- 16 years ago -

Ok thanks! It's just in almost every sentence so I wasn't sure. She is writing a paper about Massage Therapy. The paragraph I am on now is discussing the items you would need to purchase. I didn't want to have her change it if she is on the correct path. She is an "A" student after all and graduating early. I don't know why she is having her 3.0 sister proofread her paper! lol 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

She is an "A" student after all and graduating early. I don't know why she is having her 3.0 sister proofread her paper! lol haha. Only advice I can give....if it is in almost every sentence she might want to think about reforming some of her sentences. Variety will get higher marks than repeatition. Some of the sentences might even benefit from ommitting the "his or her" altogether. 

Kristy --- 16 years ago -

back when I was in school we used him or he when we did not know the gender specific but now you have to use him or her etc. 

PeachyKeene --- 16 years ago -

Example: "To begin his or her business, a massage therapist has to first find a building to rent or own to work out of." I would say: "To begin one's business, a massage therapist has to first find a building to rent or own to work out of." "Although the freedom of choosing whom and when a license massage therapist gives a massage is the appealing factor that really keeps him or her self employed' I just dont like this sentence structure.. I cant think of a way to reword it.. but she is trying to use too many words to just say that Massage therapists probably stay self employed because they can choose who to give a massage to and when.. Which IMO in her opinion. If this is a factual paper, she should take that sentence out. Everytime I have ever made myself or my husband a massage apppointment, *I* picked the time.. not the therapist. And the therapist for that matter didnt look me up and down and say "no Im not going to be touching you.." Know what Im saying? 

miasmama12 --- 16 years ago -

his or her is very exeptable but I agree with Peachy to you one's every once in a while 

PeachyKeene --- 16 years ago -

Just make sure she keeps the entire paper in the same tense. She can't say "he did...." and then "he is going to..." If the paper is past tense, then make sure there is no "future" tense in it. 

Priv8_Hug-H8R_4Lifey --- 16 years ago -

Just make sure she keeps the entire paper in the same tense. She can't say "he did...." and then "he is going to..." If the paper is past tense, then make sure there is no "future" tense in it. Very true. I also didn't really like the structure of that first sentence. For me the end should be something along the lines of "they first need to decide where they want to work." or where they want to operate. Then go on to give the choices....such as owning, renting, or the choice to partner with a salon and pay a percentage for using the space. 

MrsAdventures --- 16 years ago -

Thanks everyone! This is her Senior Career Project which is a factual paper about the industry you intend to work in. 

PeachyKeene --- 16 years ago -

I also didn't really like the structure of that first sentence. For me the end should be something along the lines of "they first need to decide where they want to work." or where they want to operate. Then go on to give the choices....such as owning, renting, or the choice to partner with a salon and pay a percentage for using the space. Ohh I like that idea better! Sorry, my brain is still fuzzy ... but setting it up this way would give her more to talk about in her paper, and it would have a better structure. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground